Sunday, June 17, 2018
  • Bay Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

What could BRT look like in Tampa Bay? Here are three examples

Bus rapid transit has emerged as Tampa Bay's latest transportation solution. Many, though, may still be asking: "What exactly is BRT?"

Unlike rail — the regional transit option that pro- and anti-rail forces have long fought over — BRT looks different in almost every city. Each system is built to meet the individual needs of its city, region and ridership.

Sometimes the routes are built in their own, special busways (dedicated lanes or tracks). Other times they're additional lanes added to existing roads. Some have fancy stations where passengers board at ground level. Others have minimal stops, few and far between to speed up travel time.

Here in Tampa Bay, planners have proposed building what may be the longest BRT system in the nation: A 41-mile line connecting Pinellas to Hillsborough to Pasco counties.

TAMPA BAY TIMES COVERAGE: BUS RAPID TRANSIT

Tampa Bay's transit future: Light rail's out. Rapid buses are in.

Tampa Bay Transit: How rapid buses left light rail in the dust

Learn how bus rapid transit (and rail) could work in Tampa Bay

Learn how bus rapid transit (and rail) could work in Tampa Bay

For the most part, the buses would use the shoulder of Interstate 275 as a dedicated lane. In some sections, they'd mix with regular traffic or use the express toll lanes the state plans to build in the coming years. For the 3.5 miles between West Shore and downtown Tampa, buses would likely have their own lane in the expanded median between the interstate.

But every city does BRT its own way. To give readers a sense of what's possible, the Tampa Bay Times compared the Tampa Bay plan to three existing sytems: Pittsburgh, one of the oldest BRT lines in the country; Hartford, one of the newest; and Cleveland, which had long held the highest BRT rating in the United States (until Albuquerque opened its system in 2017 and took the top spot.)

TAMPA BAY TIMES REPORT: Tampa Bay has one of the worst public transit systems in America. Here's why.

While each system is different, they're all very different from Tampa Bay's still nascent proposal: 1. They're much shorter, just 9 miles compared to 41 miles. 2. They run far more frequently. 3. They exist alongside other premium transit options, such as light rail and commuter rail. But in the bay area, BRT would be the premium transit option.

There are dozens more examples of BRT out there. But these three glimpses at existing systems could help bay area residents understand what this transportation option could look like if it's ever built here.

A Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority bus makes a stop on its bus rapid transit line, one of the highest rated in the country. [Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority]

Health Line: Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority

  • Opened: 2008
  • Cost to build: $168.4 million (half federal sources, including a New Starts Grant; a third from Ohio)
  • Length: 9.38 miles
  • Stops: 36 stations
  • Peak frequency: 5-8 minutes
  • First-year ridership: 2,637,664
  • 2017 ridership: 4,258,145

Cleveland is home to one of the most successful BRT systems in the nation.
But the first line — the city now has three — opened in 2008 to mixed reaction.

The transit agency took over two center lanes on a main drag and converted them to BRT lines. The agency also reduced the number of stops along that line from 108 to 38. The result was a 40-percent reduction in travel times.

The public responded favorably. In a current climate where bus ridership is dropping nationwide, Cleveland's BRT lines continues to increase ridership.

In addition to having fewer stops and their own lane, the BRT vehicles also take advantage traffic lights that sense the bus coming and switch to green to let it pass through intersections.

Transit-oriented development has followed, generating $6.5 billion of development along the corridor, according to Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority CEO Joseph Calabrese.

The bus stations are in the road medians, have real-time arrival displays and ticket vending machines.

"We built this exactly like we'd build a rail system, but without the tracks," Calabrese said.

But it took several studies and prolonged public debate before the BRT plan was adopted decades ago.

"There were a few people that said it should be rail or nothing," Calabrese said. "If that were the case, it would have been nothing, because we simply couldn't afford it."

A CT Fastrack bus runs in its own guideway in Hartford, Connecticut. The system opened in 2015. [Connecticut Department of Transportation]

CTfastrak: Connecticut Department of Transportation

  • Opened: 2015
  • Cost to build: $567 million (80 percent federal, New Starts Project, 20 percent state)
  • Length: 9.4 miles,
  • Stops: 11 stations 
  • Peak frequency: 7 minutes
  • First-year ridership:  3,050,754
  • 2017 ridership: 3,366,656

The Hartford BRT line is still in its infancy, but early ridership numbers are "way higher" than projected, transit administrator Dennis Solensky said.

The 9.4-mile route was built in existing right-of-way along a railroad line. No other vehicles run in that space.

The transit agency said it continues to improve the service, recently adding heaters to stations and comping passes for university students.

A lot of thought and energy went into developing the 10 new stations, Solenksy said, such as making sure they had adequate lighting, seating and landscaping. Seven also have free parking on site.

But it took considerable time and conversations to get the project off the ground.

"I wouldn't be honest with you if I didn't admit it had its share of detractors," Solensky said. "But it's been successful by any terms."

The agency took the approach of replacing traditional routes with one that has "tremendous frequencies and reliability."

In just a few years, annual ridership is now up to about 3.4 million.

The East Liberty Station on the East Busway in Pittsburgh has been a shining star of transit oriented development for the agency. (Courtesy of Pittsburgh Port Authority)

Martin Luther King Jr. East Busway: Pittsburgh Port Authority

  • Opened: 1983
  • Cost to build: $115 million, plus $68 million for a 2-mile extension (Paid for by a mix of federal, state and county funds.)
  • Length: 9.1 miles
  • Stops: 9 stations
  • Peak Frequency: 3 to 6 minutes
  • First-year ridership: 27,000 rides on an average weekday
  • 2017 ridership: 13,000 rides on an average weekday and 9,000 on an average weekend. Thirteen other bus routes operate party-way on the East Busway, accommodating an additional 10,000 rides on an average weekday.

Pittsburgh is home to one of the oldest BRT line in the nation, opening in 1983. The city actually has two busways, with the East Busway being the oldest.

Both run along railroad tracks, generally hidden from view and the communities they pass through.

Because BRT was built in a time when jobs were in decline and people were moving away from the city, development project manager Breen Masciotra said the agency didn't see a lot of development around the stations.

That changed a few years ago with the redevelopment of the East Liberty Station. Through a lot of elbow grease, that project now has almost 20 different funding sources, Masciotra said. The redevelopment has helped connect the station and route with the community, and the agency said that has raised ridership.

While the line might not be as connected to the community as in other cities, officials said its strength lies in its frequency. Buses run every 3 minutes in peak hours, making it a reliable and speedy option.

Because the buses are essentially on their own highways, so they're able to go as fast as 75 mph between stations.

"We can barely fit people on the buses," Masciotra said. "It's very, very well used."

This is an artist’s rendering of the kind of rapid buses the Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority wants to run along Frist Avenues N and S between downtown St. Petersburg and the beaches. But they’re also an example of what the regional bus rapid transit (BRT) system could look like. [Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority]

Proposed: Tampa Bay Bus Rapid Transit

  • Earliest projected opening: 2024
  • Projected cost to build: $380-455 million
  • Length: 41 miles from St. Petersburg to Tampa to Wesley Chapel
  • Stops: 21 stations
  • Peak frequency: 15 minutes
  • Projected ridership: 3.3 to 3.6 million annually

Local planners have set aside their rail ambitions — for now — and are pursuing a 41-mile rapid bus route as a potential answer to Tampa Bay's transportation woes.

Political and business leaders alike hope the three-county BRT line will provide a quicker, more reliable alternative to being trapped in interstate  traffic.

The buses will operate along the shoulder of Interstate 275 for much of the route, including between downtown Tampa and the University of South Florida and on the Pinellas side. For other sections, the buses will run in the express toll lanes the state has proposed to build on I-275, including on the Howard Frankland Bridge.

A map of the proposed bus rapid transit system for the Tampa Bay region. [Times]
A map of the proposed bus rapid transit system for the Tampa Bay region. [Times]
The plan currently calls for 21 stations, most at street level. Two between West Shore and downtown Tampa will likely be elevated. The Florida Department of Transportation is looking into building five large transit hubs along the line that would key into existing bus networks, trolleys, street car or circulators.

Planners are proposing buses run every 15 minutes, which is a far cry from Hartford's 7-minute frequency, nevermind Pittsburgh's 3 minutes. That and other details could change as the project is vetted by the public over the next six months.

Comments
Democrat who hopes to challenge Gus Bilirakis put on New Democrat Coalition Watch List

Democrat who hopes to challenge Gus Bilirakis put on New Democrat Coalition Watch List

A major Democratic group just put one of Gus Bilirakis' potential challengers on its list of candidates to watch.The New Democrat Coalition, 68 congressional Democrats who emphasize economic issues and "finding pragmatic solutions to policy challenge...
Published: 06/15/18
Updated: 06/16/18
Valdes fires back, and draws a blistering response from Alvarez

Valdes fires back, and draws a blistering response from Alvarez

[SEE UPDATE AT THE END FOR FIGHTING WORDS FROM ALVAREZ]Victor DiMaio on Thursday released this announcement on behalf of Florida State House hopeful and Hillsborough County School Board member Susan Valdes:"Susan Valdes hoped the race between Democra...
Published: 06/14/18
Tampa City Council hears cautious optimism in Buckhorn’s modest last budget

Tampa City Council hears cautious optimism in Buckhorn’s modest last budget

Tampa City Council members reacted to Mayor Bob Buckhorn's cautious last budget Thursday with their own hedge, saying the city's economic forecast could change on a dime if the national and regional economy goes south in the next few months.Buckhorn ...
Published: 06/14/18
Hillsborough School Board member Susan Valdes’ resignation letter raises objections

Hillsborough School Board member Susan Valdes’ resignation letter raises objections

Hillsborough County School Board member Susan Valdes, who is running for the Florida House District 62 seat, sent in her legally required resignation letter hours before last Friday's deadline. On Monday, Supervisor of Elections Craig Latimer announ...
Published: 06/13/18
Jane Castor takes early fundraising lead in Tampa mayor’s race

Jane Castor takes early fundraising lead in Tampa mayor’s race

Election Day is still more than eight months away, but former police chief Jane Castor, who dominated the field in a recent local poll, is also breaking ahead in the money race.And Castor has much more money remaining in the bank than her opponents f...
Published: 06/12/18
Updated: 06/13/18
What quorum? Pat Kemp left TBARTA meeting, scuttling planned vote

What quorum? Pat Kemp left TBARTA meeting, scuttling planned vote

TAMPA — The regional transit authority will schedule an emergency board meeting after a member, Hillsborough County Commissioner Pat Kemp, said she fell ill and abruptly left Friday’s meeting.The problem with that is Kemp’s sudden&#...
Published: 06/12/18
Executive director of TBARTA runs for Hillsborough County Commission

Executive director of TBARTA runs for Hillsborough County Commission

TAMPA – Ray Chiaramonte, the executive director of the Tampa Bay Area Regional Transit Authority, has entered the race for the Hillsborough County Commission District 7 seat.Chiaramonte filed papers Monday with the Hillsborough County Superviso...
Published: 06/11/18
Murman decision to withdraw from District 7 race shakes up county commission race

Murman decision to withdraw from District 7 race shakes up county commission race

TAMPA — In the year since County Commission Chairwoman Sandy Murman filed to switch to commission District 7, she raised more than $180,000 to fund a race for the countywide seat.But in a surprise move Friday, Murman let a deadline pass without...
Published: 06/08/18
Harry Cohen’s message to Tampa: ‘You know me’

Harry Cohen’s message to Tampa: ‘You know me’

TAMPA — Harry Cohen stood before several hundred people at the Tampa Museum of Art on Wednesday evening with a simple message: He's a proven quantity that residents can rely on to take the city to the next level — and do it fairly.Co...
Published: 06/06/18
Updated: 06/07/18
Ed Narain is still making up his mind about a run for Tampa mayor

Ed Narain is still making up his mind about a run for Tampa mayor

People ask Ed Narain all the time if he's going to run for mayor of Tampa.Narain admitted as much after being contacted Tuesday by the Tampa Bay Times about a flurry of rumors that he was about to jump in the race.“A lot of people...
Published: 06/05/18