Make us your home page

It's Hall of Fame day, and we take a closer look at the candidates

Astros first baseman Jeff Bagwell had seven 100-run/100-RBI seasons, won an MVP award (plus five other top-10 finishes) and was the 1991 Rookie of the Year.

Associated Press

Astros first baseman Jeff Bagwell had seven 100-run/100-RBI seasons, won an MVP award (plus five other top-10 finishes) and was the 1991 Rookie of the Year.



Today is Hall of Fame day, with the announcement of this year's election set for 6 p.m. on MLB Network.

Based on 235-plus released ballots, roughly half the total, it looks like OF Tim Raines, enjoying a bump of support in his final year of eligibility, and 1B Jeff Bagwell will receive the required 75 percent needed for election. Closer Trevor Hoffman and C Ivan Rodriguez, in his first year on the ballot, look to be close calls, and potentially OF Vlad Guerrero as well.

But almost as important as who gets in will be the expected rise in support for Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, the "poster boys" for the steroids era, who project to make big jumps to the 65 percent range, raising the possibilty of election in the near term.

Here is my ballot, followed by some thoughts on players I did and didn't vote for:

Jeff Bagwell
Barry Bonds
Roger Clemens
Trevor Hoffman
Fred McGriff
Tim Raines
Ivan Rodriguez
Gary Sheffield
Lee Smith

x-Jeff Bagwell
Complete player with seven 100-run/100-RBI seasons, MVP award (plus five other top-10 finishes), Rookie of the Year, Gold Glove.

x-Barry Bonds
Seven MVP awards, 8 Gold Gloves, 14 All-Star selections, .444 on-base pct., 762 home runs, 1,996 RBIs, 2,935 hits need to count for something.

Pat Burrell
This is for the Hall of Fame, right?

x-Roger Clemens
Seven Cy Young Awards (plus five other top-6 finishes), 354 wins, seven ERA titles, two triple crowns, MVP award (plus five other top-10 finishes) should, too.

Vladimir Guerrero
Won an MVP award with Angels, made All-Star team nine times, went 30-30 twice, averaged 35 homers for 11 seasons. His chances may improve going forward.

x-Trevor Hoffman
Second all-time in saves, after being first to reach 500 and 600. Led NL twice, had 30-plus in 14 of 15 seasons. Four top-10 Cy Young finishes, two top-10 MVP finishes.

Edgar Martinez
Was a great hitter (.312 avg. .933 OPS), but not a great overall player; 72 percent of his plate appearances as a DH. Close, but not quite Hall worthy.

Mike Mussina
Won 270 games and posted a 3.68 ERA while spending all 18 seasons in the rugged AL East, but didn't lead league at any point, didn't win a Cy Young and didn't win a World Series.

x-Fred McGriff
There's still a spot on this ballot, and should be in the Hall, for someone who hit 493 homers the old-fashioned way, averaging 30.55 over 15 seasons.

x-Tim Raines
Is arguably the second best leadoff hitter to Rickey, and his on-base and base stealing skills have become more appreciated over time. Appeared to get a bump in votes given it was his last year on the ballot, also may have been helped by strong social media support.

Manny Ramirez
He has so many numbers that make him Hall worthy - 555 HRs, .312 average, .996 OPS - and one that screams no: 2 PEDS suspensions.

x-Ivan Rodriguez
Basically redefined the position with his defensive prowess, and did work with the bat as well.

Curt Schilling
A great postseason pitcher, but has only 216 wins, no Cy Youngs and a career 3.46 ERA. That's enough reason to say no, before any concern over his repeated controversies.

x-Gary Sheffield
Menacing batsman totaled 509 HRs and 253 steals (one of only four with 500-250), won a batting title (career .292 avg., .393 OBP). Ask pitchers who they feared facing.

x-Lee Smith
A bit of a compiler, but his 478 saves were No. 1 when he retired, and still are third most all-time. Had 13 seasons of 25 or more, led his league four times in a dominant 11-year run.

Sammy Sosa
Getting caught with a corked bat - and against the Devil Rays nonetheless - was not a good look.

Billy Wagner
Never led his league, but his 422 saves are second most for a lefty, fifth overall. Better is his 0.998 WHIP, best of all relievers with 500 innings, and 2.31 ERA. May get in as competition for ballot space lessens.

Larry Walker
Another player who was very good but not great enough.


[Last modified: Wednesday, January 18, 2017 6:24am]


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours