Sunday, June 17, 2018
Features and More

'Gears of War,' 'Bioshock' sequels take divergent paths

The hardest part about creating a successful sequel, in any media, is making the source material feel fresh, even if it obviously isn't.

We can look to Hollywood for two potential solutions: You can either re-create the entire experience through a rehashing of the plot, or you can reboot the entire franchise and start over while maintaining the feel of the original. Tentpole release Gears of War: Judgment (March 19) takes the former road, while long-awaited sequel Bioshock Infinite (March 26) is more the latter.

The difference here is, Irrational's take on Bioshock works, ahem, infinitely better than Epic's retread of Gears.

There's been so much written about the "games as art" argument that it doesn't even apply here. Both are stellar in their presentations, but the story lines are of inverse importance to their respective titles. Gears is an action franchise, and always has been. The current release is no different, and that is its unfortunate, and perhaps irretrievable, failing. Not that I'm advocating Gears become thought-provoking and introspective, but there is little there to warrant much of a visit, save blowing another few days on multiplayer.

There's an attempt to sell a story about Damon Baird's past (notable because of his lack of backstory in Gears of War 3), and there's a nifty tie-in to the end of that trilogy. What isn't present is any evolution of the franchise. There's talk of Sera's war-torn past, a few new weapons and a harrowing campaign experience, but the whole title feels thin. It certainly isn't progressive enough to warrant an entire AAA release. The entire experience screams DLC gone wild.

Irrational, meanwhile, decided that two trips to the underwater city of Rapture was enough, and that has made all the difference. While the gameplay of the latest Bioshock — the firefights, the conflicted protagonist, the replacement of plasmids with vigors — remains mostly the same, the setting and the story are largely new.

This time around, instead of exploring the themes of Objectivism and free will, Bioshock's story line plumbs the depths of religious fervor, racism and American exceptionalism, appropriately lofty goals for a game now set among the clouds. Features like the skylines and Elizabeth's dimensional tears add enough to dispel the old System Shock vs. Bioshock comparisons that cropped up previously.

This seems to be the only way longstanding franchises can last. Last time I raved about the rebooted Tomb Raider, which was infinitely more appealing than Lara Croft's past installments precisely because it expanded the character's story (something Judgment did) while altering the mechanics (which Judgment didn't). Somehow Irrational has made the formula feel new by altering the characters and story and only giving the gameplay a facelift. It's peculiar that dichotomy can exist, yet be successful in either case.

This is a potential solution for a series like Halo, which has scored with both sidestories and direct sequels, but began to show its age in the latest release in November. Bioshock proves you can completely strip away what would seem an essential element of a sequel, yet make it feel like part of the family.

— Joshua Gillin writes about video games and entertainment news for tbt*. Feel free to challenge his opinions at [email protected]

Comments
Irish boxer brings his dream to St. Petersburg

Irish boxer brings his dream to St. Petersburg

ST. PETERSBURG — In his vision for this weekend, Connor Coyle is standing in the ring at the Coliseum, and the referee is raising his gloved fist.He’s got a National Boxing Association middleweight championship belt around his waist, the first of sev...
Published: 06/15/18
With over 40 years between the birth of my two daughters, I am two different fathers

With over 40 years between the birth of my two daughters, I am two different fathers

Still shaken by Bobby Kennedy’s assassination six days earlier, I sat in the hospital waiting room mindlessly thumbing through a May 1968 Rolling Stone while my wife, Fran, gave birth to our daughter Elle. As was customary, when everyone had been fre...
Published: 06/15/18
Puerto Vallarta is a dreamy Mexican getaway within reach

Puerto Vallarta is a dreamy Mexican getaway within reach

LOREN ELLIOTT • Times CorrespondentPUERTO VALLARTA, MEXICOThe third-floor balcony attached to our rented apartment served as a peaceful refuge above Puerto Vallarta’s bustling central district streets. Below us, taxis honked, people crowded bus ...
Published: 06/15/18
How Tampa's Cole and Marmalade got famous, beat cancer and helped save more cats

How Tampa's Cole and Marmalade got famous, beat cancer and helped save more cats

Here's how to make your cat famous on the internet, according to the owners of some famous felines.
Published: 06/15/18
Irish boxer brings his dream to St. Petersburg

Irish boxer brings his dream to St. Petersburg

ST. PETERSBURG — In his vision for this weekend, Connor Coyle is standing in the ring at the Coliseum, and the referee is raising his gloved fist.He’s got a National Boxing Association middleweight championship belt around his waist, the first of sev...
Published: 06/14/18
Updated: 06/16/18
High-tech nighttime lagoon show coming to Universal Orlando this summer

High-tech nighttime lagoon show coming to Universal Orlando this summer

A gliding, wraith-like figure of a Dementor from the Harry Potter films enters Central Park, and the exteriors of the surrounding buildings immediately are covered in a layer of ice, a sign of their power to drain happiness out of the air around them...
Published: 06/14/18
Why this ballet dancer is skipping college in favor of her own St. Petersburg Ballet Conservatory

Why this ballet dancer is skipping college in favor of her own St. Petersburg Ballet Conservatory

GULFPORT — Brianna Melton is as serious a ballet student as they come.By her junior year at St. Petersburg High’s International Baccalaureate program, she had already spent four summers training with ballet companies across the country and had narrow...
Published: 06/14/18
Frito and Cheeto: How rescued seahorses found webcam fame

Frito and Cheeto: How rescued seahorses found webcam fame

Smile for the camera, Frito. The world is watching, and you have a story to tell. The tiny seahorse came to the Clearwater Marine Aquarium on Sunday with fishing line wrapped around her neck. By Wednesday, she became the CMA’s newest internet ...
Published: 06/13/18
Updated: 06/14/18
From soft serve to ice pops, 12 places to get frozen treats

From soft serve to ice pops, 12 places to get frozen treats

I know we have three more months or so of hot-as-dog-breath Tampa Bay summer, but let’s start things off on the right foot with some frozen treats. Ice cream is on my mind after a recent visit to Disney Springs, when I found love in a perfect scoop o...
Published: 06/13/18
He loves his Dad Shoes ... in all their lame, comfortable glory

He loves his Dad Shoes ... in all their lame, comfortable glory

Think of your father, and the first pair of shoes that come to mind. Grass-stained golf cleats. Crusty old mudders on the deck. Fraying, decaying Birkenstocks. Burgundy leather loafers, the slip-on kind, softened and flattened by the weight of so ma...
Published: 06/13/18