Make us your home page

Heart rate monitor provides scientific feedback for any fitness goal

Jay Downing preaches the benefits of heart rate monitors to all who will listen.

"You will see results," said Downing, a fitness specialist at the Carillon Wellness Center in St. Petersburg. "Used properly, a heart rate monitor is probably one of the most useful tools we have for overall fitness."

That's because it's the one sure way to know if you're working hard enough to improve fitness and performance — or so hard that you run the risk of hurting yourself.

The problem is, Downing said, too few runners, bikers and swimmers actually use this small but mighty piece of exercise equipment.

"A lot of people just don't want to be bothered," he said. "Then there are those people who have them but don't know how to use them."

Heart rate monitors, electronic devices that measure how many times the most important muscle in the body beats per minute, come in all shapes and sizes.

The most basic versions, with a chest-strap transmitter and wrist receiver, sell for under $60. Buy one with more advanced functions, such as GPS technology and downloadable training programs, and you can pay well over $300.


Heart rate monitors have been a mainstay for cardiac rehabilitation patients for decades.

"If you have any type of procedure or issue, including a heart attack or heart disease, you should undergo at least 12 weeks of supervised cardiac rehabilitation," said Dr. Vibhuti Singh, an interventional cardiologist at Bayfront Medical Center in St. Petersburg. "The heart rate monitor is a vital part of that rehabilitation."

Heart patients typically start on an exercise bike or treadmill, peddling slowly or walking, and then picking up the pace if their condition permits it, while a trained technician closely monitors their heart rate.

"A heart rate monitor lets us control the intensity of their exercise," said Charlie Mack, a clinical exercise physiologist for Bayfit Cardiac Care. "Depending on their diagnosis and medication, heart patients can see benefits by exercising at 40 percent of their maximum heart rate."

But many of Mack's patients have continued monitoring their heart long after their rehab is completed.

"The bottom line is a heart rate monitor allows you to approach your exercise program scientifically," he said.


Most of the people Downing works with at Carillon want to trim down or simply improve their overall fitness.

"The first thing I do is identify their fitness goals," Downing said. "Do you want to lose weight or are you trying to take a couple of minutes off your 10K time?"

The heart rate, or how many times the muscle beats per minute, varies during rest and exercise. The resting heart rate is — obviously — how many times a heart beats per minute (BPM) when the muscle is at rest. The maximum heart rate (MHR) is how many times a heart beats per minute at full capacity, which varies by age.

To figure out your MHR start with the number 220 and subtract your age. For example, if you are 50 years old, your MHR is 170.

"If you want to just maintain heart health and burn some fat, you should exercise at 60-70 percent of your MHR for 30 to 60 minutes at least four times a week," Downing said. "But the longer you exercise, the more fat you will burn.'' For a 50-year-old, 60 to 70 percent of the MHR is 102 to 119.

But if you want to set a new personal record in the upcoming St. Anthony's Triathlon, you will have to push it a little harder.

"For aerobic endurance training, you should be training at 70 to 80 percent of your MHR," Downing said. So our 50-year-old would keep his or her heart rate at 119 to 136.


Dr. John Gross, a sports medicine specialist at St. Anthony's Hospital in St. Petersburg, works closely with elite competitors at the St. Anthony's Triathlon and various Ironman events. An accomplished athlete, Gross is a frequent speaker at local triathlon and running clubs, where he extols the virtues of a heart rate monitor-based training program.

"There are a lot of good reasons to monitor your heart rate," he said. "Heart rate monitors act as the link between your mind and your body.

"It will show you when you are training too hard," he said. "It will show you when you aren't training hard enough."

The devices are particularly useful for seasoned athletes who want to fine-tune their performance with speed work and interval training.

"But you have to be careful," Gross said. "Heart rate monitors do have their disadvantages."

For one thing, they're not all created equal, and price is not necessarily a guarantee of quality. If possible, bring your heart rate monitor to a trainer or health professional who can gauge its accuracy for you.

Read the directions carefully to be sure you're wearing the monitor and reading it properly.

Also, dehydration, heat, humidity and lack of sleep are factors that can affect your heart rate.

"You are not always the same person that you were yesterday," Gross explained. "So heart rate monitors are not the holy grail for runners. But the advantages far outweigh the disadvantages."


Scott Chambers is your typical weekend warrior. During the week, the 38-year-old St. Petersburg resident manages his family's auto supply business.

"I try to run every day," he said. "On weekends I try to race."

Last December, under Downing's direction, Chambers started training with a Polar heart rate monitor, an entry-level device that retails for about $55.

Polar heart rate monitors are especially popular with recreational athletes because they are inexpensive and they link up with most gym equipment, which eliminates the need to wear the wrist unit when on the treadmill.

"I have taken about 30 seconds per mile off my time in just a few short months," he said. "I am training at a higher level. I recover quicker . . . my body doesn't go into shock. It was just a great investment."

Terry Tomalin can be reached at

Buyers Guide

Heart rate monitors are available with a variety of functions, some useful, others downright confusing. Before buying a unit, decide what you want the monitor to do. Do you need a basic device to help you stay within your target heart range? Or do you want a computer on your wrist that will help you manage your speed work on the track?

The Polar FT1

Heart Rate Monitor: A basic, easy-to-use heart rate monitor, Polar HRMs are inexpensive and compatible with most gym equipment. This model retails for about $55, and is a good choice for beginners and exercisers seeking weight loss and heart health.

The ePulse2: Advertised as the only "truly strapless continuous heart rate monitor" on the market, this device may appeal to women who do not like the chest strap on other heart rate monitors. This one is worn on the forearm, not the wrist, and our tester found that hard to get used to. Retails for $149.95.

The Timex Race Trainer: A slightly more sophisticated heart rate monitor with a 100-lap memory and calories-burned function. For years, Timex had the market cornered on running watches. The optional Timex data recorder saves your workouts so they can be downloaded to a personal computer. Price: $149.99.

The Garmin Forerunner 310XT GPS Fitness Monitor: This has all the bells and whistles, including a GPS tracking system that allows you to compute your actual speed, making it ideal for open water swimmers, paddlers and cyclists. The Forerunner retails for $349.

Heart rate monitor provides scientific feedback for any fitness goal 03/11/11 [Last modified: Friday, March 11, 2011 3:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours