Make us your home page


Robert Trigaux

'Most troubled' banks double in Florida as recession hits lenders



BankunitedclosingfdicAPphoto The health of Florida’s 309 commercial banks declined dramatically in the first quarter of 2009, compared to the fourth quarter of 2008, as the number of banks deemed the most troubled doubled in number.

Twenty-one Florida-based banks were rated “zero” — the worst possible rating on a scale of zero to five “stars” — by the bank rating firm Bauer Financial Inc. In the previous quarter, ending Dec. 31, 2008, only ten Florida banks were rated zero, a designation indicating weak capital and a high volume of bad loans.

(AP photo: A regional ombudsman with the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp puts up a statement at the headquarters of BankUnited, seized by regulators this spring, in Coral Gables, Fla.)

The 21 zero star banks are concentrated along Florida’s gulf coast, most notably from Sarasota south to Naples. The locations of banks in greatest trouble mirror the state’s worst housing markets where foreclosures are highest and where price decline of homes for sale have been most severe.
There are exceptions Other secondary pockets of zero star banks in Florida can be found in Miami and Panama City.

Customers of weak banks should monitor their progress and be sure their deposits do not exceed the current limits of federal deposit insurance. Specifics on those limits can be found online at the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.

The rapid increase of zero star banks suggests Florida will see an increase in the pace of bank failures and federally-orchestrated sales of weak institutions in the coming months and in 2010. Only three Florida banks have failed in 2009 so far, though federal bank regulators have been busy in other parts of the country, notably in Georgia, closing and selling off troubled institutions.

None of Florida’s zero star banks are headquartered in the immediate Tampa Bay area. And some of them, such as Federal Trust Bank in Sanford and the Bank of Bonifay, have been sold to stronger institutions since March 31. But Sarasota’s First State Bank operates a majority of its offices in Pinellas County.

Bauer Financial also rated 16 Florida banks with just one star, a sign that at least some additional banks may be poised to become zero rated institutions later this year. In contrast, 18 Florida banks received five stars, including the First National Bank of Pasco in Dade City and Valrico State Bankin Valrico, They achieved Bauer’s highest ranking.

In Florida’s smaller credit union industry, four institutions were rated zero. One, Miramar-based Eastern Financial Florida Credit Union,is now in conservatorship and run by Space Coast Credit Union in Melbourne.

Both the data on commercial banks and credit unions are from March 31. The time lag is the result of the FDIC collecting industry data each quarter, and Bauer Financial's reorganizing the data to be more consumer friendly. 

-- Robert Trigaux, Times Business Columnist

[Last modified: Tuesday, June 1, 2010 11:25am]


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours