Tuesday, February 20, 2018
Parenting & Relationships

Friend's love triangle leaves woman in quandary

Adapted from a recent online discussion.

Friend's love triangle leaves woman in quite a quandary

Q: I have a good friend, "Judy," who is in a shaky engagement where she's trying to sort through a lot of issues with the guy, "Andy." She is battling lingering feelings she has for her best guy friend, "James," which become stronger when she is fighting with Andy (the guys are exact opposites).

To make it more complicated, James is interested in me, and I am interested in him. I would never make a move. However, James recently asked me on a date (I am newly single). I said no, being loyal to Judy. She got mad at him for asking me out and confessed her feelings. He does not feel the same way toward her; he feels awkward and is distancing himself from her.

Her relationship with Andy has since gotten much stronger and seems to be on the permanent up and up.

Is there ever going to be an appropriate time where Judy and James have distanced themselves enough from each other, and Judy is satisfied enough with her relationship with Andy, that I can ask permission to give it a go with James? I would be content if she answered, "No!" but my friends say Judy has no right to block James from me since she is engaged, etc.


A: Are you all fish in an aquarium, and you dictated the letter to your human keeper?

I'll try answering bottom to top:

• Your friends are right, Judy has no right to insist you and James can't date.

• You can, out of respect for Judy and her relationship, choose to hold off for a while as Judy recovers from her feelings for James (do let James in on this). Then, if you do start dating James, you can also respect the distance between him and Judy as necessary for Judy's peace of mind, and not throw them together frequently in the same social situations.

Ideally Judy will fall decisively for her fiance — well, ideally she would have before getting engaged to him, but I write for the reality I've got — but sometimes that just doesn't happen; people are quite capable of dwelling on someone permanently, and often find they can get on with their lives only if they stay away from that person for good.

• There is an appropriate time for you and James to try dating. Judy and Andy's wedding makes a convenient milestone, but I'm not convinced that day should ever come, or will. If it doesn't, then I'd say wait till Judy stops dwelling on James — or, alternately, when your interest in James outweighs your friendship with Judy. Whichever comes first.

• About the aquarium. If you do all inhabit a smallish world, then it may be that you and James are interested in each other because you've exhausted your interests in the other available people. Offices get like this, grad programs do, college buddies do, and TV shows that have been on the air for more than a couple of seasons ... anyway, all that means is that it's a good idea to question your interest in James before you act on it, just in case. Probably a sensible path with anyone, but it's especially important when a circle of friends gets a bit incestuous.


Tell Me About It: Play up challenged child’s strengths

Q: One of my children has a challenging personality. Within my family, we are aware of it, and deal with it, and love him oh-so-much. As he is getting older, I can see how the outside world (teachers, coaches, neighbors) favors him less than my other...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Tell Me About It: DNA results reveal 52-year-old secret

Q: I am in the middle of a growing crisis in my extended family because of revelations from a DNA match. After getting my results, I was contacted by a woman looking for her biological family. It quickly became apparent she was the child my sister ga...
Published: 02/20/18

Tell Me About It: Don’t expect help from careless grandma

Q: My mother moved to be closer to us when we had a baby, who’s now 2. She’s not responsible with him. She gives him anything he points to and grunts. Just in the past month, this has included a lighter ("He doesn’t know how to use it"), garden shear...
Published: 02/19/18
Ordinary dogs take to the Derby Lane greyhound track for the Mutt Derby

Ordinary dogs take to the Derby Lane greyhound track for the Mutt Derby

Some stopped midway, some turned around and ran the wrong way and some dashed to the arms of their owners as more than 300 average house pets took to the track at Derby Lane on Sunday for the Mutt Derby. The popular fundraiser for the Jaycees died o...
Published: 02/18/18

Tell Me About It: Doubts creep in to six-year relationship

Q: I have been with my partner for six years and have just graduated from college. I love my partner and could see myself happily married to them for the long haul. However, I am beginning to feel wistful about never having dated anyone else — or kis...
Published: 02/18/18

Tell Me About It: Vacation opens dialogue about money

Vacation opens dialogue about moneyQ: My girlfriend and I just went on our first vacation together. I thought it went well, but after we were home she told me she felt I had been cheap because I wanted to split all costs 50-50.I think cheap would be ...
Published: 02/16/18
Top things to do in Tampa Bay for the week of Feb. 19-25

Top things to do in Tampa Bay for the week of Feb. 19-25

Gasparilla Distance Classic: One of Tampa’s best known road races returns to downtown, with a 5K and 15K Saturday and an 8K and half marathon on Sunday. The chief attraction is the 15K on Saturday, which takes runners out and back along the man...
Published: 02/15/18
Updated: 02/18/18
Dance Moms star Chloe Lukasiak to appear at Florida State Fair on Saturday

Dance Moms star Chloe Lukasiak to appear at Florida State Fair on Saturday

TAMPA — Chloe Lukasiak will take on a different role than she is accustomed when she stops by the Florida State Fair this weekend.After all, the 16-year-old Pennsylvania-native and resident rose to fame on Seasons 1 through 4 of Lifetime’s reality te...
Published: 02/15/18

Tell Me About It: Past eating disorder affects food choices

Q: My wife refuses to change her diet and grocery shopping to accommodate my health needs and those of our kids. Everything she gets is processed grains and sugar. My doctor recently recommended losing weight, and exercise won’t cut it. But because s...
Published: 02/15/18
Top things to do this weekend: Florida State Fair, Mutt Derby at Derby Lane

Top things to do this weekend: Florida State Fair, Mutt Derby at Derby Lane

GO, DOG, GO: Mutt DerbyOne of the most hilarious days at the races is Sunday, when ordinary house pets get a chance to run on the Derby Lane greyhound track. Mutt Derby registration begins at 11 a.m., but you can register in advance at greyhoundpets...
Published: 02/14/18