Tuesday, August 21, 2018
Top News App

Florida man sues for $2.8 million fishing tournament prize money

OCEAN CITY, Md. — Phil Heasley of Naples caught the fish of his life, but the $2.8 million in tournament prize money got away.

Heasley reeled in a 6-foot white marlin last year off Maryland’s coast. But in a sign of how concerned some big money tournaments are about cheating, officials made him and his crew take lie detector tests. The officials said all four men failed.

Heasley is now in a protracted court battle over the winnings and his crew’s reputation, pitting their integrity against that of one of the world’s most lucrative angling contests.

The white-haired CEO of a financial software company had motored with his crew into the Atlantic before sunrise on a Tuesday in August in his 68-foot fishing boat, the Kallianassa, to compete in the 2016 White Marlin Open.

About 65 miles out, they zeroed in on a fast-moving school of skipjack tuna, according to transcripts from the nine-day trial. One of the mates quickly hooked a marlin. The captain maneuvered the boat, and Heasley worked the reel.

The avid fisherman said he fought the famously acrobatic species for about 10 minutes. The blue-finned fish was "running like mad" and leaping to dislodge the hook.

Hanging from the tournament scale in Ocean City, the white marlin turned out to be relatively scrawny, weighing in at 76.5 pounds — not far over the 70-pound qualifying weight and nearly 20 pounds lighter than the 2015 winner.

"I did not think that we had a fish that was going to win some great big amount of money," Heasley said on the witness stand.

The marlin wasn’t even mounted. It went to a food bank.

But three days later, the tournament deemed it the only qualifying white marlin of the five-day open. The total prize was $2,818,662.

The open itself paid out only $15,000. But like many anglers, Heasley had placed a big bet on himself and his crew in various "calcuttas," which are optional betting pools.

Boats can pay a total of nearly $30,000 apiece before the tournament. Whoever hooks the heaviest fish in a category and participated in the calcuttas takes home the big money.

Heasley planned to give half to the crew, a life-changing gift.

But there was one more step: Heasley had to pass a lie detector test.

Tournaments have employed polygraphs for decades. Sometimes they’re used to settle disputes. No accusations had been made against the Kallianassa, but polygraphs are standard at the White Marlin Open.

"I kind of call it the velvet hammer," the contest’s founder, Jim Motsko, said recently. "You need something to keep people honest," he said. "Would you put up $15,000 if you didn’t trust anybody?"

Heasley, 68, had competed in dozens of tournaments, once winning $800,000. But this was his first White Marlin Open and his first polygraph.

In a hotel conference room, the examiner measured his heartbeat, breathing and perspiration and asked, "Did you commit any tournament violations?" Similar questions followed.

The results were inconclusive. Another test was required. The unsuspecting and hung-over captain, David Morris, had to be tested too. The examiner said Morris indicated "deception" during his exam.

The men still posed with a promotional check at the award ceremony. But the actual money was being withheld, they were told, pending Heasley’s second polygraph and tests for the two mates. No one passed.

Tournament officials denied the prize. Heasley refused to sign a release of the winnings. The tournament asked a court to intervene.

Winners from other fishing categories joined in the litigation, claiming they were entitled to the money. They accused the Kallianassa of dropping its fishing lines before 8:30 a.m., a rule violation.

This is far from the first court fight over big prize money for a big fish.

In 2010, a boat crew sued over a $900,000 prize after catching an 883-pound fish in the Big Rock Blue Marlin Tournament. The boat was disqualified because the mate who hooked the marlin lacked a fishing license. The tournament learned of the violation during a polygraph test.

The case went to North Carolina’s Supreme Court before a settlement was reached in 2013.

Polygraph issues at the White Marlin Open didn’t end with Heasley. Tests for two anglers "raised concerns" this year. But in October, tournament officials determined no rules were violated. They didn’t identify the boats in question.

At trial, Heasley’s lawyers questioned the accuracy of polygraph tests, and criticized the tournament’s exams.

The judge ruled against Heasley in June, writing that Heasley had agreed to the open’s terms.

The judge also sided with the other anglers over the Kallianassa’s fishing start time, citing discrepancies among the crew’s accounts and other evidence.

The case is now on appeal. In a statement to the Associated Press, Heasley said he’s fighting for the decency of the sport.

"I have continued our fight in the appellate courts," Heasley wrote, "because I am not the kind of person to lay down and let anyone run over us with lies and junk science."

Comments
Candidates bring varied backgrounds to contentious District 61 House race

Candidates bring varied backgrounds to contentious District 61 House race

TAMPA — One-hundred and one.According to the Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections website, that’s the number of votes that stood between community activist Dianne Hart and Rep. Sean Shaw in 2016 when the two went head-to-head in the District 6...
Updated: 12 minutes ago
Fired Brooksville fire captain must wait awhile longer for check from the city

Fired Brooksville fire captain must wait awhile longer for check from the city

BROOKSVILLE — More than two years after a Brooksville fire department captain was fired for breaking her boss’ rule — a rule that violated directives from the agency’s medical director — the City Council on Monday was poised to pay her a financial se...
Updated: 13 minutes ago
Brooksville’s TreeUmph! adventure course closes after less than a year in operation

Brooksville’s TreeUmph! adventure course closes after less than a year in operation

BROOKSVILLE — The TreeUmph! Adventure Course that opened last year east of Brooksville was closed on Monday."We truly regret that this action is necessary,’’ owner Aaron Corrs told the Tampa Bay Times in an email on Tuesday. "It comes after many mont...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Got an Instant Pot? Here’s a beginner’s guide to pressure cooking, and our favorite starter recipes

Got an Instant Pot? Here’s a beginner’s guide to pressure cooking, and our favorite starter recipes

It’s becoming a regular routine for me after Amazon Prime Day — another batch of my friends snag a deal on the Instant Pot pressure cooker, so I send out another batch of my favorite recipes.Welcome to the cult, folks. I never meant to join the more ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Mayor Rick Kriseman didn’t tell commissioners that ferry riders will have parking issues

Mayor Rick Kriseman didn’t tell commissioners that ferry riders will have parking issues

CLEARWATER –– When Mayor Rick Kriseman asked Pinellas County commissioners last month for $150,000 to pay for the CrossBay Ferry, he didn’t disclose potential parking challenges.Unlike in 2016 when the service was introduced, the ferry will dock near...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Journey’s Neal Schon: Aretha Franklin tribute was my idea, not the band’s

Journey’s Neal Schon: Aretha Franklin tribute was my idea, not the band’s

During Journey’s concert on Saturday at Amalie Arena in Tampa, guitarist Neal Schon put a momentary pin in the band’s parade of hits to perform an extended solo, during which photos of the late Aretha Franklin flashed on screen behind him.Schon would...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Bowen: Is ‘Live PD’ tarnishing Pasco’s image?

Bowen: Is ‘Live PD’ tarnishing Pasco’s image?

The summer bucket list included reading more 20th century authors: Ernest Hemingway. Joseph Heller. Kurt Vonnegut. Check. Cops and criminals in the 21st century made plenty of appearances, too. Authors John Sanford and Ace Atkins are favorites.Check....
Updated: 3 hours ago
Top 5 at noon: How Andrew Gillum and Gwen Graham, once allies, became rivals; Journey guitarist: Aretha Franklin tribute was my idea, not bands’; and more

Top 5 at noon: How Andrew Gillum and Gwen Graham, once allies, became rivals; Journey guitarist: Aretha Franklin tribute was my idea, not bands’; and more

Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com.ONCE ALLIES, ANDREW GILLUM AND GWEN GRAHAM BECAME RIVALSGwen Graham was a Democratic star in 2015, one of the party’s lone bright spots after winning her congressional race the year before. S...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Fall food, wine and beer festivals at Florida theme parks expect to fill bellies, profits

Fall food, wine and beer festivals at Florida theme parks expect to fill bellies, profits

Back in 1995 when Epcot launched its International Food and Wine Festival, the idea was to generate attendance during the slow period in the fall. It worked. After two decades, the festival is mobbed on the weekends and has grown to one of Walt Disne...
Updated: 4 hours ago
What to expect at Epcot’s International Food and Wine Festival this year

What to expect at Epcot’s International Food and Wine Festival this year

How soon until Epcot is just one big food festival? We’re getting close. Once just a month long, the annual Epcot International Food and Wine Festival is up to 75 days in its 23rd year, beginning Aug. 30 and running through the middle of November. Th...
Updated: 4 hours ago