Sunday, November 19, 2017
TV and Media

Review: Jon Stewart and Bill O'Reilly's 'Rumble'

RECOMMENDED READING


The canniest conservative on cable TV news and the sharpest social progressive in late-night comedy finally had it out on a debate stage Saturday, and the biggest tragedy is that more people didn't get to see it.

That's because the primary way anyone outside Washington could see Daily Show host Jon Stewart and O'Reilly Factor host Bill O'Reilly's "Rumble in the Air-Conditioned Auditorium" debate was an online live stream that loads of fans could not access when it started at 8 p.m. Saturday.

Judging by the complaints on Twitter and Facebook, many who paid $4.95 to see the event received only error messages when clicking on the special URL provided. Celebrities from Scrubs star Zach Braff to Pulitzer-winning movie critic Roger Ebert complained about the mess, which forced moderators of a live blog organized by the Wall Street Journal to apologize for the lack of content.

Fortunately, the mess seemed to clear up about 45 minutes in, and those who forked out for access could also watch or download an archived version.

What those lucky enough to get access saw was a spirited give-and-take between conservative and progressive positions highlighted by a lot of jokes, a fair bit of passion and a surprising amount of solid facts. Kinda like what some of us wish would have happened last Wednesday in Denver.

So here's a quick look at some of the highlights.

The manifestos

Even though moderator — and former VH1 VJ/ex-Fox News anchor — E.D. Hill said the first hour of the debate would start with questions, O'Reilly and Stewart shrugged off Hill to present opening statements that served as manifestos for the evening.

O'Reilly: "About 20 percent of us are slackers, and it's a growing industry. That is what this election is all about. … We are spending an enormous amount of money on 20 percent (of people) who, for whatever reason, (say) 'Ah, we're just not gonna cut it.' "

Stewart: "My friend Bill O'Reilly is completely full of s---. A good portion of this country has created an alternative universe. … I call this place where these folks live B---s--- Mountain. (turning to O'Reilly) I have come here to plead with the mayor of B---s--- Mountain. Please talk to your people."

The props

O'Reilly drew laughs by flashing a procession of large cards bearing simple slogans: "Bush is gone," "Debt is bad," "Drones yes! Waterboards no!" and "Iran not frightened," with a picture of an atomic bomb helpfully added. His thesis: That a perception of Barack Obama as a weak president has led Americans to overuse entitlement programs and Middle Eastern terrorists to attack us.

Stewart, who stands 5 feet 7 next to a 6-4 O'Reilly, used a lift hidden under the podium where he stood to elevate himself at key points of the debate — as when he asserted his esteemed rival was "completely full of s---" by refusing to consider the impact of Bush administration policies or history.

Best argument

Stewart often surprised viewers with a deep knowledge of facts, including maintaining that O'Reilly's hometown of Levittown, Long Island, N.Y., was built up by soldiers who got low-interest mortgages, small-business loans and college funds through the G.I. Bill, which was — technically — government-subsidized education, business and housing. (Historians such as Stephen Ambrose have said many of America's early suburbs were built up that way.) He also noted that O'Reilly's father left his job after becoming ill, using workers' compensation to keep up their income.

O'Reilly: "My father's salary, a portion of it, went into that fund in case he needed that disability. (Stewart) doesn't know the difference between the private and the public sector."

Stewart: ''Your suggestion is, Barack Obama came into office and all of sudden everybody went 'Lord have mercy. We don't need to work anymore.' "

O'Reilly: "They advertised on the radio for food stamps!"

Stewart: "Why is it that, if you take advantage of a tax break, you're a smart businessman, but if you take advantage of something that you need to not be hungry, you're moocher?"

Worst moderator

Forget about Jim Lehrer. Hill, who kept trying to interject questions as Stewart and O'Reilly dug into a real debate, erred by stepping in when discussion was great and asking lame questions when it wasn't. (She is the former Fox News anchor best known for asking if a fist bump between the Obamas was a "terrorist fist jab" in a 2008 news promo.) Small wonder Stewart just started asking O'Reilly sharper, more interesting questions on his own.

Best swipe

O'Reilly: "(Stewart) has offended every single American by saying we are only as good as our weakest link. We're only as good as CNN? Are you kidding me?"

Stewart: "Fox News is an overreaction … sort of like the lupus of news … they have seen something (like liberal bias), it is there with a soupcon, and Fox News has gone overboard. I think anytime you run an organization where more (viewers) believe the president is a Muslim than believe in evolution, there's a problem."

The verdict: Everybody wins

O'Reilly and Stewart attacked each other's arguments but not their personalities, armed with facts and a fair bit of passion. They didn't replace traditional news sources or change many minds, but they did offer a blueprint for debate that can inform, entertain and push forward the bounds of public discussion at once.

Wonder if anybody in the political world was actually paying attention?

 
Comments

Sunday’s sports on TV/radio

TODAYAutosMonster Energy Cup: Ford EcoBoost 4003 p.m.NBCCFLSaskatchewan at Toronto1 p.m.ESPNewsEdmonton at Calgary4:30 p.m.ESPNewsCollege basketballMonmouth at Virginia1 p.m.FSFWomen: Maryland at Connecticut1:30 p.m.ESPNPuerto Rico Tip-Off, fifth pla...
Published: 11/18/17

Saturday’s sports on TV/radio

TODAYAutosXfinity: Ford EcoBoost 300 qualifying11 a.m.CNBCXfinity: Ford EcoBoost 3003:30 p.m.NBCSNCollege basketballMaryland-Eastern Shore at GeorgetownnoonFox SunBucknell at Maryland8:30 p.m.Big TenGolfPGA Europe: Tour Championship2:30 a.m.GolfPGA: ...
Published: 11/17/17
Video: Forget Pizza Rat. Meet St. Petersburg’s Pizza Squirrel

Video: Forget Pizza Rat. Meet St. Petersburg’s Pizza Squirrel

New York, it seems, doesn't have a monopoly on pizza-chomping rodents.Around 2:45 p.m. Friday, the Tampa Bay Times spotted a squirrel digging a nearly entire slice of pizza out of a trash can at 146 Second St. N in St. Petersburg. The squirrel hoppe...
Published: 11/17/17
Jeffrey Tambor accused of sexual harassment by his ‘Transparent’ co-star

Jeffrey Tambor accused of sexual harassment by his ‘Transparent’ co-star

"Transparent" actress Trace Lysette has accused actor Jeffrey Tambor of sexually harassing her on the set of the Amazon series.Lysette’s allegations mark the second time the star, who plays Maura Pfefferman on the critically acclaimed dramedy, has be...
Published: 11/17/17
Here are this week’s pop culture winners and losers

Here are this week’s pop culture winners and losers

WINNERS:Taylor SwiftFollowing the death of his mother, Gloria, The Tonight Show host Jimmy Fallon shared a touching story with the audience about his mom squeezing his hand three times and saying "I love you," when he was a kid. "Last week, I was in ...
Published: 11/17/17
Review: ‘Marvel’s Runaways’ pits rebellious teens against their evil parents

Review: ‘Marvel’s Runaways’ pits rebellious teens against their evil parents

The parents in Runaways really are the worst.Hulu's new Marvel series follows a ragtag group of teenagers who have to band together to defeat their own parents, who are collective members of a secret criminal organization called the Pride.In the wake...
Published: 11/17/17
What to watch this weekend: ‘The Punisher,’ ‘Search Party,’ Elizabeth Smart Lifetime movie

What to watch this weekend: ‘The Punisher,’ ‘Search Party,’ Elizabeth Smart Lifetime movie

GRIEF AND GUNS: THE PUNISHERMarvel fans first saw Marine veteran Frank Castle (Jon Bernthal) in Netflix's Daredevil series. The brutish anti-hero finally gets his own series with The Punisher, exploring what he did after helping Daredevil (Charlie Co...
Published: 11/17/17
Jesmyn Ward wins National Book Award for ‘Sing, Unburied, Sing’

Jesmyn Ward wins National Book Award for ‘Sing, Unburied, Sing’

Jesmyn Ward is having a good year.At a glamorous ceremony Wednesday night in New York, Ward was named the winner of the 2017 National Book Award for Sing, Unburied, Sing, about a Mississippi family's epic road trip. The book is Ward's third novel ...
Published: 11/16/17
Your heart can go on when ‘Titanic’ returns to theaters

Your heart can go on when ‘Titanic’ returns to theaters

It's the holiday season, so why not capitalize on a beloved film by bringing it back to theaters for a limited engagement?That's what Dolby Laboratories, Paramount Pictures and AMC Theaters are doing, announcing that a remastered version of Titanic w...
Published: 11/15/17

Wednesday’s sports on TV/radio

TODAYCollege basketballIndiana at Seton Hall6:30 p.m.FS1Montana State at Penn State7 p.m.Big TenUSF at Stetson8 p.m.820-AMButler at Maryland8:30 p.m.FS1Creighton at Northwestern9 p.m.Big TenCollege footballE. Michigan at Miami (Ohio)7 p.m.CBSSNW. Mic...
Published: 11/14/17