Tampabay.com

MAY 23, 2012

Phillip Phillips continues dominance of cute, unassuming white guys as American Idol champs

phillip_phillips.jpgLet me make one thing clear: Phillip Phillips seems like a really nice guy.

Watching him get so emotional during his final, triumphant moment on the American Idol stage, I had tremendous respect for a guy who just stopped trying to sing his final number and walked off the stage to hug his family, minutes after winning the biggest singing competition on television.

But Phillips is also an example of what seriously ails American Idol these days: The backwards taste of its voters.

As a singer, Phillips should lands in third place among this season's top three contestants, behind runner up Jessica Sanchez and third place finisher Joshua Ledet. If there was any doubt, Sanchez destroyed that during tonight finale, going toe-to-toe with the biggest belter in the the business, Jennifer Holiday, on her signature song And I Am Telling You.

(To be honest, too much of that duet sounded like off-the-chain shouting, the musicality of the moment destroyed by two amazing singers breathing fire in an attempt to one-up each other.)

When he isn't coming off like a clone of eccentric rocker Dave Matthews, Phillips is an interesting artist. But on Tuesday's show, two of the three numbers he sang sounded like Matthews knock offs, leaving me puzzled as to exactly what kind of record this guy is going to create when he's finally unleashed in the studio. The ballad he sang Tuesday, Home, was a great start, touching and melodic, fitted perfectly to his style and voice (Sanchez was undone,at least in part, by some uninspired songs chosen for her Tuesday -- something even the judges noticed)

idollogo.jpgSanchez is a diva in the classic sense, able to "sing the phone book" as judge Randy Jackson loves to say (the chorus of Idol semi-finalists singing from phone books was a nice touch in tonight's finale). Ledet is another Al Green-level soul belter who can have Nee Yo's career or John Legend's.

Look at the Billboard Hot 100, and you've got to get down to #19 before you hit a singer/songwriter with a guitar -- and he's country music star Eric Church.

Once again, Idol voters -- presumably the middle-aged women who make up the bulk of the show's audience these days -- have chosen a cute, unassuming white guy singer songwriter over performers who seem more in line with the artists currently selling on Billboard's charts.

Already, I've heard from legions of Phillips fans who disagree, insisting he's a breakout artist who will transcend the long line of disappointing white guy singer songwriters who have preceded him. But Phillips is the fifth-straight white male to win the Idol crown; and before Scotty McCreery hit big on the country side, winner Lee DeWyze was the worst-selling winner in Idol history, already kicked off his record label.

Idol ratings Tuesday were down about 30 percent from the penultimate episode last year, as the relentless optimism of the judges -- who seemed to outsource most every negative comment to record label head and unofficial "fourth judge" Jimmy Iovine -- has made the contest's later rounds less than compelling.

Tonight's finale only highlighted Idol's issues, allowing judge Steven Tyler to play a song with Aerosmith so tuneless and filled with muffed guitar notes, I wondered if axeman Joe Perry was too blasted to play. Jennifer Lopez, who has turned Idol into her own personal promotional vehicle, also soaked up the spotlight with another dance tune with vocals auto-corrected to the nth degree.

Tampa Bay area singers Shannon Magrane and Jeremy Rosado made several appearances during the finale, singing in group numbers including a tribute to deceased Bee Gee Robin Gibb.

But most of Idol's finale was just too much -- trying way too hard to convince viewers it is still the massive hit it once was, whistling past the tendency by the show's audience to pick the same kind of winners over and over with diminishing returns. ... Read more

MAY 23, 2012

My take on the fall 2012 TV season (including appearances on NPR and TV One): Comedy is king (and queen) again

mk_20-mindy-pink_1994_jw2.jpgIt's the same question I always ask, just after network TV's upfronts week; when we learn what shows were canceled, picked up or hung out to dry (hint: everything airing on low-rated Fridays).

What just happened?

There's always the usual ratio of well-meaning failures (ABC's Pan Am, CBS's A Gifted Man), out-of-their-misery cancellations (NBC's Are You There Chelsea) and no-brainer new shows (brilliant Office alum Mindy Kaling's The Mindy Project on Fox).

And there's always a few head-scratchers. Another Matthew Perry sitcom (NBC's Go On)?

Still, there are some trends worth dissecting. Here's my short list of What I Learned from the Upfronts:

Comedy will be king (and queen), at least for another year. Thanks to Modern Family and Fox's New Girl, the Big Four TV networks picked up a total 17 new comedies for next season. Fox paired Kaling's show with Zooey Deschanel's New Girl; CBS moved Two and a Half Men to Thursdays behind Big Bang Theory and NBC created comedy blocks from Tuesday through to Friday. (My question: Can the network that renewed Whitney really be trusted with four nights of comedy?)

Everything old is new again, but no one admits it. In November, ABC will bring back Tim Allen's Last Man Standing on Fridays with Reba McEntire's new sitcom Malibu Country; a pairing that feels a lot like the network's old T.G.I.F. family comedy lineup. Similarly, Big Bang and Men could help CBS create a slight echo of NBC's mighty Must-See TV lineup Thursdays (though Fox's X Factor might have something to say about that).

the-voice-social-media-television.jpgSocial media remains an important talking point. Every network talked up social media to keep shows in touch with fans and avoid looking stodgy. ABC entertainment head Paul Lee noted, "There is no show now that doesn't have a massive social media component, even before we launch it…(it) gives us a critical insight into the show."

That may help explain why a viewer-challenged series such as Community, with strong online followings, survived NBC's cut.

Not all new technology is welcome. Nearly every network executive criticized Dish Network's new Auto Hop feature allowing its digital video recorders to automatically skip commercials without fast forwarding. NBC Broadcasting chairman Ted Harbert called it "an attack" on network TV's business; CBS TV president Les Mooves said it was "illegal." Network executives earn money from DVR ratings by insisting viewers still get some exposure to commercials because they must fast forward past them. Dish's feature removes that pretense; expect a lawsuit before the dust clears.

On screen diversity jumps a little bit. So far, there are two new network TV shows next season where a non-white actor is the sole star: The Mindy Project with Kaling, who is of Indian descent, and NBC's Infamous, a midseason show starring The Game alum Meagan Good, who is black. Elsewhere, actors of color appear in co-starring roles: Andre Braugher on ABC's Last Resort, Anthony Anderson among three dads on NBC's Guys with Kids and Lucy Liu as a new school Dr. Watson on CBS' Sherlock Holmes remake, Elementary.

Just 27 years after Bill Cosby led one TV's most successful comedies ever, the glass ceiling is finally splintering.

No wonder network TV so often resembles a look back at the future.

 

... Read more

MAY 23, 2012

Donald Driver's win on Dancing with the Stars actually makes me miss Bristol Palin and Kirstie Alley

168012_donald-driver-and-peta-murgatroyd-celebrate-winning-the-season-14-dancing-with-the-stars-mirrorball-.jpgWhen NFL star Donald Driver won ABC's Dancing with the Stars Tuesday, I realized something:

Everything I used to hate about this show, I have begun to miss tremendously.

Even though it's my job to keep up with these programs, Dancing with the Stars hasn't gotten much attention from me this season. That's because it started its run seriously deficient on one thing -- actual stars -- and finished without much of the other thing, interesting conflicts.

Back when the show was more newsworthy, snarking about tabloid fixtures such as Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino, Kirstie Alley or Bristol Palin at least provided some marginal excuse for keeping up with the program.

But this season's crop of stars -- Gladys Knight, Melissa Gilbert, Jaleel White -- were both scandal-free and seriously lacking in celebrity power. Indeed, the final three dancers -- Driver, telenovela star William Levy and classical singer Katherine Jenkins -- were likely among the least-known "stars" in a crop of decidedly low-profile competitors.

Didn't help that Driver, a smoothly-chiseled wide receiver for the Green Bay Packers, fits a common mold for DWTS winners, as the seventh professional athlete and third NFL player to win in 14 seasons.

Small wonder the show is planning an all-star edition next, trying to bring back some of the celebrities it's audience sparked with before.

It may be the last move left for a show which has increasingly struggled to find celebrities big enough to fulfill the program's name.

Takes a lot to get me to miss Bristol Palin and Kirstie Alley. But DWTS just might have done it.

 

Get More: Music News ... Read more

MAY 22, 2012

Tampa Bay Times ends temporary 5 percent pay cut for staffers, starting July 2

times_logo_stacked_blk_url.jpgNo one can deliver this news better than Times Publishing Co. CEO and Chairman Paul Tash, so here's the text of his memo to staff about the end of the pay reductions implemented last year, announced at a 2 p.m. meeting today:

From Paul Tash

I am delighted to report this news: We are ending the temporary 5 percent pay reduction we put in place last September. The change takes effect Monday, July 2, and will show up in paychecks on Friday, July 13.

The Tampa Bay Times continues to attract new readers, and there are encouraging signs that advertisers are following them to Florida's favorite newspaper. This decision represents a bet that we can keep those trend lines headed in the right direction, and that we can keep finding ways to reduce other expenses.

With pay restored, of course, we will provide no more extra days off, but we are giving staffers an extra month --- through June 30 -- to use any days they have remaining.

In this fragile economy, I cannot promise that there is only smooth sailing ahead. But your dedication and commitment have kept the Times moving forward, no matter what. I thank each of you for your contributions to our collective success. Now, let's redouble our efforts to accelerate our gains. ... Read more

MAY 22, 2012

Here's why The Avengers really worked: Filmmakers embraced comics storylines instead of "improving" them

the-avengers1.jpgThis isn't my normal pop culture turf, but as a serious comic book fanboy who has seen The Avengers movie twice, I wanted to take a moment to talk about something I've noticed in how some people are talking about this film.

Comic book culture -- like a lot of so-called "genre" areas such as science-fiction and fantasy -- are often a serious litmus test for consumers: either you get it and love it, or you don't. Which is why I truly understand how some critics feel about seeing comic book heroes take over the blockbuster summer movie season; if you don't like superheroes and the trappings of the genre, it can feel like the idiots have taken over the asylum.

But then comes a movie like The Avengers (and Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight before that) which flips the script by being a great movie about superheroes. And suddenly, folks who could shrug off crap like The Green Lantern have to figure a reason why this comic book movie stuff actually works (or they could just pretend it's a crappy movie, like this guy).

That's what came to mind when I read this Washington Post essay about why the film works. I have no idea if the author knows much about the comic book world, but the tone falls somewhere between bewilderment and condescension, with an odd objective: finding an acceptable reason to like this entertaining movie.

the-avengers-image-hulk.jpgHer conclusion: The actors elevate the material. His evidence is Mark Ruffalo, an actor with lots of cool cred for serious film fans, who does an amazing job playing Bruce Banner as a geeky, brilliant, cynical, tortured guy whose buttoned down exterior obviously hides something dark and scary.

"On paper, the Hulk doesn’t immediately look like the kind of material an actor of Ruffalo’s sensitivity and intelligence would be drawn to. In fact, many of Ruffalo’s fans — with visions of Nicolas Cage’s career dancing in their heads — first greeted the Hulk casting news with trepidation bordering on outrage (not Our Mark!)."

the-avengers-2012-movie-poster4.jpgWhy not Our Mark? Actors cool as Jack Nicholson, Heath Ledger, Robert Downey Jr., Samuel L. Jackson and Willem Dafoe have played amazing characters in comic book movies.  The fact is, these roles can be a blast if written well, and Ruffalo takes a part two other fine actors have played in recent years and wrings new substances and emotional notes from it.

I love the notion that Ruffalo's Banner is a smart, sophisticated angry guy who always seems on a low boil. That's one of the film's money lines: "I'm always angry."

But The Avengers' greatness isn't just about the actors nailing all their roles. It's about something bigger.

This movie works because the guy who made it, director/producer Joss Whedon, knows comic books intimately and embraced the way they tell stories. There was no attempt to "artify" the movie with grand ideas or dumb down the action by turning it into a succession of effects-filled fight scenes.

Most importantly, he didn't try to re-invent the wheel by coming up with new storylines; he pulled together a story from some of the most successful Avengers plotlines and characters already out there. 

Believe me, I know the love of comics is an acquired taste. I tried explaining the plot of The Avengers to a friend during lunch recently, and it sounded so geeky even I wanted to stick a sock in my mouth.

But the fact is, this is a storytelling form with literally 60 or 70 years worth of history. Captain America first appeared in comics in 1941. Thor debuted in 1962. Iron Man bowed the next year. Every one of these characters is older than I am, yet when some filmmakers take on these franchises, they ignore decades of storytelling in which concepts and plotlines have been road tested and explored.

greenlanterngreenarrow85.jpgThe great failure of Green Lantern, if you ask me, is that filmmakers ignored years of more modern stories featuring the character after its debut, copying a creaky origin story which was first published in 1959.

What gives me hope about the new Superman movie, is that director Zack Snyder is such a comics geek he faithfully translated a comic book even many fans doubted could ever reach the silver screen, Alan Moore's subversive Watchmen.

Watching The Avengers was so much fun precisely because it felt like the best superhero team-up books brought to life. These are sophisticated heroes -- at first they don't trust S.H.E.I.L.D., with good reason, or each other -- and every character gets several quality moments in the spotlight.

Imagine a filmmaker creating a western with no knowledge of classic Sergio Leone or Sam Peckinpah films. Or attempting a Hercule Poirot film with little knowledge of (or respect for) Agatha Christie. (that's language film nerds can understand)

For this fanboy geek, the real triumph of The Avengers is its lessons for other filmmakers.

Respect the comic book storytelling form. Because it works.

'Nuff said. ... Read more

MAY 21, 2012

As Fox's House shuffles off the dial tonight, I ask: When should an aging show call it a day?

hugh-laurie-3.jpgFor fans of quality television, it may be the most important question of all.

How do you know when it's time for a long-running TV series to call it a day, already?

The question arises as Fox's House prepares to ride into the sunset tonight after nearly eight years on air, concluding its story of a tortured, misanthropic doctor who tackles cases like a medical Sherlock Holmes with a two-hour finale.

The final episode's title, "Everybody Dies," calls back to the premiere episode "Everybody Lies," while also serving as a perfect summation of lead character Gregory House's sunny attitude.

Producers won't say much about what happens in tonight's finale, beyond noting the return of Allison Cameron (Jennifer Morrison), Remy "Thirteen" Hadley (Olivia Wilde) and the doctor who killed himself, Lawrence Kutner (Kal Penn). The first hour, "Swan Song," is a retrospective on the past eight seasons, with "Everybody Dies" as the hourlong final finale.

Count me among those former fans who felt this show should have shuffled off the schedule a few years ago.

I once incensed a friend (okay, he was former Tampa Bay Times metro columnist Howard Troxler) by showing him how, years ago, the medical stories on House were so formulaic you could set your watch by the symptoms patients endured (a seizure by 15 minutes in; bloody vomit by 30 minutes in; a life-threatening cure that won't work by 40 to 45 minutes in; actual cure by 10 minutes before the episode's end).

Thankfully, the show has gotten better. Still, as the most compelling part of the series also got outlandish — consummating House's long-standing flirtation with rigid boss Dr. Lisa Cuddy (Lisa Edelstein) in an awkward romance which ended when cost-cutting forced the show to eliminate her character — there were fewer reasons to tune in each week.

desperate-housewives-house.pngSeries star Hugh Laurie, who earns a reported $700,000 per episode molding his British tones into House's angular American bark, gave a different reason for the show's ending on NPR's Fresh Air with Terry Gross.

"The character is so inherently self-destructive to the point of being virtually suicidal, that a fictional character cannot sustain that suicidal tension indefinitely," Laurie told Gross. "You can't have a man on a window ledge threatening to jump forever.  At some point, he's got to jump or get back into the building, because the crowd below — who are either urging him to jump or not jump — eventually will lose interest."

Laurie has a point. House is such an extreme antihero, even in a TV universe filled with them, that keeping him entertaining while pushing the boundaries of his pathology for 177 episodes was nothing short of a miracle.

U.S. television could take a hint from the Brits, who often limit their most popular series to bursts of three, four or five seasons, walking away from even popular series such as the original version of The Office after three seasons.

Instead, American television milks a popular show until one of three things brings it down: a lack of creative ideas, a drop in the ratings, or escalating costs. Or, sometimes, all three at once.

That, for example, is what killed ABC's Desperate Housewives, a show that started as a cultural phenomenon and finished its run last week with so little buzz some critics were asking in finale stories, "Who still watches Desperate Housewives?"

But Laurie promised the Associated Press that House's finale would have no such saving graces. "Is he gonna step forward or step back?" said the actor of the episode, which features House treating a drug-addicted patient. "Is it life or is it death? I can say no more than that."

The only thing it really can't be, given Gregory House's acerbic legacy, is boring or sentimental.

... Read more

MAY 21, 2012

Tampa Bay Times sportswriters Rick Stroud and Tom Jones to lead morning show on WDAE-AM

49013.stroud.jpgTampa Bay Times sportswriters Tom Jones (bottom right) and Rick Stroud (right) will star in a new weekday morning show for sports radio station WDAE-AM (620), sparking a closer alliance between the newspaper and station owner Clear Channel Radio.

The pair begin hosting their three-hour show at 6 a.m. Tuesday, taking the timeslot once held by Dan Sileo — a former professional and college football player who was fired March 13 after inadvertently calling three black football players “monkeys” in a passing reference. The announcement of the new show was delivered after days of fanfare at 4 p.m. today during WDAE afternoon guy Steve Duemig's show.

“I think there’s a need for a show where you can bring the insights of a working journalist,” said Stroud, noting Clear Channel called him and Jones separately not long after Sileo left the job.

“A lot of people do commentary and a lot of people get animated,” he added. “As far as providing insight and accurate information…that’s something there’s a need for and we can do very well.”

As an opinion columnist covering sports media, Jones has a bit more freedom than Stroud, who must avoid jones_tom_wp_9987a.jpgbias while covering the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

“I wouldn’t say anything on the radio that I wouldn’t write for the newspaper,” said Jones, who will stop covering local sports radio to avoid conflicts of interest. “We talk to the coaches, we know the general managers. I would use the same standards on radio as in print.”

If discussions started in March, why did it take so long to finalize a deal?

“It was the first opening in our main lineup for eight years; we wanted to make sure we looked at everything,” said Steve Versnick, program director at WDAE, who initially called Stroud and Jones. “It’s our hope we’ll go at least another eight years before we have to make another lineup change.”

Another reason for delay: the newspaper’s ethical standards required executives at Clear Channel and the Tampa Bay Times to agree on a special policy for handling on air endorsements.

Such promotional announcements, a routine feature for radio personalities who aren’t journalists, draw a premium fee from advertisers.

But traditional journalists rarely directly endorse commercial products, to avoid the perception that their credibility can be bought.

wdae.jpgSo Jones and Stroud will donate their portion of proceeds from any endorsements to charities selected by the Tampa Bay Times. They will also read a disclaimer announcing the arrangement at the end of each show.

Times editor Neil Brown acknowledged the charity arrangement was new ground for the newspaper, keeping Stroud and Jones from directly profiting by endorsements, though businesses will still be paying for their on air recommendations.

“I was looking to create a bridge between the world of radio and the newspaper world,” said Brown, who retains final approval over each endorsement. “I wanted to inoculate them so their journalism is not compromised.”

Both men have non-newspaper media experience; Stroud has appeared on WDAE and ESPN as an expert analyst while Jones, who once covered the Tampa Bay Lightning, also once hosted a show on Bright House Networks’ sports channel.

They guest hosted WDAE's morning show on a Thursday and Friday in mid-April and stand ready to enter a competitive timeslot which includes sister station WFLA-AM's AM Tampa Bay and WHPT-FM's Bubba the Love Sponge Clem.

But the biggest challenge, Jones admitted, may be getting up at 4 a.m. every weekday. “I know that part will be tough,” he said, laughing, “But it’s what I’ve always wanted to do.”

... Read more

MAY 21, 2012

Mad Men recap: What will a man do to keep his life and dignity?

s5ep52.jpgWhat is a man willing to do to hold on to his life?

That's the question at hand in Mad Men's latest episode, "Christmas Waltz," which finds Sterling Cooper financial executive Lane Pryce resorting to the worst sort of fraud to pay off a debt back in his native England, forging partner Don Draper's signature on a check to raise $8,000 in days.

The actual plan he enacted was slick and a reminder of how much power these executives can have in their own financial world. Needing cash quickly, he wheedles an extra $50,000 in credit, uses that income to claim a surplus and suggests paying Christmas bonuses to everyone -- including himself, of course -- right away.

The plan unravels, however, when a big advertiser pulls back on adwork after a strike and the partners decide to hold off on their own bonuses until the New Year -- after Lane has already forged Don's signature and spent the money.

This puts Lane into a serious jam in two ways -- first, his check will stick out as the only partner to get a bonus before Christmas, and with the drop in revenue, meeting the extra debt payments will cause problems.

I'm wondering how long it will be before office manager extraordinaire Joan Harris discovers what Lane has done. And once she realizes, will she blow the whistle on him or will he try to lay the blame on her?

ep.510-harryandlakshimi.jpgWhat I love most about Lane's story here is the banal way his embezzlement occurred. I have noticed a spate of stories locally and nationally about huge sums swindled by people entrusted with the financial keys to municipalities and organizations. You wonder "How does someone steal $200,000 like swiping $10 from petty cash?"

Mad Men showed us how: By bowing to financial pressures while striving to keep up a proud facade.

This episode also marked the return of Paul Kinsey, the rudderless copywriter whose ill-fated romance with a black freedom rider only hinted at his aimless search for fulfillment outside the strait-laced world of New York advertising. Now stuck recruiting converts to Hare Krishna, Kinsey wants former colleague and Sterling Cooper TV buyer Harry Crane to help get his spec Star Trek script to NBC.

Nice as it was to see an old annoying character brought even lower, this storyline felt a bit outlandish -- especially when another Krishna convert, Lakshimi, sleeps with Harry in his office to get him to back off helping Kinsey. But since she doesn't threaten to tell his wife, I'm not quite sure why this was supposed to keep him away (though her punctuating the demand with a smack across the face was a nice touch; an ex-prostitute working the pimp role to the extreme.)

sal-romano.jpgI left this bit of story wishing creator Matt Weiner had done something like this with Sal Romano, the gay art director fired after he spurned a closeted gay client's affections in Season Three. Fans have longed for a callback to Sal for a while; can't remember any fan dismay when Kinsey was given his walking papers.

But my favorite moment from this episode was seeing Joan and Don spend time together. They remain the two demigods of Sterling Cooper, instantly understanding and respectful of each other; moments when they can spend time with each as friends and let their guard down is amazing.

ep.510-joananddoninbar.jpgWeiner knows some fans love seeing them together as a couple, so having Don take Joan to test drive a Jaguar after she gets divorce papers from her rapist husband was a nice touch. Life is shoving Joan into a single mom role she never envisioned for herself; Don gently reminds her she can find a good man if she tries.

And Joan's observation that divorce worked out for Don is contrasted by the very next scene, in which second wife Megan freaks because Don was unavailable for much of the day. She can't help being paranoid that he will eventually go back to old ways and cheat on her; the firm's effort to get Jaguar means he'll be working longer hours than ever.

Wonder how long that situation is going to last?

 

... Read more

MAY 20, 2012

Why didn't Saturday Night Live just let Kristen Wiig host her last show as a castmember?

snl-mick-jagger_320.jpgMuch as I wanted to love Saturday Night Live's season finale -- which had the double whammy of being both Mick Jagger's return to hosting after umpteen years and star Kristen Wiig's final show as a castmember -- I had one thought when it ended.

Why didn't they just make this show a tribute to Wiig and let her host it?

By far, the most poignant moment was the ending, featuring every castmember dancing and hugging Wiig to the strains of the Rolling Stones songs She's a Rainbow and Ruby Tuesday. Fans who track such things in the press know that Wiig is likely leaving the show after this season.

I say "likely" because neither Wiig nor SNL has actually confirmed this fact, though it was obvious from her tears and the cast's heartfelt hugs that she was hitting the road. It's no surprise for those who read the entertainment press -- in fact, co-stars Jason Sudeikis and Andy Samberg are also rumored to be exiting the show after this season.

mickwiig--525x315.jpgBut it's Wiig whose departure will likely be felt most. As the castmember who stepped up most after the departure of stars such as Will Ferrell and Tina Fey, Wiig's original characters -- the deformed Lawrence Welk singer, the crazy Target cashier, the ditzy quiz show contestant, the bizarro aunt movie reviewer -- were more entertaining than her stable of ace impressions, from Kathie Lee Gifford and Michelle Bachmann to Liza Minnelli and Fox News anchor Greta Van Susteren.

On Saturday, it was obvious the show wasn't quite sure what to do with Jagger, who didn't have any real product to push and has never been much of an actor. Sure, it was mildly amusing to watch him try copping a California accent, dress up like another fossilized rocker (American Idol judge Steven Tyler) or play an insurance salesman criticizing other people's Mick Jagger impressions.

But his performances with Arcade Fire and Foo Fighters mostly proved he hasn't got much of a voice anymore and the original blues tune he wrote--about the U.S. presidential election??--was mostly distinguished by how much more vibrant guitarist Jeff Beck is these days than Jagger.

It would have been so much cooler to turn Saturday's show into a Wiig tribute, packing the show with her best characters and skits. But instead, viewers had to hang until the show's final moments to see her tear up while everyone from Jon Hamm and Steve Martin to Chris Kattan and Rachel Dratch (?!) hopped onstage to wish her a wonderful farewell.

Our only solace as fans is that we know she'll be back as a host before long.

 

... Read more

MAY 18, 2012

Does Philip Phillips' success signal American Idol about to mistakenly choose another boring cute guy winner?

be9d86e8fc08f40d0f0f6a7067000816.jpgAmerican Idol, you were so close.

You had mostly left your reputation for overlooking your best contestants behind, as viewers embraced a field of singers who were more proficient, ethnically diverse and filled with women than in many years.

The success of powerhouse singer Jessica Sanchez belied the show's often bewildering toughness on female signers of color. And the continuing triumphs of gospel-drenched soul belter Joshua Ledet proved that Idol's problems rejecting soul singers were also in its past.

And then came Thursday's results, kicking off Ledet -- who seemed destined to face off against Sanchez in a battle of the big voices -- in favor of scruffy rocker Phillip Phillips, a Dave Matthews clone whose success seems much more about the mostly-female audience's preference for cute, unassuming guy singers.

Leaving aside the fact that Idol has been forced to tie itself in knots to present Phillips as an original artist -- he even moves like Matthews onstage, twisting geekily while strumming an acoustic guitar and talking in an offhand hipster mumble -- his presence in the finale signals the return of an ongoing problem for the show.

The dominance of the low-key, cute guy singer.

dewyze.jpgIdol dodged that bullet last year, handing victory to Scotty McCreery, a country singer who seemed tailor made for that genre's audience. Indeed, his debut album was certified platinum on Idol's stage months after its October debut -- still a far cry from the days when an Idol winner's first album would sell a million copies within days of release.

But now the show seems on the verge of crowning another unassuming white guy singer as champion, in the same way Lee DeWyze, Kris Allen, and David Cook took the top prize in the three seasons before McCreery's win.

Idol voters' tastes have often seemed diametrically opposed to what sells best in pop music.

British pop singer Adele was far and away 2011's top-selling artist, with country singer Jason Aldean the only artist in Billboard's Top Five selling albums coming anywhere close to Idol's cute guy singer mold (his self-titled album placed fifth in sales behind Michael Buble, Lady Gaga and Lil' Wayne)

So Idol voters have a clear choice now; a Sanchez win could hint at a new future where the show's winners fall closer to what is actually popular on the charts. Or they could pick another cute, unassuming guy destined to shrug his way into showbiz irrelevance.

The fate of TV's highest-rated reality show hangs in the balance.

  ... Read more

About the bloggers

The best TV shows, the worst shows, TV news, media issues and debates ... it's all here at the Feed, a blog on TV, media and modern life by Tampa Bay Times TV/media critic Eric Deggans. Possibly the most critical guy at the Times, he has served as music, media and TV critic at various times over 10 years.

E-mail Eric Deggans:
deggans@tampabay.com

Get updates from The Feed via Twitter


deggans
Twitter Badges

Advertisement

Advertisement

Video

Comment Policy

Please be sure your comments are appropriate before submitting them. Inappropriate comments include content that:
Is libelous
Is abusive, harassing, or threatening
Is obscene, vulgar, or profane
Is racially, ethnically or religiously offensive
Is illegal or encourages criminal acts
Is known to be inaccurate or contains a false attribution
Infringes copyrights, trademarks, publicity or any other rights of others
Impersonates anyone (actual or fictitious)
Solicits funds, goods or services, or advertises
The Tampa Bay Times does not edit posts but reserves the right to delete comments that violate our policy.

Awards and Honors

Ebonypower

Sunshine