Wednesday, June 20, 2018
Parenting & Relationships

Drink while pregnant? Author says yes, outrages everyone

When I was pregnant, I wondered, as many women do: Can I have a drink? It is well-known that drinking to excess during pregnancy is dangerous, but what about an occasional glass of wine with dinner?

America's "pregnancy bible,'' What to Expect When You're Expecting says no alcohol. Panic-Free Pregnancy says an occasional drink is fine. A 2010 survey asked obstetricians, "How much alcohol can a pregnant woman consume without risk of adverse pregnancy outcomes?" Sixty percent of the OBs said none, but the other 40 percent said some alcohol was fine.

The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) says no amount of alcohol has been shown to be safe, but Britain's Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists says that while not drinking is the safest option, "Small amounts of alcohol during pregnancy have not been shown to be harmful."

My obstetrician said a few drinks a week was fine. But as with everything else, amid this disagreement, I needed to go to the data myself.

In researching my book Expecting Better: Why the Conventional Pregnancy Wisdom Is Wrong — and What You Really Need to Know, I focused on studies that compare women who drank lightly or occasionally during pregnancy to those who abstained. The best of these studies are ones that separate women into several groups — for example: no alcohol, a few drinks a week, one drink a day, more than one drink a day — and that limit the focus to women who say they never had a binge drinking episode.

With these parameters, we can really hone in on the question of interest: What is the impact of having an occasional drink, assuming that you never overdo it?

I summarize two studies in detail in my book: one looking at alcohol consumption by pregnant women and behavior problems for the resulting children up to age 14, and one looking at alcohol in pregnancy and test performance at age 14. Both show no difference between the children of women who abstain and those who have up to a drink a day. I summarize two others in less detail: one looking at IQ scores at age 8 and a more recent one looking at IQ scores at age 5. These also demonstrate no impact of light drinking on test scores.

I argue that based on this data, many women may feel comfortable with an occasional glass of wine — even up to one a day — in later trimesters. (More caution in the first trimester — no more than two drinks a week — because of some evidence of miscarriage risk.)

• • •

Although this discussion takes up only a small part of the book, it has garnered the loudest reaction, much of it outrage. NOFAS, a fetal alcohol syndrome advocacy group, issued a press release even before the book came out, saying I was harmful and irresponsible. Amazon reviews of the book attacked me and anyone who had a drink during pregnancy as an alcoholic. One commented on my daughter: "Emily Oster claims that her 2-year old daughter is perfectly healthy, yet the full impact of the alcohol exposure on her child will not be evident until the adolescent years."

The president of ACOG has vehemently disagreed with me, saying in an interview about occasional drinking that alcohol in pregnancy is more dangerous than heroin or cocaine.

Some of the arguments made in response to the book are tangential. Commenters wish that there was more discussion of the risks of binge drinking. I spend only a page on this, since it is not the question I believe most readers of the book are asking.

Some of them are philosophical. People ask, "Why take the risk?" since there is no benefit to the baby. But this ignores the fact that we are always making choices. Driving in a car carries some risk to your baby, and your fetus does not benefit from that vacation you took. Or they ask, "Is it so hard to give up drinking for nine months?" The answer is, of course, no, but because you might enjoy the occasional beer, it seems worth at least understanding the risks.

One fact that has been cited to me a number of times is: "One in 7 children with fetal alcohol syndrome had a mother who drank one to eight drinks per week in the first trimester." The implication is that even light drinking early on is dangerous. But this claim doesn't come from a study; it comes from a statement made in a letter to the editor, and it's therefore impossible to evaluate critically. One to eight drinks a week could mean eight drinks on one night.

Another study that has been mentioned prominently relates prenatal alcohol exposure to behavior problems in young adulthood. Although some have suggested that this paper identifies impacts of having one drink per day, the analysis actually relates behavior problems to a measure of average daily intake — which includes people having more than that, sometimes a lot more. It's true that some people in this study drink lightly, but others do not, and by lumping them together it is very difficult to draw conclusions about the light drinkers.

• • •

The bottom line is that the criticism fails to identify studies that have the features we would want: a population that is never binge drinking and a data analysis that looks separately at women who drink lightly and those who drink more. In the book, I discuss one study like this, which does argue there are impacts on behavior at one drink per day, but the study fails to adjust for differences across groups, like whether the father lives at home or if there was prenatal cocaine use, among other things.

Like alcohol, Tylenol, caffeine, and anti-nausea drugs like Zofran are substances that — in moderation — are thought to be safe during pregnancy. But they are also substances that in excessive doses could be dangerous. Some women decide that they will therefore avoid them altogether because they cannot be sure. And many women, seeing the evidence in the book on alcohol, will still choose to avoid it.

But others will see the data, like the data on caffeine or Tylenol, and choose to have an occasional drink, as I did. The value of the data is not that it leads us all to the same choice, just that it introduces a concrete way to make that choice.

Emily Oster is an economist. After receiving a Ph.D. from Harvard, she moved to the University of Chicago where she is an associate professor of economics at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business.

 
Comments
Big concerts this weekend: Luke Bryan, Hall and Oates, Weezer, Logic and more

Big concerts this weekend: Luke Bryan, Hall and Oates, Weezer, Logic and more

HIS KIND OF NIGHT: Luke BryanItís been three long years since Tampa has seen the well-groomed hide of Luke Bryan, the Hollywoodiest hunk in Nashville. But heís about to make up for lost time. On Saturday heíll headline his biggest-ever show here, a b...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Top things to do this week: Go Skateboarding Day, Hollywood medium Tyler Henry

Top things to do this week: Go Skateboarding Day, Hollywood medium Tyler Henry

Tyler Henry: Hollywood MediumTyler Henry, the so-called Hollywood Medium who stars in an eponymous E! hit show, is coming to town with a live show called "Life Lessons I Have Learned From the Departed." The soft-spoken 22-year-old has done readings f...
Updated: 7 hours ago
5 things to do under $5: USF Summer Plant Festival, Bridal Show, free show by AnastasiaMax

5 things to do under $5: USF Summer Plant Festival, Bridal Show, free show by AnastasiaMax

1 Summer Plant Festival: If you think you canít get anything to thrive in Floridaís brutal summers, check out the vendors with fruit trees and advice on how to grow them, along with hundreds of blooming butterfly plants, herbs and tropical and exotic...
Published: 06/20/18
Your guide to St. Pete Pride: What's changed for 2018

Your guide to St. Pete Pride: What's changed for 2018

Pride weekend kicks off in St. Petersburg Friday with a free concert hosted by a RuPaul’s Drag Race star, a parade along the downtown waterfront on Saturday and an expanded expo of vendors and art on Sunday in the Grand Central District that ga...
Published: 06/19/18

Tell Me About It: Mom/daughter dynamic feels controlling

Q: I am afraid I may be a controlling mom of my young adult daughter, but we have a dynamic in which she seeks me out often, solicits my advice, and makes me too important in her life. I admit to offering that advice because it is hard for me to draw...
Published: 06/19/18

Tell Me About It: Regretting staying too long in bad romance

Q: I recently broke up with someone after two years. Even though there were things that bothered me while we were together, I would convince myself I was overreacting, he didnít really mean it, etc.Now that itís over, I feel like a fool for not havin...
Published: 06/18/18

Tell Me About It: After years of depression, a diagnosis

Q: Iím 33 and have dealt with depression on and off since my adolescence. I grew up in a household with every kind of abuse you can think of, but I didnít start seeking help until my early 20s via talk therapy, and cut ties entirely with my abusers. ...
Published: 06/17/18
Top things to do in Tampa Bay for the week of June 18-24

Top things to do in Tampa Bay for the week of June 18-24

St. Pete Pride: One of the largest Pride celebration in the Southeast happens this weekend, bringing a rainbow of activities. Things set off on Friday with the free SP2 Concert at North Straub Park, hosted by Coco Montrese of RuPaul’s Drag Race...
Published: 06/15/18
Updated: 06/18/18

Tell Me About It: Pregnancy news confirms estrangement

Q: I just found out my son and his wife are going to be parents. Iím very excited and somewhat confused and a little hurt: Sheís seven months along. I donít know why the long wait to tell me. They live in another state, and I havenít seen them in abo...
Updated one month ago

Tell Me About It: Sister must face her poor choices in men

Q: Last night, I received my umpteenth call from my sobbing, devastated sister (mid-20s) over yet another semi-hookup-flirty-thing guy that didnít work out. He is moving away and she found out via an announcement at work, not from him.This is a years...
Updated one month ago