Make us your home page

A‘Downton’ downer

This is an admission that will sound like sacrilege to some, especially those who put this show on their Best of 2012 lists just a few weeks ago.

But I am falling out of love with the 1920s-era English soap opera of manners, Downton Abbey.

That's tough news for fans of great TV. Winter is considered the season when the best shows arrive, particularly on broadcast television. In 2013, that roster includes The Following, a new serial killer series starring Kevin Bacon; a revamped version of NBC's Broadway drama Smash; and Justified, the crime drama featuring Timothy Olyphant's deliciously laconic U.S. Marshal Raylan Givens.

Downton Abbey might well be the cherry on that particular sundae, festooned with awards and fan appreciation for its well-crafted look at the fictional English manor of Robert Crawley, Earl of Grantham, and his aristocratic family in the era of World War I, the Titanic and beyond. But some may find its third season a bit, well, familiar.

That's not to say this upcoming run of new episodes, which begins airing stateside on PBS stations tonight through its Masterpiece series, lacks all the stuff that Downton fans love.

(WARNING: Plot description with some spoilers follow. For instance, we already know that Dan Stevens, the actor who plays Matthew Crawley, has opted not to renew his contract after the third season.)

There's a challenge to the family fortune, as downturns in business leave the Crawley family in danger of having to — gasp! —leave Downton itself! And there is a family member who can help, by pledging a newly bequeathed fortune to save the clan, but an antiquated sense of morality interferes.

More family conflict comes thanks to the cheeky Irish chauffeur Tom Branson, who crossed class lines by marrying the youngest Crawley lady, Sybil. His political views on freeing Ireland from English control and upending the class system hardly fall on sympathetic ears at Downton, especially when a clash with the English during a bloody terrorist action leads him to flee the country without his new wife.

There is the challenge of new servants added to the fold, including a new footman related to Lady Grantham's maid, the curdled Sarah O'Brien, and another new footman whose good looks set the female servants aflutter (along with a certain closeted male servant, the villainous Thomas Barrow).

And, of course, the irrepressible Shirley MacLaine arrives as Martha Levinson, mother to Elizabeth McGovern's American-born Lady Cora Crawley. Never comfortable with the rigid English system of codes, roles and class, she seems an acerbic counterpoint to Maggie Smith's tart Violet Crawley, Countess of Grantham.

Why has the bloom fallen from Downton's rose for me this season?

Suspicion No. 1: We know this world now. One culprit may be a growing familiarity with the class system depicted in the series, which once felt like an archaeological dig, full of surprises and odd discoveries.

But now, the routines of the house and the class divisions are well-known. The servants are expected to devote themselves wholeheartedly to serving their masters, the masters are expected to safeguard their fortune, oversee the maintenance of their obscenely huge properties and ensure their titles and money continue by marrying off children to the best prospects available.

Along the way, there will be circumstances which test their devotion to their musty values, which will mostly stand, because that's what musty values do. But seeing this dance play out over two seasons already, I'm ready for a few new steps.

Suspicion No. 2: The villains and heroes are too easy to see. You can judge a character on Downton by a simple question: Are they virtuous?

Footman Thomas Barrow wears villainy on his sleeve, gossiping acidly about everyone at Downton while acting only to further his agenda. (That he seems to be the regular cast's only gay character also is a bit troubling.) But Anna Bates, the housemaid who married a valet later wrongly convicted of murder, embodies virtue in her devotion to an imprisoned mate, even when his letters from prison mysteriously stop coming.

Some characters can be redeemed — oldest Crawley sister Mary seems to have moved from bad girl to virtuous since her off-again-on-again romance with middle class lawyer Matthew Crawley was consummated in marriage. But it's a soap opera convention that characters announce their standing to the audience before anyone in the story knows, and that can be a bit boring at times.

Suspicion No. 3: The predicaments rooted in the mores of the time seem silly and unrealistic. One of the early plot points in this season's episodes is the danger that the Crawleys might lose Downton itself.

But a guilty Matthew Crawley, who winds up with a fortune from the father of the fiancée he jilted to wed Mary, refuses to use the money to keep his new wife's family from losing the home they have lived in for generations.

This is what makes Matthew a virtuous character in the Downton world. But it also seems silly and stupid; could any marriage survive a husband letting his wife's family lose their legacy?

Again, this is the stuff of which fine soap opera is made, and Downton fans will probably relish every moment of Matthew Crawley's principled insanity.

But for me, it was a signal that the entertainment had ended on this particular ride. At least until this old fashioned drama develops a few more modern surprises.

Other quality shows to consider

Deception, debuts at 10 p.m. Monday on NBC, WFLA-Ch. 8.

When the troubled child of a powerful, wealthy family dies under mysterious circumstances, the cops pressure undercover officer and longtime friend of the family Joanna Locasto (Eve's Bayou alum Meagan Good) to rejoin the fold and find out what happened. The result is an odd combination of ABC's Revenge and Donnie Brasco — a show which is half wealthy-centered soap opera and half police procedural.

Justified, new season begins at 10 p.m. Tuesday on FX.

Timothy Olyphant's U.S. Marshal Raylan Givens remains a street-smart, supremely confident lawman working the backwoods of his Kentucky hometown, tripped up most by his own mistakes. In this season, his convict father's connection to an empty diplomatic pouch sparks a jailhouse murder, the theft of Givens' car (with a fugitive locked in the trunk) and the introduction of whip smart comic Patton Oswalt as a not-so-smart constable, Bob Sweeney. As a show which humanizes Southern stereotypes while exploiting and exploding them, Justified has no equal.

Cougar Town, debuts on TBS at 10 p.m. Tuesday.

TV's favorite wine-swilling, super-shallow middle-aged buddies have returned, saved from ABC's cancellation scrap heap by the good folks at TBS. By now, this sitcom's name is a serious misnomer, featuring Courteney Cox's energetic real estate agent Jules Cobb in a new marriage with a man her own age in the

fictional town of Gulf Haven, Fla. It's like being at both the coolest and stupidest dinner party ever.

A‘Downton’ downer 01/05/13 [Last modified: Tuesday, January 8, 2013 3:26pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours