Wednesday, November 14, 2018
  • Bay Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

Pinellas sheriff: 4-year-old emergency operations complex ‘looks like a dump’

When Hurricane Irma slammed Florida last year, hundreds of first responders worked inside Pinellas County's three-year-old Public Safety Complex.

But deputies had to worry about their own safety. As rain and wind pummeled the region, deputies used buckets to collect water as it poured through cracked walls across the rear of the second floor of the $81 million fortress.

Fingers are now being pointed over who is responsible for the cracks in a complex that was built to withstand a Category 5 hurricane. The problems have already cost taxpayers at least $200,000.

"I'm extremely concerned by this," Sheriff Bob Gualtieri told the Tampa Bay Times. "This was supposed to be done right. There are all kinds of problems with this building."

The complex — once hailed as a signature project of the Penny for Pinellas 1-cent sales tax — is at the center of a lawsuit over shoddy workmanship. The county is suing the building designer and three contractors who worked on the project.

Officials never expected an onslaught of deficiencies so soon after the building opened.

Cracks in walls have developed throughout the exterior walls of the 218,403-square-foot main building, energy plant and vehicle maintenance facility. Water leaks have deteriorated some exterior door and window frames and damaged interior fixtures.

Water leaks from rains have been an problem at the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office on Ulmerton Road. The $81 million complex was built in 2014 and is also home to the Pinellas County Emergency Operations Center. The county is suing the designer and contractors who built the complex. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]

The leaks also stopped electronic-locking devices from working on exterior doors. There is rust on some door and window frames. Paint is peeling and drywall is turning brown from water damage near 15 to 20 sets of windows.

Motorists on Ulmerton Road can see one of the biggest problems: Faded paint across the front of the main building. Nobody has been able to pinpoint the cause.

"It's an embarrassment," Gualtieri said. "The place looks like a dump."

The county accused St. Petersbug-based Harvard Jolly of negligently designing the building and failing to supervise the construction. Harvard Jolly blamed the problems on general contractor Lend Lease US Construction (formerly Bovis), PTAC Consulting Engineers and engineer William Lovell, Jr., according to a court filing.

The campus, conceived years ago following the 2004 hurricane season, opened in 2014. It houses the Sheriff's Office, the Emergency Operations Center, Emergency Medical Services and the 911 dispatch center. The command center's first real test came during Irma in September 2017.

The exterior paint is fading all around the Pinellas County Public Safety Complex on Ulmerton Road in Largo. Officials do not know what caused the paint to fade. The $81 million complex was built in 2014. The county is suing the designer and contractors who built the complex. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]

The complex has a hardened parking garage with more than 600 spaces that can shelter the sheriff's fleet of ground vehicles, helicopters and boats. During major events, it can accommodate 700 workers from federal, state, county and city agencies.

Andrew W. Pupke, director of the Pinellas County Real Estate Management Department, said the county has spent the $200,000 to fix water leaks in the precast wall panels. The facility can withstand a storm, he said.

"The building is safe," he said. "The building integrity is not in question."
Pressed to explain that declaration since a Category 5 hurricane hasn't hit the building, Pupke said: "That's what it was built for."

Meanwhile, the cracks and faded paint cannot be fixed until officials and contractors determine what caused them to occur, Pupke said.

Exterior cracks have formed around the walls at the Pinellas County Emergency Operations Center on Ulmerton Road. Officials don’t know what is causing the cracks. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]

That could take time. The court battle could drag on for years.

Harvard Jolly, the building designer, blamed the problems on the other contractors who it didn't manage, according to a court filing.

Ward Friszolowski, Harvard Jolly president, told the Tampa Bay Times last month that the firm is working alongside Pinellas County to help understand and resolve the concerns. Seeking a satisfactory outcome is the highest priority, he said.

Adrian Lovell, CEO of Pensacola-based PTAC Consulting Engineers, said he agrees with Harvard Jolly that another contractor is to blame, adding: "It's not my fault." He declined further comment. Engineer William Lovell, Jr. could not be reached for comment.

Lend Lease US Construction, a Chicago architectural firm and engineering company, did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

The company was embroiled in a lawsuit over the 36-story Signature Place, a St. Petersburg condominium tower. One of the accusations: Cracked and improperly applied stucco in large areas of the exterior walls, which allowed water to leak into the interior. The parties reached a confidential settlement in 2017.

The county's lawsuit has caught the attention of St. Petersburg officials.
The city is using part of its share of Penny for Pinellas money to build a 167,519-square-foot police headquarters, which was designed to withstand a Category 4 hurricane. Harvard Jolly is the designer on that $86 million project, which is also using precast structures and wall panels.

Raul Quintana, the city's architect, said he is monitoring the lawsuit and has talked with Harvard Jolly. The city is confident that it won't have any issues because it is using a local contractor with deep community ties to manage construction.

"Any water intrusion is a major concern," he said. "A lot of people are watching over this."

Last fall, county officials asked voters to renew the Penny tax for a fourth decade, which should raise an estimated $2 billion between 2020 and 2030. They pointed to the successful completion of the Public Safety Complex as a major justification for why the tax should be renewed.

In recent years, critics have accused county and city officials of using Penny money for ribbon-cutting projects like recreation centers, parks and trails to bolster election campaigns.

Commissioner Dave Eggers, who wasn't on the County Commission when it approved the construction of the Public Safety Complex, said a "flagship project" shouldn't have so many problems.

"You certainly expect an above average delivery of the project," he said. "Certainly, I'm very disappointed."

Contact Mark Puente at [email protected] or (727) 892-2996. Follow @MarkPuente.

Comments
Clearwater strong mayor fight is over but rift on City Council remains an open wound

Clearwater strong mayor fight is over but rift on City Council remains an open wound

Hoyt Hamilton asks for apology from Doreen Caudell for her words in Letter to the Editor. She apologizes but claims she was misquoted in her own letter.
Published: 11/14/18
William March: Could a late arrival in Tampa mayor’s race upset the apple cart?

William March: Could a late arrival in Tampa mayor’s race upset the apple cart?

Speculation centers on businessman Mike Griffin or former state Rep. Ed Narain possibly entering the race for Tampa mayor.
Published: 11/13/18
Is he doing a post-election two-step? Ed Turanchik  on the transportation tax, then and now

Is he doing a post-election two-step? Ed Turanchik on the transportation tax, then and now

Before the vote, Ed Turanchik was highly critical of the one-penny sales tax increase to fund transportation improvements that passed overwhelmingly on Tuesday.The former Hillsborough County Commissioner and current Tampa mayoral candidate was the on...
Published: 11/08/18
Updated: 11/09/18
Hillsborough now firmly blue

Hillsborough now firmly blue

A growing urban and suburban population has shifted Hillsborough's politics, pundits say.
Published: 11/07/18
The people’s choice?  Tampa’s Riverwalk

The people’s choice? Tampa’s Riverwalk

It's been the riparian apple of Mayor Bob Buckhorn's eye, so perhaps it's fitting , as the term-limited mayor counts down his final months in office, that Tampa's Riverwalk gets some national love.The American Planning Association awarded the linear ...
Published: 11/07/18
Los Angeles mayor hails Hillsborough transit vote on ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live!’

Los Angeles mayor hails Hillsborough transit vote on ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live!’

Eric Garcetti tells the ABC-TV host that the citizen-driven, voter-approved, penny on dollar sales tax for transportation is one of the midterm election's most exciting results.
Published: 11/07/18
Hillsborough voters approve sales tax hikes for transportation, schools improvements

Hillsborough voters approve sales tax hikes for transportation, schools improvements

The 30-year transportation measure will add a penny on the dollar to the sales tax and raise about $276 million per year. Voters were equally enthusiastic about a 10-year, half-cent sales tax for Hillsborough County Schools.
Published: 11/07/18
Hillsborough Commission District 5 election results: Mariella Smith unseats Victor Crist

Hillsborough Commission District 5 election results: Mariella Smith unseats Victor Crist

Democrats now control a majority on the Hillsborough County Commission for the first time since 2004.
Published: 11/06/18
Updated: 11/07/18
Florida House District 65 results: Incumbent Chris Sprowls defeats first-timer Sally Laufer

Florida House District 65 results: Incumbent Chris Sprowls defeats first-timer Sally Laufer

Sprowls, a north Pinellas Republican, won his third term in office. He remains on track become Speaker of the Florida House for the 2021-22 legislative session.
Published: 11/06/18
Updated: 11/07/18
Tampa Bay Judicial Races: Fuson, Allen, Gutman win in Hillsborough, Ellis wins Pinellas-Pasco

Tampa Bay Judicial Races: Fuson, Allen, Gutman win in Hillsborough, Ellis wins Pinellas-Pasco

Clear victors emerge in all four Tampa Bay judicial races
Published: 11/06/18