Tampabay.com
JANUARY 07, 2009

Facebook unmoved by breastfeeding protest

Facebook isn't budging against pressure from lactivists to let them post pictures of children breastfeeding. When I wrote this story about the approaching Dec. 27 protest online of the popular social networking site's policy of deleting photos of babies being nursed, some 61,000 people had signed the site's online petition called "Hey Facebook, breastfeeding is not obscene." When I checked Tuesday afternoon, the number had ballooned to more than 142,000. The first five days of the year, the group was getting 10,000 new members a day.

That's about the number of people who defiantly posted breastfeeding pictures Mom_kellibreastfeeding online that day. There was artwork of Mary nursing Jesus, of cows nursing their calves and lots of Mommas feeding their babies, Stephanie Knapp Muir, one of the organizers, told me. But she was peppered with complaints that many had their photos removed and a terse letter from Facebook warning them not to do it again or risk losing their membership to the site.

Facebook is standing firm on the policy, a spokesman says almost two weeks after the story ate up the Mommy blogs and news wires worldwide. Facebook says it has no problem with breastfeeding, but that photos showing nipples are considered obscene and can be removed, especially if someone complains about them. With users as young as 13 allowed on the site, the company feels it is not public space, but protected private property.

Muir calls the company’s policy unfair toward women, who have the legal right in most states, including Florida, to breastfeed in public.

"We understand that children as young as 13 are permitted to use the site, and feel that if those young users should happen to come across a picture of a mother breastfeeding, it would be a far more positive and healthy exposure for them than the myriad other photos (including paid advertisements on the site) which contain far more explicit images of women's bodies, many of which are in a sexual context."

With news sites and blogs around the world weighing in on the controversy, it doesn't seem like it's going to die out. But Facebook spokesman Barry Schnitt said the company has no plans to change the policy. "The best thing users can do is follow the policy and make sure their breastfeeding photos do not show nudity,'' Schnitt said. "In addition, since we’re not proactively looking for these photos, if users limit access to people who won’t complain, we won’t really know about them."

-- Sharon Kennedy Wynne

[Photo: That's Kelli Roman, one of the women who joined in the Facebook protest, who posted this photo on her Facebook page that shows her breastfeeding her daughter Ivy. She says it was removed from the site even though it does not show her nipple.]

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

About the bloggers

Raising children isn't easy. Whoa, Momma! is here to help you with parenting tips and discussion of all parenting issues. We think there's no such thing as TMI, so our blogging moms aren't shy about the hot topics and won't back away from a good debate. Bottle or breastfeed? Public, private or homeschool? And sex -- it's all open for comment. Don't sit on the sidelines -- pull up a bouncy seat and join the chat.

Meet the authors

Email us ideas you'd like us to write about.

Advertisement

THE AUTHORS

Sharon Kennedy Wynne has sunscreen in her blood. She may have been born in Buffalo but she got here as fast as she could, in time for kindergarten. She grew up in St. Petersburg, graduated from the University of Florida journalism school, and even got married at Sunken Gardens. She's one of the few adults we know who actually loves taking her kids to the beach. She has two sons and with 10 years of parenting under her belt, she's starting to feel a little less out of her league. She comes from a large family and loves to debate, so brace yourself when the hot topics come up.

E-mail Sharon Kennedy Wynne:
wynne@tampabay.com

SP_255665_CROS_KATE.jpgAfter six long years of trying to have a baby, Kate Brassfield was finally able to have one. And then, two minutes later, another one. Suddenly the lady who had never been around babies before was juggling two! Just as Kate felt she was getting pretty good with babies, the girls became toddlers, and now Kate is back to Square One, learning about the care and feeding of these strange, wonderful creatures. She spends her days working part-time from home and trying to keep up with the Twinosaurus Wrecks.

E-mail Kate Brassfield:
katedaphne17@gmail.com

Freelance writer Courtney Cairns Pastor wasn’t so sure about having kids and how she would balance child-rearing with her journalism career. It turned out that her journalism training went to good use. As the mom to a funny, active toddler, she learned to handle him like she did her sources. Never ask yes or no questions (the answer will always be no), get him to be specific (are you crying because you’re wet or your tooth hurts?) and be prepared for anything because no two days are the same. When she’s not playing trucks, Courtney crams for her book club, trains for races and occasionally bursts into showtunes. E-mail her at courtneyblogs@gmail.com.

Suzannah DiMarzio has it bad for the Mouse. Although she grew up outside of Boston, she took her degree in tourism management down to Orlando just to work at Disney and the travel industry. Of course, when she married her high school sweetheart, the reception was at Disney. She’s now a seasoned stay-at-home mom to two tweens and a toddler – and yes, that is as crazy as it sounds. Suzannah has her own blog, ZannaLand.com , and she's a member of the Walt Disney World Moms Panel in addition to being addicted to Twitter, iced coffee, and watching way too much Yo, Gabba Gabba.

Registration FAQ

Read our Frequently Asked Questions on how to register to comment on the site.