Wednesday, May 23, 2018
  • Soundcheck

Sting with the Florida Orchestra: Pretentious pairing, or a brilliant idea? Let’s debate

Sting is coming to the Mahaffey Theater on Saturday — pretty small venue for one of pop music's biggest names, but he has a good reason.

Sting is the guest and performer of honor at a major fundraising gala for the Florida Orchestra, a major coup for the symphony and the city. With the orchestra's backing, he'll play songs like I Burn for You, Englishman in New York, Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic and Roxanne.

Our question: Is this a good thing, or a bad thing?

Times Pop Music/Culture Critic Jay Cridlin and Performing Arts Critic Andrew Meacham debated exactly that, wondering whether Sting's performance could be transformative or whether it might feel more pretentious than anything.

"The arrangements are different; it's not elevator music," Andrew said. "They enhance the songs, bring out a different dimension within the songs."

"But not unlike his mononymous buddy Bono," Jay said, "Sting has cultivated this reputation for being pretentious, for trying to steer the conversation about his artistry toward some higher-minded plain. Which is fine and all; good on him for it. I just hope this show with the Florida Orchestra is actually, you know, kind of fun."

For more of our debate about Sting and the Florida Orchestra, click here.

Comments
Want to drink free whiskey with country star John Rich in Tampa on Friday?

Want to drink free whiskey with country star John Rich in Tampa on Friday?

Here's an offbeat way to start your Memorial Day weekend right.Country star John Rich, half of the colorful, multiplatinum country duo Big and Rich, is coming to town for a couple of promotional appearances on Friday, including a tasting of his new w...
Updated: 19 minutes ago
Review: Kendrick Lamar’s ‘Championship Tour’ brings good sportsmanship, great rhymes to Tampa’s MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre

Review: Kendrick Lamar’s ‘Championship Tour’ brings good sportsmanship, great rhymes to Tampa’s MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre

Do they give Pulitzer Prizes for concerts featuring golf cart rides, cartoon sports-card backdrops and a slam-dunking doggie mascot?If so, Kendrick Lamar might want to start clearing shelf space for plaque No. 2.Weeks after the rapturous adulation th...
Updated: 3 hours ago
SZA will not appear at tonight’s Kendrick Lamar Championship Tour

SZA will not appear at tonight’s Kendrick Lamar Championship Tour

Singer SZA will not perform at Kendrick Lamar's Championship Tour at the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa Tuesday, organizers announced shortly before the concert. Lamar's Top Dawg Entertainment label posted the news on Twitter. The Gra...
Updated: 11 hours ago
The Dirty Heads talk backyard barbecues, shedding the ‘reggae rock’ label and more

The Dirty Heads talk backyard barbecues, shedding the ‘reggae rock’ label and more

It's hard to say, exactly, how many 97X events the Dirty Heads have played at this point. There were three Next Big Things, at least, plus an acoustic Green Room performance or two.And if you want to talk about shows in St. Petersburg, forget about i...
Published: 05/22/18
SoundBytes: Todd Rundgren, Zomboy, Doyle, Bob Log III and more

SoundBytes: Todd Rundgren, Zomboy, Doyle, Bob Log III and more

— The wizard is returning. Just a few weeks after performing at the Mahaffey Theater with his band Utopia, Todd Rundgren is performing at the Capitol Theatre on Aug. 18. Tickets are $39 and up. Click here.— The headliners have been announ...
Published: 05/21/18
SoundBytes: Prince, Penn and Teller, Joe Nichols, Colony House and more

SoundBytes: Prince, Penn and Teller, Joe Nichols, Colony House and more

— Prince is no longer with us, but his estate has approved a new symphonic tour of his music, to be curated by Questlove from the Roots. "4U: A Symphonic Celebration of Prince" is coming to the USF Sun Dome on Oct. 5. Tickets are $25 and up. Cl...
Published: 05/16/18
Review: Justin Timberlake works his magic in wondrous stage spectacle at Tampa’s Amalie Arena

Review: Justin Timberlake works his magic in wondrous stage spectacle at Tampa’s Amalie Arena

Justin Timberlake had to be sweating long before he let it show.He must have been drenched beneath his scruffy denim jacket, given all the heated hoofing he laid to the stage at Tampa's Amalie Arena Tuesday night, even if his inscrutably straight-lac...
Published: 05/16/18
Wiz Khalifa, Rae Sremmurd coming to the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa

Wiz Khalifa, Rae Sremmurd coming to the MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre in Tampa

What do you get when you mix Black and Yellow with Black Beatles?You get Wiz Khalifa and Rae Sremmurd, teaming up to take over America this summer.The Pittsburgh rapper and viral duo are joining forces for a summer tour that'll stop at Tampa's MidFlo...
Published: 05/15/18
Tampa Pig Jig 2018 lineup: Chris Young, Deer Tick, more coming to Curtis Hixon Park

Tampa Pig Jig 2018 lineup: Chris Young, Deer Tick, more coming to Curtis Hixon Park

The little festival that could just keeps getting bigger.The Tampa Pig Jig has just unveiled its most stacked concert lineup yet for its eighth edition, which returns to Curtis Hixon Park on Oct. 20.Country star Chris Young (Think Of You, I'm Comin' ...
Published: 05/15/18
Soulja Boy talks viral fame, Kanye’s tweets, ‘This Is America’ and more

Soulja Boy talks viral fame, Kanye’s tweets, ‘This Is America’ and more

The Dab. The Dougie. The Whip, the Nae Nae and the Stanky Leg.Each time you've done one of these dances, you might owe Soulja Boy a tip of your cap."I really do like the dancing, these new dances that they're coming out with. I feel like I'm a part o...
Published: 05/15/18