Shown: Board member Sally Harris, who voted yes for Elia's termination; Melissa Snively, who voted no; Susan Valdes, who voted yes; Doretha Edgecomb, who voted no; and board attorney Jim Porter
People are stunned by the Hillsborough County School Board's 4-3 vote this week to buy out the contract of Superintendent MaryEllen Elia. As they terminated her contract without cause, members have been careful not to disparage Elia publicly for fear of being sued.
So what is the back story? And why did newcomer Sally Harris vote to fire Elia?
Harris spoke to Tampa Bay Times columnist Sue Carlton, who gave this report.
The others have written volumes about Elia over the years in her annual evaluations.
Here are the full board comments for 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014.
Here are some quick excerpts: …Full Story
SCHOOL CHOICE: Florida school districts offer more education options for families to compete with outside alternatives.
STUDENT VOICES: A Hillsborough committee focusing on minority student discipline finally listens to students about their views.
'OUR SYSTEM IS BROKEN': Hillsborough School Board member Sally Harris says she loves MaryEllen Elia, whom she called an icon, but voted to oust her because 'she forgot how to keep the communication open.' • The School Board now needs to define its way forward, the Times editorializes.
EARLY OUT: Volusia superintendent Margaret Smith, under fire from some board members, decides to retire two years earlier than planned, the Daytona Beach News-Journal reports.
EDUCATION TALK: Jeb Bush will hold an education summit in Tallahassee, the Orlando Sentinel reports.
TESTING: Brevard school district leaders say parents and students have no venue to opt out of state tests, Florida Today reports.
NEW SCHOOLS: Lee district officials examine whether to put a new high school in Bonita Springs, the Naples Daily News reports.
CLEAN CAMPUS: Supporters defend a Miami high school accused of having poor conditions, the Miami Herald reports. …Full Story
Gov. Rick Scott has appointed Michael Olenick to the state Board of Education.
Olenick, 62, is a former general counsel for the state Department of Education. He currently chairs the Florida Virtual School Board of Trustees.
"I know Michael shares our goal of making sure all of our students succeed in the classroom, and I am pleased to appoint him to the State Board of Education today," Scott said in a statement.
Olenick is vice president of corporate affairs and chief compliance officer of The Morganti Group, an international construction company. A graduate of Nova Southeastern School of Law, he previously served as assistant state attorney for Broward and St. Lucie counties, as well as Martin County attorney.
He will replace Ada Armas, a Miami-Dade physician who resigned from the education board to spend more time with her family.
His term ends December 31, 2016.
The appointment is subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.Full Story
Gov. Rick Scott has released several key details of his proposed education budget, including his desire to boost the overall K-12 education budget to $19.75 billion.
His latest education-related recommendation: $5 million for the Personal Learning Scholarship Account program.
The new program provides scholarships worth $10,000 or more to children with profound special needs. The money can be applied toward private school tuition, tutoring, educational materials and therapy.
"Every individual should have the opportunity to get a great job and education regardless of the challenges they may face, and that is why we are making this funding a priority," Scott said in a statement.
Last week, Scott said he wanted to see $100 million set aside for charter-school construction and maintenance.
Will his budget prioritize other aspects of school choice? We'll see when he rolls out his entire proposal later this month.Full Story
Florida's First District Court of Appeal has rejected the Florida Education Association's lawsuit claiming SB 736 -- the 2011 law changing teachers' contracts, pay and evaluations -- unconstitutionally violated their collective bargaining rights.
"Appellants have not established that the legislature delegated core legislative authority to the Board of Education and intended to violate the separation of powers requirement of Article II, section 3 of the Florida Constitution," the court majority wrote in a decision issued Friday.
The case was initially dismissed in 2013. At the time, FEA lawyers said the initial court "misapprehended" the scope of the situation, and said they would appeal.
FEA president Andy Ford issued a statement Friday expressing disappointment in the latest setback.
"We still believe that many provisions of SB 736 are destructive to students, teachers and public schools and that the legislation is having a detrimental effect on our students," Ford said. "In the coming days, we’re going to examine the ruling and make a decision about whether to appeal this ruling to the Florida Supreme Court." …Full Story
Facing difficulties filling all its substitute teacher needs, the Pasco County school district has spent months reviewing ways to attract and retain more subs.
Its effort has begun working. At the start of the year, the district had 675 instructional and noninstructional substitutes on file. Now, it has 1,003, of which 872 are instructional.
To get there, the district didn't increase its pay, as some educators have suggested. It didn't hire an temporary employment firm, as other districts have done.
Instead, Pasco quietly reduced the qualifications needed to substitute. Instead of needing an associate's degree or 60 college credits, as nearby districts require, Pasco now will accept subs with a high school diploma. Officials changed the criteria in November.
"We're basically paying minimum wage for that position," human resources director Christine Pejot said, referring to the lowest level substitutes. Those with higher credentials are paid more. "I knew we were looking at increasing our pool size, and that was one way to do it." …Full Story
MaryEllen Elia is on her way out as Hillsborough schools superintendent. She still could wind up being National Superintendent of the Year, regardless.
AASA: The School Superintendents Association issued a statement expressing dismay that the School Board had dismissed Elia without cause, and saying she deserves recognition as a finalist, perhaps more. Executive director Dan Domenech said:
“The superintendent’s job is one of the most difficult and demanding jobs in America. That’s one of the reasons why AASA was disappointed to learn, through media accounts, that MaryEllen Elia, one of the finalists for the 2015 National Superintendent of the Year, is being terminated, without cause, by her school board from her position as superintendent of Hillsborough County Public Schools in Tampa, Fla.
“Given her achievements as the leader of one of the nation’s largest school districts, it was not a surprise to us that she was honored as Florida's State Superintendent of the Year last year. She also won the Florida Excellence in Education Award. According to a news report, a state senator called her a ‘superintendent's superintendent.’ …Full Story
BRIGHT FUTURES: Florida Gov. Rick Scott proposes an expansion of the Bright Futures scholarship to help students pay for summer school courses.
GROWTH: Pasco school officials discuss the need to increase school impact fees.
CONTROL: The Pinellas school district proposes a $1 million program to help teachers with classroom management.
GOING STRONG: Gorrie Elementary in south Tampa celebrates its 125th anniversary.
HAND-OFF: Condoleezza Rice takes over Jeb Bush's Florida-based education foundation, ABC News reports.
PADDLING: A University of Florida study calls for the end of corporal punishment in Florida schools, the Independent Alligator reports.
CAREER ACADEMIES: A growing number of central Florida high school students enroll in health care academies, the Orlando Sentinel reports.
CHARTER SCHOOLS: The Duval School Board shuts down a charter school for lack of insurance, the Florida Times-Union reports.
TEXTBOOKS: Gov. Scott calls for a cut in college textbook taxes, the AP reports. …Full Story
For the second time in two years, Pasco schools superintendent Kurt Browning has announced plans to end classes at the county's first permanent school for African-American students, the Moore-Mickens Education Center. Browning gave in to community pressure and dropped the idea in 2013.
Some residents are hoping for a similar result this time.
"I believe the bus can turn around," Jesse McClendon of the Moore-Mickens Neighborhood Committee told the School Board this week.
McClendon reminded the board that the school sits in a low-income neighborhood, and offers poor people a path to improve their lot in life. He questioned whether the board would shutter a similar school serving a high-income neighborhood.
Moore-Mickens is treated "like a stepchild, always underfunded, underappreciated," he said. "I believe you are good people. I believe you are making a bad decision." …Full Story
The Hillsborough County School Board's firing of long-time superintendent MaryEllen Elia raised the key question, What experienced leader would walk into the role knowing the divided nature of an apparently politically driven board?
Andres Antonio Alonso, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, said Elia's abrupt dismissal without cause came as a surprise to the world that knows the Hillsborough district as one focused on stability and innovation, not turbulence.
"It's a school community that people have watched over time with a sense that there are good things going on," said Alonso, a former Baltimore City Public Schools superintendent who now trains district leaders.
That reputation could attract applicants to lead the district. But at the same time, the politics leading to Elia's firing could dissuade some.
The School Board can overcome any potential anxiety, though, Alonso said. …Full Story
WHAT'S NEXT? Observers discuss the Hillsborough school district's next steps in the aftermath of superintendent MaryEllen Elia's dismissal. • The Palm Beach School Board fast-tracks its superintendent search, noting that having Hillsborough on the hunt can't help, the Sun-Sentinel reports. • Marion superintendent George Tomyn announces his reelection plans, the Ocala Star-Banner reports.
LESSONS LEARNED: Four finalists for national Superintendent of the Year, including MaryEllen Elia, share their thoughts on success, the Washington Post reports.
BUSINESS PLANS: Pasco Weightman Middle School students learn real-world business skills in a new club.
BULLYING: Students at Hernando Springstead High School sign pledges to be nice to others during Celebrate Kindness Week.
EARLY RETIREMENT: The principal of a Miami high school decides to retire early amid allegations of deplorable campus conditions, NBC Miami reports. More from the Miami Herald.
VOUCHERS: A new report looks into why Florida private schools participate in the state's tax credit scholarship program, Education Week reports. …Full Story
Bill Gates at Jefferson High School
Everybody is going on the record regarding the firing of Hillsborough County superintendent MaryEllen Elia.
So Gradebook reached out to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which committed $100 million to the district's Empowering Effective Teachers program.
Here is the response from Vicki Phillips, the foundation's director of education and college readiness:
"Over the last five years, as a result of continuing collaboration among the district, union and community, Hillsborough has developed one of the most innovative and comprehensive teacher development and support programs in the country. Superintendent Elia has been recognized in Florida and nationally for her leadership in these efforts. The foundation chose to invest in Hillsborough because of its active, engaged and caring community, including its teachers and administrators, and we remain committed to Hillsborough as long as its leaders, teachers and parents are committed to the work. As we've always said, ensuring there is an effective teacher in every classroom is a critical part of improving education for each and every student."
The Florida House is moving quickly on a proposal to allow guns on college campuses.
The House Criminal Justice Subcommittee approved the measure (HB 4005) in a party-line vote Tuesday, making it the first bill to advance in the Florida House this year.
Still, it faces a significant hurdle in the Senate. Former Republican Sen. John Thrasher, who left the upper chamber in November to become the president of Florida State University, adamantly opposes the idea.
Thrasher's hesitancy "carries a lot of weight with a lot of senators," Senate Education Appropriations Subcommittee Chairman Don Gaetz said Wednesday.
Superintendent MaryEllen Elia, dismissed by the Hillsborough School Board Tuesday, told employees Wednesday that she is not retiring, she appreciates her years leading the school district, and the issue of her future can now be removed as a distraction.
Hillsborough County Public Schools Superintendent MaryEllen Elia sent this message out to her employees at 7:30 a.m. on Wednesday:
Last night the School Board voted to terminate my contract without cause. As a result, my last day on the job as Superintendent of this wonderful school district will be March 5.
I want to thank the Board for taking a stand and providing clarity on an issue that has become a tremendous distraction for our schools, our employees, and for the community. I'm not happy with the outcome, but perhaps this will enable everyone to move forward.
I want to assure all of you that every minute that I still serve as Superintendent, I will continue to do this job with passion — putting children first. However, this vote will make it possible for the district to move ahead and for me to pursue other opportunities. Retirement is not in my immediate future.
Gov. Rick Scott on Wednesday released new details on his proposed education budget.
Among his latest recommendations:
"We want Florida to be the global leader for jobs, and we must have a skilled workforce to reach that goal," Scott said. "By investing in science, technology, engineering and math education, we are ensuring our students are prepared for the jobs of the 21st century."
Senate Education Committee Chairman John Legg, R-Trinity, said he was encouraged to see the governor's focus on education.
"It is a positive direction, as long as it is linked to measurable goals," he said.
But Sen. Dwight Bullard, D-Miami, said Scott was missing the larger picture. "If we are going to be smart about it, we have to spend time picking apart the current budget and putting the money in the proper places," he said.
Scott has already unveiled a plan to increase K-12 spending to $19.75 billion.
He wants to spend $7,176 per student -- the highest amount ever, not accounting for inflation.Full Story