Saturday, December 16, 2017
TV and Media

Honoring comic book form at heart of 'The Avengers' success

This isn't my normal pop culture turf. • But as a serious comic book fanboy who has seen The Avengers movie twice (with plans to see it again), I wanted to explore something I've noticed in how some people are talking about this film. • Comic book culture — like a lot of so-called "genre" areas in pop culture such as science fiction and fantasy — is often a serious litmus test for consumers: Either you get it and love it, or you don't. • Which is why I truly understand how some critics feel about seeing comic book heroes take over the blockbuster summer movie season.

With the last Dark Knight film coming later this summer, along with the Amazing Spider-Man reboot, if you don't like superheroes and the trappings of the genre, it can feel like the idiots have taken over the asylum.

But then along comes a movie like The Avengers (and Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight before that) that flips the script by being a great film about superheroes.

And suddenly, folks who could shrug off ill-considered nonsense like the last Green Lantern movie must suddenly figure out a reason why this stuff actually works. (Or they could just pretend it's a crappy film, like Andrew O'Hehir from Salon, who called The Avengers "competent but pointless popcorn entertainment.")

That's what came to mind when I read Ann Hornaday's Washington Post essay on the film. I have no idea what she knows about the comic book world, but the column's tone falls somewhere between bewilderment and condescension, with the odd objective of finding an acceptable reason to like this entertaining movie.

Her conclusion was echoed by other disbelieving critics: The material was elevated by the film's coolest actors.

As evidence, she cites Mark Ruffalo, an actor with lots of cool cred for serious film fans. Ruffalo does an amazing job playing Bruce Banner as a geekily brilliant, cynically tortured guy whose buttoned-down exterior hides something dark and scary inside, beyond his ability to morph into a giant green rage monster.

She writes: "On paper, the Hulk doesn't immediately look like the kind of material an actor of Ruffalo's sensitivity and intelligence would be drawn to. In fact, many of Ruffalo's fans — with visions of Nicolas Cage's career dancing in their heads — first greeted the Hulk casting news with trepidation bordering on outrage. 'Not our Mark!' "

But this fanboy — and stone Ruffalo devotee — must object. Why not "our Mark"? Actors as cool as Jack Nicholson, Heath Ledger, Robert Downey Jr., Samuel L. Jackson and Willem Dafoe have played amazing characters in comic book movies.

The fact is, these roles can be a blast, if written well. Ruffalo takes a juicy part two other fine actors have played in recent years and wrings new substance and emotional notes from it.

Indeed, he gets one of the film's money lines, spoken by Banner to Captain America just before the Hulk bursts free: "That's my secret, Cap. I'm always angry."

But The Avengers' greatness isn't just about the actors all nailing their roles. It's about something bigger.

This movie works because the guy who made it, director-producer Joss Whedon, knows comic books intimately and embraced the way they tell stories. There was no attempt to "artify" the movie with grand ideas or dumb down the action by turning it into a succession of effects-filled fight scenes.

Most importantly, he didn't try to re-invent the wheel by coming up with new storylines; he pulled together a story from some of the most successful Avengers' plotlines and characters already out there.

Believe me, I know the love of comics is an acquired taste. I tried explaining the plot of The Avengers to a friend during lunch recently, and it sounded so geeky even I wanted to stick a sock in my mouth. But the fact is, this is a storytelling form with literally 60 or 70 years worth of history.

Captain America first appeared in comics in 1941. Thor debuted in 1962. Iron Man bowed the next year. Every one of these characters is older than I am, yet when some filmmakers take on these franchises, they ignore decades of storytelling in which concepts and plotlines have been road-tested and explored.

The great failure of Green Lantern, if you ask me, is that filmmakers disregarded years of more modern stories featuring the character, instead copying a creaky origin story that was first published in 1959.

And what gives me hope about yet another new Superman movie is that director Zack Snyder is such a comics geek that he faithfully translated a comic book even many fans doubted could ever reach the silver screen, Alan Moore's subversive Watchmen.

(Though I always remember a writer who once said there's no drama in watching a superman tackle problems; true drama is seeing a regular guy tackle a superhuman problem.)

Imagine a filmmaker creating a Western with no knowledge of classic Sergio Leone or Sam Peckinpah films. Or attempting a Hercule Poirot film with little knowledge of (or respect for) Agatha Christie.

For this fanboy geek, the real triumph of The Avengers is its lessons for other filmmakers.

Respect the comic book storytelling form. Because it works.

'Nuff said.

Eric Deggans can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8521.

Comments

Saturday’s sports on TV/radio

TODAYBoxingMiddleweights: Lemieux vs. Saunders9:30 p.m.HBOCollege basketballButler vs. PurduenoonFoxMiami at George WashingtonnoonCBSSNLouisville vs. MemphisnoonESPN2Detroit vs. MichigannoonESPNUNC-Greensboro at N.C. StatenoonFSFSeton Hall at Rutgers...
Published: 12/15/17
Adam Savage’s ‘Brain Candy Live!’ at the Straz Center: Canceled

Adam Savage’s ‘Brain Candy Live!’ at the Straz Center: Canceled

Looks like the idea of Brain Candy Live! returning to Tampa Bay in 2018 turned out to be a myth.The interactive science spectacular, co-hosted by MythBusters' Adam Savage, has canceled its upcoming North American tour, including a May 5 event at the ...
Published: 12/15/17
Here are this week’s pop culture winners and losers

Here are this week’s pop culture winners and losers

Salma HayekSalma Hayek has spoken out against Harvey Weinstein, calling the producer a "monster" who threatened her career and her life after she reportedly denied his sexual advances. Hayek said working with Weinstein on the film Frida was like "goi...
Published: 12/15/17
What to watch this weekend: ‘A Christmas Story Live,’ Star Wars movie marathon, Hollywood Christmas Parade

What to watch this weekend: ‘A Christmas Story Live,’ Star Wars movie marathon, Hollywood Christmas Parade

OH, FUDGE! A CHRISTMAS STORY LIVE!The trend of live musicals broadcast on television isn't slowing down anytime soon, and A Christmas Story Live! — based on the classic holiday movie and Broadway musical — was ripe for the next taking. Fo...
Published: 12/15/17

Friday’s sports on TV/radio

TODAYBoxingSuper lightweights: Vargas vs. Herrera10 p.m.FS1College basketballWomen: Southern at USF7 p.m.1040-AMMaryland-Eastern Shore at Creighton8 p.m.FS1College footballDivision III, final: Mount Union (Ohio) vs. Mary Hardin-Baylor (Texas)7 p.m.ES...
Published: 12/14/17
Harry Potter’s Nymphadora Tonks, Natalia Tena, joins A Celebration of Harry Potter at Universal Orlando

Harry Potter’s Nymphadora Tonks, Natalia Tena, joins A Celebration of Harry Potter at Universal Orlando

The bubble gum pink-haired, shape-shifting witch Nymphadora Tonks from the last four Harry Potter films is headed to A Celebration of Harry Potter next month.Natalia Tena marks her first appearance at the annual wizarding world celebration Jan. 26-28...
Published: 12/14/17
Disney-Fox deal gives ESPN control of local cable rights to Rays, Lightning games

Disney-Fox deal gives ESPN control of local cable rights to Rays, Lightning games

As part of its deal to buy a massive package of 21st Century Fox assets, Disney will acquire Fox Sports Regional Networks, which control the local cable rights to a slew of professional teams, including the Tampa Bay Rays and Tampa Bay Lightning.Assu...
Published: 12/14/17
Poll: Most Americans say 'Merry Christmas' and prefer Rudolph over Charlie Brown

Poll: Most Americans say 'Merry Christmas' and prefer Rudolph over Charlie Brown

The Monmouth University Polling institute released the results of their Christmas poll today.
Published: 12/14/17

Thursday’s sports on TV/radio

TODAYBoxingSuper Bantamweights: Salgado vs. Diego De La Hoya10:30 p.m.ESPN2College basketballBethune-Cookman at USF7 p.m.820-AMValparaiso at Northwestern8 p.m.Big TenSouthern at Baylor8:30 p.m.ESPN2College volleyball, NCAA semifinalsNebraska vs. Penn...
Published: 12/13/17
Uber Eats is delivering 'free' chicken McNuggets across Tampa Bay

Uber Eats is delivering 'free' chicken McNuggets across Tampa Bay

You'll still have to pay the delivery fee, but the 10-piece McNuggets are free.
Published: 12/13/17