Thursday, August 16, 2018

Parents ask Florida Supreme Court to send school funding suit back to trial court

Arguing the trial and appeals courts didn't properly consider their authority, parents suing Florida over its public education funding system have asked the state Supreme Court to send the case back for another review.

The lower courts ruled that they could not objectively determine whether the state had met the constitutional terms for funding a high quality public education, contending the language is not measurable.

Related coverage: Appeals court upholds ruling against Florida education funding challenge 

Not so, the plaintiffs say.

"The Florida Constitution's separation of powers provision does not bar Parents' suit because they are not asking the judiciary to encroach on the legislative duty to make educational policy, nor are they asking the courts to make appropriations or order the Legislature to do so," attorneys  for the plaintiffs in Citizens for Strong Schools wrote in a brief, made public Tuesday.

"Parents instead seek only declaratory relief, and for courts to fulfill their traditional responsibility to: (1) interpret constitutional terms, and (2) determine if the other branches have acted constitutionally. Article IX mandates that the Legislature act, which it has done, but that does not take away the judicial responsibility to ensure that those actions are consistent with Article IX's restrictions on legislative power."

They suggested the case be sent back for consideration "under the correct standard of review."

The group has argued that state funding of public education has not met the 1998 constitutional standard. In the brief, the lawyers pointed to wide disparities in funding and achievement levels among the 67 counties in Florida, and within the counties as well.

"Parents presented evidence to the trial court that not all children are learning the core content knowledge, as measured by wide disparities in achievement on state assessments, especially for children experiencing poverty or attending school in poorer school districts," the lawyers wrote.

Districts have differing abilities to raise funds for education, as well, they noted.

They also raised the issue of McKay Scholarships, in which families can take voucher money to private schools, which they argue are not free or uniform — issues that were tackled in previous lawsuits.

The case has been ongoing since 2009. Most recently, the "framers" of the 1998 constitutional language sought to join the case, a move that state attorneys deemed "irrelevant."

Read the complete brief here.

Comments

Dems vow to raise teacher pay

School leaders filled the Hillsborough High School auditorium Thursday to hear pitches from two of this year's Democratic candidates for governor.They were a study in contrasts as they addressed the Hillsborough Association of School Administrators: ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Teachers complain about campaign material in their email

Teachers complain about campaign material in their email

This post has been updated with the candidate's response.Laurie Rodriguez opened her Hillsborough County School District email and found a campaign flyer for Steve Cona, a builders association executive who is running for School Board.Rodriguez, a te...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Florida’s teacher shortage is ‘real, and it’s going to get worse,’ State Board of Ed member worries

Florida’s teacher shortage is ‘real, and it’s going to get worse,’ State Board of Ed member worries

As millions of Florida's school children returned to classes this week, many schools struggled to find enough teachers greet and teach them."We are very concerned about the growing teacher shortage," Cathy Boehme of the Florida Education Associa...
Published: 08/16/18
Florida education news: Budgets, audits, board races and more

Florida education news: Budgets, audits, board races and more

BUDGETS: Florida Board of Education members say local school districts should have more flexibility in how they spend their resources, while kicking off planning for their next legislative budget request. Teacher salaries and school security top...
Published: 08/16/18
Brooksville Elementary gets new principal

Brooksville Elementary gets new principal

Mike Lastra has been chosen as the new principal of Brooksville Elementary School, Hernando County school district announced Wednesday.He follows Jill Renihan, who recently left the position to take a job as the district's new director of s...
Published: 08/15/18
Florida Board of Education supports funding flexibility as it discusses budgets

Florida Board of Education supports funding flexibility as it discusses budgets

Teacher pay and school security topped the list of concerns for Florida Board of Education members Wednesday as they kicked off their annual legislative budget request process.Though they wondered where they might find the money for any added ex...
Published: 08/15/18
Achievement schools are getting those needed teachers

Achievement schools are getting those needed teachers

At Tuesday's Hillsborough County School Board meeting, Superintendent Jeff Eakins answered our questions about the 50 Achievement Schools and lingering teacher vacancies. The district's communications office gave us more information that we will shar...
Published: 08/15/18
State audit shows some students improperly received Florida Tax Credit Scholarships

State audit shows some students improperly received Florida Tax Credit Scholarships

To be eligible for a Florida Tax Credit Scholarship, children must meet specific financial criteria including household income standards.When issuing scholarships between 2015-2017, funding organization Step Up For Students did not pro...
Published: 08/15/18
Florida education news: Teacher pay, birthday treats, water supply and more

Florida education news: Teacher pay, birthday treats, water supply and more

TEACHER PAY: Pasco County School Board members said they want to look for money in the district budget to give employees raises. So far, they've asked questions but come up with no solid answers.TRANSPARENCY: Hillsborough County school dist...
Published: 08/15/18
Pasco School Board members ask questions, await answers in pursuit of money for raises

Pasco School Board members ask questions, await answers in pursuit of money for raises

Pasco County School Board members say they want to give employees pay raises this year.In the two weeks since declaring their desire, though, the board members have not submitted a single idea to the administration they say they would support to...
Published: 08/14/18