Wednesday, October 17, 2018

Former Florida Supreme Court chief justice: Amendment 8 ‘misleading,’ ‘deceptive’

It's still a long way to November, when voters will be asked to vote up or down on 13 proposed amendments to the state constitution. But only a few so far have generated as much debate as Amendment 8, a measure that is the subject of a lawsuit filed by the League of Women Voters.

The amendment is a combination of three separate education proposals which were rolled into one. It would: (1) create eight-year term limits for school board members, (2) enshrine in the constitution the civics education graduation requirement that currently exists in state law and (3) pave the way for the Legislature to create a separate body to authorize and oversee charter schools, outside of the authority of the local school boards.

The lawsuit has its first hearing August 17, yet former Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Charles T. Wells has already decided where he stands: opposed.

Wells offered his thoughts in an unprompted eight-page "opinion," sent first to the League and then the Times/Herald. Wells now works at an Orlando law firm, which is not representing any of the parties in the suit.

"This significant change from local county school board control … is hidden by packaging the change with what are thought to be attractive proposals for term limits and civics education," Wells wrote. "In reality, the terms limits and civics education proposals are only bait to attract voters to vote yes for Amendment 8."

Wells was appointed by Democratic governor Lawton Chiles and served on the court from 1994 to 2009, serving as chief justice from 2000 to 2002. Wells ruled against state school vouchers in the Bush v. Holmes decision.

The true purpose of the amendment, argues Wells, is to "overrule" a previous court decision by the First District Court of Appeal, which struck down a statewide charter school authorizer by finding it unconstitutional. That decision was referenced several times in the Constitution Revision Commission's discussion of the amendment during the drafting process.

The fact that the proposal's summary does not mention that original case is one of the reasons why it's "misleading" and "deceptive," Wells wrote.

You can read his entire "opinion" here.

RELATED COVERAGE: Explaining 13 constitutional amendments on Florida's ballot

Gradebook podcast: Supporting Amendment 8, with Erika Donalds of the Florida Constitution Revision Commission

Comments
Pasco school district gets strong credit ratings for upcoming issue

Pasco school district gets strong credit ratings for upcoming issue

In advance of selling $67.5 million in certificates of participation, the Pasco County school district sent several high level officials to New York to pitch for a good credit rating.The effort paid off, chief finance officer Olga Swinson told t...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Pasco County school employee contract talks turn to salaries

Pasco County school employee contract talks turn to salaries

After a two month break while awaiting updated financial data, negotiators for Pasco County school employees and the district administration return to bargaining this week, with plans to start talking pay.The United School Employees of Pasco intends ...
Published: 10/17/18
Florida education news: Turnarounds, rebuilding, funding and more

Florida education news: Turnarounds, rebuilding, funding and more

TURNAROUNDS: Hernando County's long struggling Moton Elementary School takes advantage of a state "Hope" grant to establish a family resource center for its students and parents. The goal is to help with issues outside school that impact academi...
Published: 10/17/18
Lee Elementary — or whatever it will ultimately be called — will be rebuilt in Tampa

Lee Elementary — or whatever it will ultimately be called — will be rebuilt in Tampa

Things have come full circle as the Hillsborough County School District moves ahead to rebuild fire-ravaged Lee Elementary School.The board on Tuesday unanimously approved a plan that the district negotiated with its insurers that pays full cost of b...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Pasco School Board, teachers take stands for improved education funding

Pasco School Board, teachers take stands for improved education funding

Stating the need for increased funding, about a dozen Pasco County teachers rallied Tuesday outside the school district headquarters for candidates and issues they say support public education."I believe that's what this year's election should really...
Published: 10/16/18
Florida superintendents association sets up account to help hurricane-hit school districts

Florida superintendents association sets up account to help hurricane-hit school districts

Hurricane Michael blasted at least 10 north Florida school districts, razing some campuses and leaving others unusable.Seven districts — Bay, Calhoun, Franklin, Gadsden, Jackson, Liberty and Washington — remain closed indefinitely, a...
Published: 10/16/18
Florida education news: Sales tax, scholarships, ballot language and more

Florida education news: Sales tax, scholarships, ballot language and more

SALES TAX: With limited funding, the campaign for a Hillsborough County schools sales tax increase relies on parent volunteers to get the word out. If approved, the revenue will pay for air conditioning repairs, among other construction and main...
Published: 10/16/18
Amendment 8 ballot language was ‘defective,’ Florida Supreme Court rules

Amendment 8 ballot language was ‘defective,’ Florida Supreme Court rules

The Florida Supreme Court removed Amendment 8 from the November 6 ballot because it failed to inform voters of its true purpose, the court stated in its opinion on the matter, released Monday."That the ballot summary is unclear is best demonstrated b...
Published: 10/15/18
Scholarship letters begin circulating for bullied Florida students

Scholarship letters begin circulating for bullied Florida students

Fifteen days after their official launch, Florida's new tax credit scholarships for students who claim being bullied in public school have begun being offered.Families that report any of 13 types of incidents, as outlined in law, are gettin...
Published: 10/15/18
When do Florida schools take buses off the roads?

When do Florida schools take buses off the roads?

35 miles per hour.That's the wind speed at which the Florida Department of Education has recommended school districts start pulling buses off the road, for safety's sake.The department sent the message to districts as Hurricane Michael churned n...
Published: 10/15/18