Projections show FAU, UWF and New College would lose money under performance funding model
State university system Chancellor Marshall Criser III is making the rounds at the Capitol this week, including a presentation at today’s Senate Education Committee meeting to talk about performance funding.
The 12-university system has asked the Legislature to allocation $50 million in new money to reward schools for meeting various goals, although Gov. Rick Scott’s budget proposal only included $40 million.
Whatever the final amount, it will be divided among the universities using 10 different criteria worth a maximum of 50 points. Universities must earn at least 26 points to get any new funding. Those that earn 25 point or less risk losing 1 percent of their 2014-2015 base funding; That money would then be redistributed to the other high-scoring schools.
We have received a copy of the projections, and the three schools expected to lose money are Florida Atlantic University, University of West Florida and New College of Florida. New College President Donal O'Shea said previously that he is one high-performing Pell grant recipient away getting the extra point needed to avoid a penalty.
The highest-scoring and highest-earning school, according to the projections, is the University of Florida, which would receive $11.7 million for its 42 points. Second place is the University of South Florida, which stands to receive $8.9 million for 37 points.
The three low-performing schools would all lose varying amounts of money, based on calculating 1 percent of their normal allocation from the state. FAU would be docked $1.4 million, UWF would lose $675,595 and New College would be $172,720 poorer.
Because the amount of performance money is based both on the points a school receives and its existing base funding, there are some weird outcomes in the projections.
For example, both Florida International University and University of Central Florida both were projected for 34 points, but their awards are $7.3 million and $8.8 million respectively. And Florida State University is projected to be awarded $1 million more than FIU, $8.6 million, even though it scored one point less. That is because FIU has a smaller base funding –- which depends on enrollment and historical allocations from the state -- than the other two schools.
Schools earn points for achieving set goals or showing improvement, whichever is higher. Here are the 10 criteria:
1. percent of bachelor's degree graduates employed or continuing their education
2. Average wages of employed bachelor degree graduates
3. Cost to university per undergraduate degree
4. Six-year graduation rate
5. Academic progress rate (second-year retention with GPA above 2.0)
6. Bachelor's degrees Awarded in areas of strategic emphasis (includes science, technology, engineering and math)
7. Percent of undergraduates with a Pell grant (university access rate)
8a. Graduate Degrees Awarded in areas of strategic emphasis (includes STEM)
8b. For New College only since it doesn't have graduate programs: Freshman in top 10 percent of graduating high school class
9. Board of Governors choice for each school
10. Board of Trustees choice for each school