Saturday, November 25, 2017
Parenting & Relationships

Encourage college son's passion, but counsel him on backup career plan

RECOMMENDED READING


Adapted from a recent online discussion.

Encourage college son's passion, but advise him on backup plan

Q: My son is a freshman at an academically challenging liberal arts college. He is telling us that he is struggling to keep up, and, yes, we've told him to go to the academic advising office and the like.

The larger issue is what he is concluding from his struggles — that he wants to become a music major — which is okay, except that his goal is to parlay his mediocre musical talents (not just my opinion) to a performance career.

I don't want to quash the hopes of any 18-year-old, but how to make the best of this situation? Tell him to leave college (we'll keep his college fund in the bank) and get a job or pursue, e.g., vocational education, and work on his music in the evenings like other budding artists? Let him pursue a music major but remind him of the likelihood of a future as a band teacher (nothing wrong with that in our eyes)? Let him figure everything out on his own (as we're paying ... )?

College/life decisions

Carolyn: Interesting. On one hand, you have the fact that your son probably won't get far doing something he hates, and that points to supporting his passion as arguably the best path for him to succeed. (Let's define success as "self-supporting in a non-soul-crushing line of work.")

On the other hand, you don't want to just smile and write checks while your son squanders his opportunity to learn something that's both satisfying and practical — and that points to using your financial leverage to be the voice of economic reality.

How bout we split the baby. You support the music major, while insisting that he develop alternatives to a performance career. It's not as if all the best musicians perform and all the rest teach. The ones who perform for a living are but a small percentage of the musicians out there, and talent is but one variable. Even a befuddled 18-year-old has to know that.

So, as his guardians and clickers of the "pay" button, you can say you're all for this as long as there's a clear structure to his Plan B. Work with him on it as needed. Music and sound both are businesses, and any business has people of all talents involved, from creative types to bean-counters.

There's also the matter of unintended consequences. It seems as if your son could use a confidence boost right now — and it seems to me that it will be easier for him to recover later from a bad choice of major than it will be for him to recover now from low self-confidence.

Re: Musical son:

Anonymous: I just want to make sure your line about lots of different kinds of jobs in the music industry didn't get buried. I used to suggest that all the time to students I worked with who all wanted to be professional basketball players. There are lots of great jobs in sports. Perhaps this young man can get an internship in the field that will open his eyes to more possibilities.

Carolyn: Amen re: sports. In liberal-arts land, it can seem as if the only career paths are law, medicine, business, education and stardom. Anyone who can preach variety should.

Comments

Tell Me About It: Shut down sister-in-law’s weight shaming

Shut down sister-in-law’s weight shamingQ: My sister and her wife, "Sue," will be visiting soon. I’m feeling anxiety about Sue’s visit.Sue has a habit of making comments about my weight and what I’m eating — commenting on my portion size, how many he...
Published: 11/24/17
Top things to do this weekend: Lindsey Stirling, Faizon Love, Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood Live

Top things to do this weekend: Lindsey Stirling, Faizon Love, Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood Live

PULLING STRINGS: Lindsey StirlingDubstep violist Lindsey Stirling shot to fame as a quarter-finalist on America’s Got Talent in 2010 and she has been rocking the spangles on Dancing With the Stars this season as the last woman left . But on Friday yo...
Published: 11/22/17
Updated: 11/24/17
5 things to do under $5 Nov. 23-30: Craft festival, License-Free Saltwater Fishing Day, Snow Bash

5 things to do under $5 Nov. 23-30: Craft festival, License-Free Saltwater Fishing Day, Snow Bash

1. Gem, Jewelry and Bead Show and Sale: Check out these rocks when more than 50 dealers from around the United States sell crystals, minerals, beads, gems and jewelry. $5. Coliseum, 535 Fourth Ave. N, St. Petersburg. 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Friday through ...
Published: 11/22/17
Updated: 11/24/17

Tell Me About It: Frequently-visiting sister needs to pitch in

Frequently visiting sister needs to pitch inQ: I live overseas with my husband and two boys. My sister visits often due to work travel and generous vacation benefits. Sounds great — especially as I have no other family member who can visit as often, ...
Published: 11/22/17
Plan your weekend: Indie shopping, Lindsey Stirling, ice skating, Amy Grant and Michael W. Smith

Plan your weekend: Indie shopping, Lindsey Stirling, ice skating, Amy Grant and Michael W. Smith

Shopping Black Friday: Avoid the madness of the malls at a variety of indie shopping experiences this weekend. Skatepark of Tampa has one of the best sneaker selections in Tampa Bay and free skating all day Friday to celebrate. They’ll open at...
Published: 11/21/17
Updated: 11/24/17
Black Friday deals at Legoland, SeaWorld, Disney and more

Black Friday deals at Legoland, SeaWorld, Disney and more

Black Friday isn’t just for stores. Many theme parks and attractions in Florida are also offering up deals that could make a nice gift or family splurge. The smaller the park, the bigger the deal, so Legoland, Gatorland and SeaWorld are toutin...
Published: 11/21/17
Updated: 11/23/17
Mark your calendars: Here are the top holiday concerts, ‘Nutcracker’ shows and parades

Mark your calendars: Here are the top holiday concerts, ‘Nutcracker’ shows and parades

Get out your calendar, set aside the time and get tickets to see the top holiday shows and parties coming this season. Here are our editor’s picks for the holidays:CONCERTS98 Degrees The turn-of-the-millennium boy band brings their new holiday tour p...
Published: 11/21/17
Updated: 11/22/17
Here's where to see Christmas lights in Tampa Bay

Here's where to see Christmas lights in Tampa Bay

Once the Thanksgiving leftovers are put away, you can stop grumbling about it being too early for Christmas lights and decorations. Let the grand illuminations begin! Despite our tropical climate, or maybe because of it, Tampa Bay goes all out when ...
Published: 11/21/17

Tell Me About It: Sister’s partner is a textbook abuser

Sister’s partner is a textbook abuserQ: My sister stays home with her two small children (2 and 1) while her partner works. Recently, during a fight, he took all of their money and left. He has since returned and they have patched things up for now. ...
Published: 11/21/17
Disney-Pixar’s ‘Coco’ has a Dia de los Muertos theme and is, well, lifeless

Disney-Pixar’s ‘Coco’ has a Dia de los Muertos theme and is, well, lifeless

Disney-Pixar’s Coco was more enjoyable three years ago when it was titled The Book of Life and came from Twentieth Century Fox.Both animated features spring from Mexico’s Dia de los Muertos celebration, the annual "day of the dead" when departed rela...
Published: 11/20/17
Updated: 11/23/17