Monday, June 18, 2018
Movies

Review: 'Won't Back Down' simply doesn't stand up

Immediately after Won't Back Down happily ended I was hoping for a sequel. You know, a movie describing how this miraculous turnaround of a failing inner city elementary school happens. Certainly it must involve more than ukulele sing-alongs and pretty art projects but that's all the movie naively suggests.

Won't Back Down is more concerned with spreading blame for America's education woes, with its anger focused on school boards and teacher unions protecting poor employees. As a former public school teacher, I'll agree that happens but I'm not convinced it happens as cancerously as director and co-writer Daniel Barnz insists.

Barnz gives lip service to equally accountable factions — poverty, bureaucracy and uncaring parents. Yet he nullifies their effects by building a story around two struggling parents with abnormal patience and perseverance to see underachieving children succeed. Ads for Won't Back Down claim the movie is "inspired by actual events" but so are a lot of horror flicks intended to scare viewers out of their wits.

Consider the actual events in question: Two cases in California when enough petition signatures were obtained to invoke a "parent trigger" law, turning public schools into charter programs operated by for-profit agencies, free of government and union regulation. One case was dropped and the other is proceeding. (A parent trigger bill died in Florida's Senate in March.)

Charter schools were the subject of last year's documentary Waiting for Superman, which extolled the system's virtues without explaining exactly what they do differently from public schools. I wrote then that the filmmakers should have given viewers a peek inside the lesson plans, perhaps inspiring a mediocre teacher to try something new. That movie and Won't Back Down are both produced by Walden Media, with the same fatalism about public schools.

Barnz never mentions parent triggers (it's called a fail-safe law here) or tuition-funded charter schools (although one is shown, looking magical as Oz). But the former is what the parents played by Maggie Gyllenhaal and Viola Davis invoke, and the latter must be the solution skipped before the happy ending. Where else would the money come from to pay teachers and update materials, on the poverty side of Pittsburgh?

The inherent falseness of Won't Back Down may only be bothersome if you've done your homework. Likely more viewers will buy into the Erin Brockovich-style spunk Gyllenhaal provides, and the performance by Davis, an actor so emotional that even her nose cries on cue. It's not a bad movie, if you're inclined to be manipulated by impromptu romance and rousing changes of heart.

I'm not, but I can appreciate the feelings of those who are. Go see Won't Back Down and enjoy it. Just don't believe it's anything more than a stacked deck with a lot at stake.

Steve Persall can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8365.

Comments
‘Incredibles 2’ just might be better than the original — and a cure to superhero fatigue

‘Incredibles 2’ just might be better than the original — and a cure to superhero fatigue

It’s been 14 years since the premiere of Brad Bird’s beloved animated superhero film The Incredibles, one of the mega-hit Pixar films that cemented its reputation for film humor and heart that would satisfy both parents and children. With cool mid-ce...
Published: 06/13/18
Why is Mister Rogers making adults cry decades later?

Why is Mister Rogers making adults cry decades later?

Neighborly block party comes to downtown Tampa.
Published: 06/12/18
 ‘Won’t You Be My Neighbor?’ about Mr. Rogers is much-needed emotional tonic for troubled times

‘Won’t You Be My Neighbor?’ about Mr. Rogers is much-needed emotional tonic for troubled times

If beloved children’s television show host Mr. Rogers were once a representation of all things milquetoast, in the summer of 2018, his message of love and tolerance is not only saintly, it’s radical. In the deftly crafted documentary Won’t You Be My ...
Published: 06/12/18
Yes, ‘Ocean’s 8’ is a heist movie, but it’s also an empowering, cheeky comedy

Yes, ‘Ocean’s 8’ is a heist movie, but it’s also an empowering, cheeky comedy

Most every successful heist movie, just like a heist itself, functions by obeying a well-defined formula.First comes the setup and backstory (typically involving the righting of a wrong, to lend the subsequent lawbreaking a veneer of moral justificat...
Published: 06/06/18
TMZ: Last surviving munchkin from ‘The Wizard of Oz’ dies at 98

TMZ: Last surviving munchkin from ‘The Wizard of Oz’ dies at 98

The last surviving munchkin in The Wizard of Oz has died.Jerry Maren, 98, died last week at a nursing home in San Diego, according to TMZ.The cause of death for the last surviving member of the famous Lollipop Guild, made famous in the 1939 classic, ...
Published: 06/06/18
‘Blind Side’ star is at Tampa Theatre for a screening this weekend

‘Blind Side’ star is at Tampa Theatre for a screening this weekend

BLIND SIDE: Summer Classic Movie SeriesAll summer long, Tampa Theatre is showing classic Hollywood movies. Sunday features not only a screening of 2009’s The Blind Side, but also actor Quinton Aaron, who played Big Mike in the film, for a Q&A. Based ...
Published: 06/06/18
In ‘Hereditary,’ Toni Collette reveals a sixth sense for icy terror

In ‘Hereditary,’ Toni Collette reveals a sixth sense for icy terror

All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way, as Tolstoy noted in a sentence so right, by the time you started arguing with it Anna Karenina was off and suffering.If Tolstoy got a look at Hereditary, he might’ve added: ...
Published: 06/06/18
Jodie Foster makes ‘Hotel Artemis’ first-class experience

Jodie Foster makes ‘Hotel Artemis’ first-class experience

Hotel Artemis is a shining example of how it isn’t the amount of money spent to make a movie, but how the budget is being spent. Director/writer Drew Pearce has managed to take the money that would be the cape-pressing budget for most superhero movie...
Published: 06/06/18
Summer movie guide: All the superheroes, sequels and quirky comedies to see

Summer movie guide: All the superheroes, sequels and quirky comedies to see

Summer started early this year in Hollywood with the record-breaking release of Avengers: Infinity War, and the marquee Marvel superheroes couldn’t have come at a better time. The box office for the year is down nearly 3 percent, and the industry is ...
Published: 06/05/18
How Ybor City parties inspired the sets of Avengers: Infinity War

How Ybor City parties inspired the sets of Avengers: Infinity War

Thanos has nothing on Plant City native Charlotte Lee.For the Avengers: Infinity War baddie to alter the perception of his surroundings, he needed a Reality Stone, which, according to the Marvel movie’s lore, was a remnant of one of six singularities...
Updated one month ago