Wednesday, December 13, 2017
Features and More

The best punishment for Tony Soprano: To go on living

I have never particularly cared about whether mobster Tony Soprano (the late, tremendously lamented James Gandolfini) dies in the final episode of the seminal HBO series The Sopranos, which ended in 2007 with a fade to black that left a lot of viewers wondering if their television service had cut out. The conduct of Tony's life, the moral decisions the people in his life made in relation to him and the 86 episodes of television that preceded that moment, seem far more momentous.

But the debate revived this week when a profile of Sopranos creator David Chase was published on Vox.com. No, Chase was quoted as saying, Tony did not die. (Chase later issued a statement saying that the Vox reporter had misconstrued what he said. "As David Chase has said numerous times on the record, 'Whether Tony Soprano is alive or dead is not the point.' " the statement said. "The final scene of The Sopranos raises a spiritual question that has no right or wrong answer.")

But if we give in to our inability to tolerate ambiguity, and demand an answer the question, that Tony lived seems to me to be the preferable choice.

There are plenty of ways to think about his potential death.

If he went out in a hail of bullets in a New Jersey diner, we could interpret his end as inevitable, given his profession and the conventions of the genre of which his story is a part. Seeing Tony murdered before them might provide a galvanic kick to his family, forcing the reckoning with the reality of Tony's work which they have avoided so as to more comfortably enjoy the fruits of his criminal labors. Or death could be punishment for Tony himself.

But if we want Tony to suffer for the damage he has done to his family, his community and the people touched by his criminal enterprises, I think it is better for him to live.

This is in line with my general thinking on the death penalty. In addition to our inability to administer it without causing the kind of pain that we see as criminal when caused without the sanction of the state, it seems both harsher and more hopeful to keep our worst malefactors alive and capable of achieving a reckoning with the harm that they have caused.

And it strikes me that Tony's particular story is exceptionally well-suited for this sort of punishment. Tony's therapy with Dr. Jennifer Melfi comes to an end in part because she has become convinced that by making Tony a more functional person, she has helped make him a more effective criminal. But I think it is undeniable that she has also made Tony more aware of himself and his feelings. In a sense, she has created the perfect condition for Tony's ongoing punishment: an ability to continue committing bad acts while seeing them with increasing clarity.

The Vox profile of Chase discusses his affinity for Edgar Allen Poe and Herman Melville, among other authors. To me, Tony Soprano has a different analogue. He is a grubbier, smaller version of John Milton's Satan in the fourth book of Paradise Lost, aware of what it would take for him to be a better person and ultimately unwilling to extricate himself from a disaster of his own making.

"Which way I fly is Hell; myself am Hell," Milton's Satan ruminated. That seems like a decent description of Tony Soprano. That he has to share Satan's fate and live with himself forever, or at least until his natural death, is a far crueler fate than for him to be cut down by the man in the Member's Only jacket.

Comments
The Phantom never dies, orchestra doings this week

The Phantom never dies, orchestra doings this week

PHANTOM REDUX: LOVE NEVER DIESTurns out, the Phantom survived that angry mob. We know that because the antihero of Andrew Lloyd Webberís 1986 musical The Phantom of the Opera re-emerges in the 2010 sequel, Love Never Dies.It opens in 1907 New York, w...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Top things to do this week: Star Wars parties, comics Gilbert Gottfried, Michael Carbonaro

Top things to do this week: Star Wars parties, comics Gilbert Gottfried, Michael Carbonaro

NEW HOPE: Star Wars partiesWith the opening of Star Wars: The Last Jedi, the force of fan excitement is strong, so of course there are Star Wars parties this weekend. The giant movie complex Riverview 14 GDX is having celebration with characters from...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Even post-Weinstein, 'Baby, It's Cold Outside' is extremely popular

Even post-Weinstein, 'Baby, It's Cold Outside' is extremely popular

Gifts are wrapped, halls are decked and people are on Twitter calling Baby, It’s Cold Outside a "sexual predator anthem." It’s a holiday tradition for the social media age. Pointing out the creepiness of the song — or "rapeyness," ...
Published: 12/13/17

Holiday help in Pasco County for Dec. 15

Farm Share giveaway set for Dec. 15Pasco County Tax Collector Mike Fasano, Sheriff Chris Nocco, Supervisor of Elections Brian Corley, Florida House Speaker Richard Corcoran and Property Appraiser Gary Joiner will host the 23rd annual Farm Share Holid...
Published: 12/13/17
Hometown Pasco for Dec. 15

Hometown Pasco for Dec. 15

We want your news!Hometown Pasco is devoted to everyday life in our county, whether itís snapshots from your family reunion, recreational sporting event, news from your last club meeting or just a few lines thanking someone for a job well done. You ...
Published: 12/13/17
5 things to do under $5: Gasparilla Bowl beach day, Hanukkah on Ice, boat parades

5 things to do under $5: Gasparilla Bowl beach day, Hanukkah on Ice, boat parades

1 Battle at the Beach: The Gasparilla Bowl is coming to Tropicana Field on Dec. 21, but before that the bands, cheerleaders and dance teams from Florida International University and Temple University will have a day of beach-related games and competi...
Published: 12/13/17
Hometown Hernando for Dec. 15

Hometown Hernando for Dec. 15

We want your news!Hometown Hernando is devoted to everyday life in our county, whether itís snapshots from your family reunion, recreational sporting event, news from your last club meeting or just a few lines thanking someone for a job well done. Y...
Published: 12/13/17
6 gift ideas for grandparents and grandchildren to spend more time together

6 gift ideas for grandparents and grandchildren to spend more time together

A grandparent can be a tough person to buy a Christmas gift for. Likewise, many grandparents are stumped on what to get the kids besides some cash. Why not make your Christmas gift something you both want more of: more time together making memories. ...
Published: 12/13/17
Five trendy gift ideas for the cook in your life

Five trendy gift ideas for the cook in your life

Giving the gift of cooking isnít really something you can mess up. Whether gifting a gadget or paying for a class, you can encourage a budding culinary enthusiast or give a seasoned veteran a new toy to play with. Here are five ideas for holiday gi...
Published: 12/13/17
Four ideas for edible gifts you can find throughout Tampa Bay

Four ideas for edible gifts you can find throughout Tampa Bay

Carlynn Crosby, Times correspondent Florida Pure Sea Salt Harvested from Tampa Bay’s waters, these handcrafted salts come in flavors like maple bacon, Sriracha, lemongrass, habanero or black truffle. They retail for $15 a jar online, at flor...
Published: 12/13/17