Sunday, May 27, 2018
Books

'The Long Road to Antietam' depicts power struggle behind Civil War battle that changed America

The casualty figures for the Battle of Antietam on Sept. 17, 1862, are astounding: Approximately 6,000 Union and Confederate soldiers killed; approximately 17,000 wounded. It was the single bloodiest day of combat in American history, with four times as many American casualties as occurred on D-Day in World War II.

Historian and cultural critic Richard Slotkin, an emeritus professor at Wesleyan University, is the author of an award-winning trilogy of scholarly books on American cultural history (Regeneration Through Violence, The Fatal Environment and Gunfighter Nation), among other works. In The Long Road to Antietam, he has written a riveting, perceptive analysis of the Civil War campaigns of 1862, of the reasoning behind the Emancipation Proclamation and of the complex power struggle between President Abraham Lincoln and the 35-year-old Union Commander of the Army of the Potomac, Gen. George B. McClellan.

Slotkin writes, "The significance of Antietam lies not in the battle itself but in the campaign that produced it … a radical turn in strategies of both Union and Confederacy … Before Antietam it was still possible for Americans to imagine a compromise settlement of sectional differences. After Antietam, and the Emancipation Proclamation," only an outright military victory by one side could settle things. And either way, Slotkin points out, would spell "a revolutionary transformation of American politics and society."

At the heart of this book is the persistent political and psychological contest between Lincoln and McClellan. Lincoln believed that "conciliation" with the South was conditional. He thought a president had the power to alter slavery, and he insisted that slavery "be started down the road to eventual extinction." McClellan, an archconservative white supremacist with strong political (yes, presidential) ambitions firmly, and correctly, believed that the South would never accept this.

But, by Antietam, Lincoln, seeing no other way to a solution to the crisis, was "determined to fight a war of subjugation, to restore the Union and begin the destruction of slavery by force."

Slotkin informs us that behind Lincoln's back, McClellan, the popular and promising commander of the Army dubbed "the Young Napoleon" by the press, would refer to Lincoln as a "well-meaning baboon" and "the original gorilla." And, as to the general's loyalty toward his commander in chief, Slotkin quotes McClellan's Aug. 9, 1861, letter to his wife, Mary Ellen: "I receive letter after letter ---- have conversation after conversation calling on me to save the nation … I will cheerfully take the Dictatorship."

As commander of the Army of the Potomac, McClellan was criticized during his life and after for dithering with his army in Washington in the fall and winter of 1861-62 while he should have been engaging the enemy. Even when rebels had managed to plant fortifications along the lower Potomac, subjecting Washington to an embarrassing blockade, McClellan refused to take action.

It's true that the troops under McClellan's command around Washington were raw and that his huge army was in a state of incomplete organization, but Slotkin believes that the reasons for McClellan's military inaction were political: If he didn't risk battle, he could never be defeated or, more calculatingly, risk offending those Northerners with Southern sympathies who could further his political aspirations.

Slotkin tells us that one of the strategic aims of Gen. Robert E. Lee's invasion of Maryland was, in accordance with Confederate President Jefferson Davis' plan, to pressure slaveholding Maryland to secede to the Confederacy. And that is the reason Lee, with approximately 68,500 troops, found himself facing McClellan's 72,500 — although McClellan, as usual, exaggerated that figure greatly.

Antietam is named for the river which runs near the small town of Sharpsburg, Md. The area upon which the battle took place on that hot day in September was made up of grassy, rolling fields, cornfields, some forest. While Slotkin's descriptions of the various maneuverings of the armies are complex, requiring a certain level of military expertise to understand fully, his vivid combat scenes, sometimes told in participants' words, are horrific yet filled with human compassion: "Men and officers of New York and Wisconsin are fused into a common mass, in the frantic struggle to shoot fast … Men are falling in their places or running back into the corn."

The author goes on to tell us how the overly cautious McClellan held the field while he allowed Lee's forces to slip away during the night of Sept. 18; how Lincoln, confident after the Antietam "victory," signed the Emancipation Proclamation on Sept. 22; and how the president finally replaced the scheming, hesitant McClellan with Gen. Ambrose Burnside in November 1862. This is one of the most moving and incisive books on the Civil War that I have ever read.

 
Comments
Notable: Books for the beach

Notable: Books for the beach

NotableBooks for the beachSuit up: It’s time for a few new books built for vacation reading.By Invitation Only (William Morrow) by Dorothea Benton Frank is the latest serving of Frank’s trademark warm humor and engaging characters, set around two wed...
Published: 05/25/18
Judy Blundell brings on summertime on Long Island in ‘High Season’

Judy Blundell brings on summertime on Long Island in ‘High Season’

NightstandJudy BlundellSince it’s Memorial Day weekend, we decided to touch base with Judy Blundell, whose new book is High Season. The novel’s protagonist is Ruthie Beamish, director of a small museum who, to make ends meet, rents out her seaside ho...
Published: 05/25/18

Events: Pulitzer winner Jack Davis to discuss ‘The Gulf’ at Oxford Exchange

Book TalkUniversity of Florida historian Jack E. Davis (The Gulf: The Making of an American Sea) will discuss and sign his Pulitzer Prize-winning book at 1 p.m. May 27 at the Oxford Exchange, 420 W Kennedy Blvd., Tampa. Admission $5, applicable towar...
Published: 05/25/18
Review: Family matters in David Sedaris’ ‘Calypso’

Review: Family matters in David Sedaris’ ‘Calypso’

David Sedaris gets right to the point in the opening of the first essay in his new book, Calypso: "Though there’s an industry built on telling you otherwise, there are few real joys to middle age. The only perk I can see is that, with luck, you’ll ac...
Published: 05/24/18
Review: Strait-laced writer Michael Pollan explores psychedelics, and leaves the door of perception ajar

Review: Strait-laced writer Michael Pollan explores psychedelics, and leaves the door of perception ajar

Microdosing is hot. If you haven’t heard — but you probably have, from reports of its use at Silicon Valley workplaces, from Ayelet Waldman’s memoir A Really Good Day, from dozens of news stories — to microdose is to take small amounts of LSD, which ...
Published: 05/24/18
Bancroft: Philip Roth deftly explored male lust, Jewish identity, American history and politics

Bancroft: Philip Roth deftly explored male lust, Jewish identity, American history and politics

Philip Roth, one of the most potent voices in American fiction, died Tuesday night of congestive heart failure in a New York City hospital. He was 85.Mr. Roth was the last man standing of a generation of fiction writers sometimes called "the great wh...
Published: 05/23/18

Events: Tarbell.org founder Wendell Potter to discuss, sign book

Book TalkTarbell.org founder Wendell Potter (Nation on the Take: How Big Money Corrupts Our Democracy and What We Can Do About It) will discuss and sign his book at 4 p.m. May 23 at the St. Petersburg Main Library, 3745 Ninth Ave. N.Applications are ...
Published: 05/21/18
The real stuff is how Tom Wolfe best used his write stuff

The real stuff is how Tom Wolfe best used his write stuff

Tom Wolfe’s best writing lifted real people into legend: car designers and astronauts and disciples of LSD. With that writing, Wolfe lifted himself into legend as well. The author of 16 books, including such bestsellers as The Right Stuff and ...
Published: 05/18/18
Review: In Stephen King’s ‘The Outsider,’ evil can’t be true but must be true

Review: In Stephen King’s ‘The Outsider,’ evil can’t be true but must be true

On a July day, Terry Maitland, one of the most popular men in Flint City, Okla. — high school English teacher, Little League coach, husband and father, recently named the town’s man of the year — attends a teachers convention in a city over an hour’s...
Published: 05/17/18

Events: Gilbert King to discuss ‘Beneath a Ruthless Sun’ at Inkwood in Tampa

Book TalkCutter Wood (Love and Death in the Sunshine State: The Story of a Crime) will discuss and sign his nonfiction book about a murder on Anna Maria Island at 6 p.m. May 14 at Bookstore1, 12 S Palm Ave., Sarasota.The Gulfport Historical Society p...
Updated one month ago