Sunday, May 20, 2018

Elected vs. appointed? Florida’s superintendent selection process gets a closer look

Much of Kurt Browning's lengthy tenure in public office has focused on Florida residents' voting rights.

The vote was his business as Pasco County's elections supervisor, and then as Florida secretary of state. Now as Pasco's superintendent of public schools, Browning finds himself still taking up the issue.

This week, he argued against a proposed constitutional amendment to do away with the election of school superintendents. Florida has 41 of them, and Pasco County is the largest in that group. (See the list here.)

"If this amendment goes to the voters and is approved, what happened is local control is taken away from counties' voters," Browning said Tuesday.

He noted that the bulk of the districts that still elect their superintendents are small, rural and less affluent than the 26 that appoint.

"What fits for Miami-Dade doesn't necessarily fit for Liberty," Browning said. "But the way that our system is set up, you will have districts in south Florida, in large part, telling districts in north Florida how to select their superintendent."

Here's the scenario Browning and others envisioned when urging the Constitutional Revision Commission's education committee to kill the proposal.

The 41 counties with elected superintendents had 2,410,374 registered voters, according to state records as of Oct. 31. The 26 with appointed leaders had 10,446,259 registered voters.

Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties alone had 3,474,228 — that's nearly 1.1 million more registered voters than all those 41 counties combined.

If the voters in the 26 figure they already have an appointed superintendent and see no reason to oppose the amendment, they could decide the outcome even if every single registered voter in the 41 counties votes "no."

Chris Doolin, a lobbyist for Florida's small county association, argued that the individual counties should be able to make their own decisions, as the constitution already allows.

He noted that whether they have elected or appointed superintendents, districts generally have the same spread of results in the state testing and school grading system.

As Clay County activist Travis Christensen put it, "I would like the state to leave our local elections alone."

Of course, the arguments favoring the proposal were many.

The vast majority of school districts in the nation appoint superintendents. Appointments allow for the best candidate to emerge regardless of home address. Currently elected superintendents would still be able to apply and be selected.

And, as education commissioner Pam Stewart noted, appointments would help remove election politics from what she said is a profession and should be treated as such.

Browning said he understood, and even agreed with, the rationale for appointing superintendents. He's just not buying.

"What I struggle with is this loss of local control, from the standpoint that you have a position — a very major position — that is going to be selected by three people" rather than an entire community, he said.

Moreover, he continued, there's nothing that has to separate being elected from being a professional.

The committee moved the proposal forward, with just one member opposed. It still must go through a second committee and gain full commission support before it could go to the voters.

Comments
ICYMI: Florida education news in review, week of May 13, 2018

ICYMI: Florida education news in review, week of May 13, 2018

The Florida legislative session ended weeks ago. But the debate over lawmakers’ funding of public education continued to surface. House Democrats called for a special session to revisit the budget, while House Republican leaders attacked the cr...
Published: 05/19/18
Pasco County parent drops school rezoning challenge

Pasco County parent drops school rezoning challenge

Just days before a scheduled administrative hearing, a Pasco County parent has pulled the plug on his challenge of the school district's proposed attendance zone changes.Jim Stanley, who has fought the district's effort for nearly two years, contende...
Published: 05/18/18
Schools’ security chief: More and more, it’s about “access control”

Schools’ security chief: More and more, it’s about “access control”

Speaking at a Tiger Bay Club meeting shortly after the deadly school shootings in Santa Fe, Tx, Hillsborough school security Chief John Newman said the tragedy underscores the need for campus vigilance.It's something he is keeping in mind as the dist...
Published: 05/18/18
Florida spring testing season ends with few disruptions

Florida spring testing season ends with few disruptions

Classes officially end in most Florida school districts next week. Many students will finish up with local semester exams.They won't have any more state exams to contend with. The assessment window for Florida Standards Assessments and end-of-co...
Published: 05/18/18
Florida House majority office goes on offense to tout its public education funding plan

Florida House majority office goes on offense to tout its public education funding plan

The Florida House Republican leadership has had enough of what it's calling the "47 cent myth."That's where several groups, including superintendents and teacher unions, have accused lawmakers of shortchanging public education with a 4...
Published: 05/18/18
Florida education news: State funding, teacher tenure, high school graduations and more

Florida education news: State funding, teacher tenure, high school graduations and more

SPECIAL SESSION? The Florida Legislature ended its spring session amid criticism of its public education budget, which added 47 cents to the base per-student allocation for general operations. Thirty-five House Democrats have filed a petiti...
Published: 05/18/18
Jameis Winston a no-go for Wiregrass Ranch High School graduation

Jameis Winston a no-go for Wiregrass Ranch High School graduation

Who's in?Apparently not Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Jameis Winston, who asked that question as part of a Twitter contest in which his attendance at a local high school graduation was the prize.Who’s in? https://t.co/unDbDHtipb&md...
Published: 05/17/18
Florida Dems use obscure law in last-ditch effort to call Legislature back for more school funding

Florida Dems use obscure law in last-ditch effort to call Legislature back for more school funding

At the end of session, superintendents and the statewide teachers' union called for the Legislature to redo their education funding in the budget they were about to pass. When a special session seemed imminent on gambling issues, again, they made the...
Published: 05/17/18
Did ending teacher professional services contracts help Florida students’ academic achievement?

Did ending teacher professional services contracts help Florida students’ academic achievement?

Florida lawmakers first proposed doing away with teacher "tenure" in 2010, making it happen in 2011 despite strong teacher opposition.One of their arguments: Making it easier to get rid of low-performing teachers could lead to higher student academic...
Published: 05/17/18
Gradebook podcast: Inside the debate over Florida textbooks

Gradebook podcast: Inside the debate over Florida textbooks

With the rise of Common Core, some conservative Florida groups began taking a closer look at what information appeared in school textbooks and other materials.  They found "objectionable" content in some districts, and have continued to...
Published: 05/17/18