Tampabay.com
DECEMBER 12, 2006

LISTEN TO THIS: Taylor Hicks Edition

TaylorNext Monday in Floridian, I'll be reviewing seven (7) of the newest American Idol releases, including Fantasia's latest, which is so shockingly good it's messing with my head. For now, though, here's a quickie look at Mr. Soul Patrol's debut, which was released today and will no doubt sell tons (40 copies to my mother at least).

TAYLOR HICKS

ALBUM: Taylor Hicks (Arista)

GRADE: C

WHY WE CARE: The world's oldest 30-year-old is the reigning American Idol champ, an incredibly earnest Everyman with a husky blue-eyed-soul voice, clunky dance moves and Newt Gingrich's hair. Hicks' rabid fanbase is called the Soul Patrol -- and no matter what I snark, they're gonna flip for this 12-track debut that might as well be Michael McDonald's third Motown album.

WHY WE DON'T REALLY LIKE IT: The pride of Birmingham, Ala., means well with his juke-joint cliches and Memphis horns, but seriously dude: When you sample Ray's What'd I Say and Marvin's Ain't That Peculiar IN THE SAME SONG, you're begging to get slapped. This guy "borrows" from so many people, I swear I saw a picture of my wallet in the liner notes. 

REMINDS US OF: Something we'd buy our mother for Christmas. (Just suck it up, sons and daughters. Target has it for $9.98.)

DOWNLOAD THESE: Dream Myself Awake (written by Rob Thomas), The Right Place (co-written by Bryan Adams)

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

About the blogger

Pop music critic Sean Daly of the Tampa Bay Times brings you the latest music news and concert reviews. He writes about rock music, country music, rap music and whatever sounds are out there. Cool job, isn't it? And his CD collection -- from Journey to Dylan, Prince to U2, Public Enemy to Stan Getz -- is much bigger and better than yours.

Features and columns archive
Get Pop Life updates via Twitter
Follow me on Facebook
Join the Stuck in the '80s fan page

Advertisement

Follow us on Facebook

TampaBay.com on Facebook

Registration FAQ

Read our Frequently Asked Questions on how to register to comment on the site.