Make us your home page

From rubble to revival

NEW YORK — Out of the ashes of 9/11 has risen a vibrant neighborhood packed with new restaurants and hotels, places to live and spots to shop, along with many ways to pay respects to an area some worried would never come back.

A decade after the attack on the World Trade Center, Lower Manhattan draws roughly 9 million of the city's nearly 50 million visitors a year, including the area around ground zero.

The neighborhood now has 18 hotels with more than 4,000 rooms, up from six hotels and 2,300 rooms on Sept. 11, 2001. For many tourists, it's a must-see, right up there with Times Square and the Statue of Liberty.

"It's a 24/7 neighborhood," said George Fertitta, chief executive of NYC & Company, the city's marketing and tourism arm. "It's a great moment in time for Lower Manhattan."

While local shopping, restaurants and other attractions abound, remembering 9/11 is the primary focus for many visitors. The new memorial at ground zero will open on the 10th anniversary of the tragedy. A museum will open at the site a year later under a glass atrium, taking visitors 70 feet down on gentle ramps to the very epicenter of what used to be "the pit."

Ans van de Pasch, 49, of Venlo in southeastern Holland, first visited ground zero three years ago, peeking through masked fences like thousands of others. This summer, the site is more visible, and she brought her husband and two teens.

"There's a different spirit. You can feel the community is back," Pasch said as they walked through the nearby St. Paul's Chapel, where weary firefighters, police and volunteer rescuers sought refuge during their desperate work in 2001.

She wanted her kids to see the ground zero area for themselves. "It's very necessary that you can have one moment in your life when you let yourself, as a citizen of the world, stop and think, 'This must never happen again.' "

Here are some details on visiting the memorial, along with suggestions for other things to do in Lower Manhattan, from intimate tours offered by the September 11 Families' Association to shopping, parks and restaurants.

National September 11 Memorial & Museum

The memorial is a big reveal years in the making. Created by design competition winner Michael Arad, who partnered with California landscape architect Peter Walker, it takes up about half of the 16-acre site. Additional office buildings and a new transit hub remain under construction with the museum.

The memorial will be dedicated on Sept. 11 during a ceremony for victims' families. It opens to the public the next day.

"The fact that this memorial outlines the very footprints where these towers stood sends a message to the world of what we lost that day and how we've come together," said memorial president Joe Daniels.

On the twin footprints of the towers are gentle waterfalls that empty into massive reflecting pools edged by bronze parapets with the names of the 2,983 people killed on 9/11 in New York, in a field near Shanksville, Pa., and at the Pentagon, along with victims of the 1993 bombing at the World Trade Center.

"Could they do it again?" 9-year-old Grisham Aleshire of Springfield, Mo., asks, looking out at the construction where the fallen towers stood. "They have lots of security now," mom Tia reassures.

When the memorial opens, 225 swamp white oak trees will have been planted around the site. More than 400 are planned overall, creating an urban grove. On the west side of the south pool, bordering a small clearing called the memorial glade, stands the "survivor tree." It's a Callery pear rescued from the rubble and nursed back to health in the Bronx, only to be struck by lightning and survive again last year. President Barack Obama laid a wreath at the tree in May, and new growth on branches that were once almost entirely shorn is thriving.

If you go: Access to the site can be confusing as construction continues. Many subway stops, including those at Chambers and Fulton streets, will bring you nearby. Timed tickets (free but required) can be reserved up to six months in advance at About 250,000 passes have already been reserved. Print your tickets beforehand if you can. Enter at the northeast corner of Albany and Greenwich streets for check-in no more than 30 minutes ahead of your reservation.

Hours: Through Jan. 8, the memorial is open 10 a.m. to last entry at 7 p.m. weekdays; 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. weekends; last entry at 5 p.m. Jan. 9-March 10.

Restrooms: No restrooms will be available on site until the museum opens in September 2012. The World Financial Center's glass-enclosed Winter Garden has public restrooms and there are some on the second floor of the Burger King on Liberty Street at Church.


The September 11 Families' Association offers intimate tours led by survivors, 9/11 workers and loved ones of those who perished.

Tracy Gazzani, a retired schoolteacher from Brooklyn, has done more than 150 of the tours, recounting the life and loss of her 24-year-old son, Terry. He worked a bonds desk at Cantor Fitzgerald on the 104th floor of the north tower.

She spoke haltingly about learning of people who were jumping from the burning towers and her family's frantic distribution of fliers in search of Terry in the aftermath.

"This is my way of healing," Gazzani said, "my way of helping other people heal, because it's very important that we all learn to heal."

top view: The tours stop in the World Financial Center buildings for bird's-eye views of ground zero as guides tell their stories to groups of no more than 20.

If you go: Tours ($10, under 12 free) are offered daily from the Tribute WTC Visitor Center, run by the families' association, at 120 Liberty St. across from ground zero. Only groups of 10 or more may reserve a tour in advance; others should check the tour schedule at and arrive at least an hour before scheduled departure time.

Must-see: The tours usually include a stop at "11 Tears," a memorial honoring 11 American Express employees who died on 9/11, located in the company's headquarters in the lobby of 3 World Financial Center. Suspended above an 11-sided granite pool is a 600-pound quartz stone, carved into an 11-sided teardrop. Eleven drops of water fall into the pool periodically, creating intersecting ripples. Victims' names and words chosen by their loved ones are etched on the stone.

Fire Department Memorial

Next door to the Tribute WTC Visitor Center, outside the firehouse on Greenwich Street at Liberty, is the Fire Department of New York Memorial Wall. The firehouse, home to Ladder Co. 3, Engine Co. 10, lost five firefighters on 9/11, but the wall is a tribute to all firefighters who died. It was a gift from the law firm Holland & Knight and also honors one of the firm's partners, Glenn J. Winuk, a volunteer firefighter and medic from Jericho, N.Y. He helped evacuate the firm's offices near the World Trade Center, then raced to the towers to help. Winuk died when the south tower collapsed.


St. Paul's Chapel, a small Episcopal church built in 1766, miraculously survived 9/11 just across the street from the World Trade Center. Through May 2002, volunteers ministered around the clock to ground zero workers at the chapel. Now on display, the exhibit "Unwavering Spirit" includes one of many cots set up with hand-knit blankets and stuffed animals during the harrowing work. A collection of uniform patches paying tribute to volunteers from around the world still smells of smoke. Enter through the graveyard, on Church Street, between Vesey and Fulton.

Part of the same Episcopal parish, Trinity Church at the corner of Broadway and Wall Street was another nearby refuge for relief workers. A sculpture out front was made out of a giant sycamore tree destroyed on 9/11.


Nearby museums include the National Museum of the American Indian, New York Police Museum, the Museum of Jewish Heritage, which honors victims of the Holocaust, and the Skyscraper Museum in Battery Park City.

Restaurants, shopping and deals

get a bite: Stone Street, a cobblestone pedestrian mall closed to traffic, is lined with restaurants offering outdoor table service. The popular Adrienne's Pizzabar is on Stone between Broad and Hanover. One of New York's oldest steak houses, Delmonico's, is nearby on Beaver; historic Fraunces Tavern — with a museum — is on Pearl.

Shop til you drop: Shopping ranges from bargains at the massive Century 21 store across from ground zero to luxury retailers like Hermes, 15 Broad St., and Tiffany, 37 Wall St. Street vendors, the tribute center shop and many other places sell postcards, photos and other 9/11 mementos.

Super savings: A new campaign from NYC & Company includes Lower Manhattan hotel deals, restaurant promotions and merchant discounts at getmorenyc/lower-manhattan. The Downtown Alliance of New York — — is a trove of information on things to do and how to get around.


With 25 acres of waterfront parkland, the Battery is the largest public open space in Lower Manhattan. Pier 25 on the Hudson River in Tribeca between Franklin and North Moore streets has an 18-hole miniature golf course, beach volleyball, picnic lawn and playground. Near the Police Museum, Old Slip Park is a good place to rest tired feet.

Near Pearl Street, the British Garden at Hanover Square honors 67 British subjects who died on 9/11. Queen Elizabeth II, in long sleeves, white gloves and hat, officially opened the park in searing heat last July.

Wall Street: Never mind the bear market. Stop by for a photo op with the famous bronze charging bull sculpture in Bowling Green Park near 26 Broadway, or dive into the neighborhood's history on a guided tour from Wall Street Walks — All include ground zero.


Other 9/11 memorials

Pentagon Memorial is at 1 Rotary Road on the Pentagon Reservation in Arlington, Va.; and The memorial is open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, barring an elevated threat at the Pentagon or certain special commemorative events. Free admission. Visitors are encouraged to take mass transit, using the Pentagon stop on the yellow and blue lines of the region's Metrorail system. (The walk from the station to the memorial still exceeds 500 yards.) The Pentagon also is served by an extensive network of bus routes. Those driving to the memorial can park for a fee at the Fashion Centre mall at Pentagon City. The Pentagon parking lots are generally off limits to the public, though the Hayes Street lot is usually available to visitors on nights and weekends.

Flight 93 Memorial is about a 90-minute drive from Pittsburgh, 3 1/2 hours from Washington, and five hours from New York City. Information: Take the Somerset exit (No. 110) off the Pennsylvania Turnpike (Interstate 76), and the toll booth operator can give you directions to the memorial, which is off a small country road. Open 9 a.m.-7 p.m. April 1 to mid October (winter hours 9 a.m.-5 p.m.). No entrance fee.

Construction is ongoing at the memorial, which currently has only temporary restroom facilities. Huge crowds are expected for the 10th anniversary of 9/11, and scheduled visits that weekend from President Barack Obama and Vice President Joe Biden may add to traffic woes. Groups that want to schedule a visit should contact the park office in advance at (814) 893-6322. Programs or ceremonies require a permit, which is not guaranteed.

From rubble to revival 08/20/11 [Last modified: Saturday, August 20, 2011 4:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours