Make us your home page

Don't bet on 20 percent down payment rule for mortgages

20 percent down? Don't bet on it

WASHINGTON — Remember the proposed requirement from six federal agencies that home buyers make minimum 20 percent down payments if they want the lowest interest rates?

Remember the controversy that erupted over the plan last spring, when labor unions joined with bankers, civil rights groups, mortgage companies, realty agents and consumer advocates to get it changed? A bipartisan group of 39 senators and more than 250 Democrats and Republicans in the House even signed letters demanding that the agencies ditch the proposal because it would be deeply harmful to a housing market mired in deep trouble.

Half a year has passed, and here's an update: The 20 percent proposal is still alive, but it's bogged down in agency reviews of the roughly 12,000 comments filed by interest groups and individuals. Almost certainly it will not be ready for final adoption until the first quarter of 2012. Even then, there will be a mandatory one-year lag before the new requirement takes effect.

But can it survive in its current form that long, given the rip currents of the political year that's just getting under way? The agencies themselves — the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., the Treasury's Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Federal Reserve, the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Federal Housing Finance Agency — are officially mum on the proposal.

The group includes strong proponents of the 20 percent rule who argue that the "qualified residential mortgage," or QRM, language adopted by Congress in its 2010 Wall Street financial reform legislation requires them to devise a national standard for safe, low-risk home mortgages based on historical data. One of the statistical indicators of risk, based on studies of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgages, they maintain, is the amount of equity a borrower has in the property. A standard that does not include down payments, proponents insist, will be deficient.

But the three co-authors of the QRM provision say Congress expressly omitted reference to down payments and never intended that the agencies set an equity minimum that would prevent up to 40 percent of buyers from qualifying for a low-interest-rate mortgage.

In testimony Sept. 8 before a House Financial Services subcommittee, one of the co-authors, Sen. Johnny Isakson, R-Ga., said "if this rule goes into effect as proposed, it will be the last nail in the coffin for the already crippled U.S. housing market . . . Poor underwriting led us into the housing crisis, not down payments."

Isakson, along with Sens. Mary Landrieu, D-La., and Kay Hagan, D-N.C., told the six agencies before they published the proposal that down payments were rejected in congressional discussions as an underwriting standard. The legislation left the door open for private mortgage insurance to cover the financial risks of down payments below 20 percent, just as the government-supervised mortgage investors Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have permitted for decades.

The QRM controversy comes at a politically sensitive time for President Barack Obama. Housing continues to be a lead weight holding back the economic recovery. His poll numbers are plunging, plus key segments of his political base — unions, community and economic development groups and consumer activists — oppose any move to force working families to come up with more cash to buy a home. The rule — even in proposed form — is likely to be an attractive target for the president's opponents.

The White House can't dictate regulatory policy to independent bodies such as the Federal Reserve and Federal Housing Finance Agency. But with Treasury and HUD playing important roles in formulating the final rule on mortgages, Obama has a direct pipeline into the policymaking process.

Bottom line: Don't expect to see a 20 percent rule any time in the near future. Even independent regulators don't operate in political vacuums. They've either gotten the message already or they will soon.

Kenneth R. Harney can be reached at

Don't bet on 20 percent down payment rule for mortgages 09/24/11 [Last modified: Friday, September 23, 2011 6:33pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Special to the Times.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours