Garcia proposes five-year delay in flood rates, faces long odds
As Congress continues to struggle over resolving the flood insurance rate hike crisis that threatens thousands of Florida families, Miami Congressman Joe Garcia introduced legislation Thursday to delay the proposed rate increases for at least five years.
The bill is an effort to expand beyond the partial delay in flood rate increases included Monday in a massive spending bill pending before the House and Senate. Under that proposal, FEMA would delay rate increases for some properties who were expecting rate increases beginning this fall because of new flood maps but it didn't address properties already hit by huge increases. Download HOME Act of 2014
The proposal by Garcia, a Democrat, faces an uphill battle, however. House Speaker John Boehner said Thursday that the GOP-controlled House is “not going to do that” when asked about the legislation aimed at delaying the 2012 flood insurance fix.The temporary fix was tucked into the $1.1 trillion spending proposal pending before Congress but it does not apply to properties that already have been hit with higher insurance bills as a result of the Biggert Waters Flood Insurance Reform Act of 2012, which attempted to end subsidized insurance rates for homeowners covered by the National Flood Insurance Program.
The Biggert Waters Act requires homeowners to pay premiums commensurate with their true flood risk and requires FEMA to update flood maps across the country. But the rate increases, some of which took effect in October, have since sent a chill through Florida’s housing market, particularly in coastal counties with older homes that until now had the benefit of deeply subsidized premiums.
More than 268,000 Florida policyholders are expected to be hit with rate increases of between 20 to 400 percent under the act. Others are allowed to keep their subsidies but can’t pass them on when selling their homes.
Garcia’s proposal, which has the support of a handful of Florida Democrats, applies to all property owners covered by the National Florida Insurance Program, and provides the greatest relief to those hardest hit -- including an estimated 47,000 in Miami-DadeCounty, 11,000 in MonroeCounty, 50,000 in Pinellas and 14,000 in Hillsborough.
Garcia’s bill also establishes a tax credit of up to $7,500 for home owners who pay to raise their homes above the flood plain and conduct other flood mitigation efforts. It also authorizes FEMA to study the effects of the NFIP reforms and removes the current cap on the cost of that study.
“The impact of Biggert-Waters upon South Florida has been alarming and unacceptable,’’ Garcia said in a statement. “ I have had constituents see their insurance premiums jump from $2,000 to $49,000.”
A more modest proposal to delay the rate impact for two years is getting traction in the Senate, where Florida Sen. Bill Nelson has been instrumental in pushing it.
But opposition to the delay has also been strong among environmental and free market groups. SmarterSafer.org – a coalition of environmental groups, taxpayer advocates and insurance companies commended Boehner and the Union of Concerned Scientists and the conservative issued a statement Thursday urging lawmakers to resist delaying flood insurance reforms.
"Homeowners hit by insurance rate increases are understandably upset and calling for action from their senators. But continuing to subsidize flood insurance through the NFIP is not the answer, especially in the face of growing flood risks from sea level rise," the group said in a statement.
On the other side of the equation is Florida Gov. Rick Scott, who wants a delay in the flood insurance rate hikes because of their impact on the housing market. He sent a letter to President Barack Obama this week asking to talk with the president to urge him to use his executive authority to delay the implementation of the rate increases.