Saturday, September 22, 2018
Features and More

Review: Artist of great mind and talent has a show one flight up at Florida Holocaust Museum

ST. PETERSBURG

Much of the art that takes the Holocaust as its subject is created by people who had a personal experience with it. Judith Weinshall Liberman was a young girl growing up in what is now Israel during World War II and has said she had no such connection beyond remembering her father's anguish when discussing news that began filtering in about European Jews' horrific plight.

Yet a chord was struck that began resonating strongly 40 years later and led to a large series of Holocaust-related paintings and wall hangings that occupied her for more than a decade beginning in 1987 when she was in her late 50s. The Florida Holocaust Museum has many of them in its permanent collection, and they're now on view in its second-floor galleries.

Most works fall into two groups that Liberman calls maps and scenes. Some scenes are literal narratives — of concentration camp life, for example — and others are more symbolic. The maps are also symbolic but the symbols are used to convey statistics of death and diaspora.

The latter group is more effective in its presentation of devastation, perhaps because the hundreds of photographs available to us of the real people and their suffering are more moving and immediate than paintings of them could be. The most effective scenes are those that use fewer details, such as Boarding, in which a large group of men, women and children stand in front of a boxcar waiting to be loaded. The crowd is huge in proportion to the train car. The faces and bodies are simple shapes, and their near-abstraction illustrates the depersonalization of the experience.

Liberman uses a spare and somber palette of black, gray and red in most of the works. They're obvious choices for death, despair and bloodshed, and I compare them to the work of Samuel Bak, who recently had a show at the museum and who often and effectively infuses his Holocaust-themed paintings with glorious jewel tones.

Limiting color is a good choice for her maps, however, which chronicle the history using numbers and geography and don't need visual distractions in doing so.

In the wall hanging Gypsies, Too, the map of Europe is filled with hands bearing the number of that population who died and reminds us that Jews weren't the only ones persecuted. The hands become a good metaphor for the Gypsies who made much of their livelihood from palm-reading and fortune-telling but whose own fates passed into the hands of others.

For 2000 Years, Liberman uses Gothic lettering to date the numerous Jewish communities established over millennia, many of which were wiped out in less than a decade.

She uses screened photographs on many of the wall hangings. Two designed as prayer shawls have such images, of real confiscated shawls on one and of burned Torahs on another.

This exhibition is enhanced by the inclusion of paintings unrelated to the Holocaust. They are of animal skulls created, she says in the wall label, during a course she took in 1971, using oil instead of the acrylic she switched to. Several of them show the influence of Georgia O'Keeffe's cow skulls, and two of turtle skulls are sculptural and abstract. They show her skill simply as a painter without a didactic motive.

Liberman first trained to become a lawyer; she holds two law degrees, from the University of Chicago and University of Michigan. Living in Boston in her mid 30s, she studied art and began painting in earnest at that time. Now in her 80s, she has become a playwright, too. She is a person of protean intelligence and prodigious talent and has used both to explore a subject that will continue to haunt human history with the question: How could we let this happen?

But I am conflicted by art that can't be appreciated on a purely aesthetic level, which is true of many historical paintings. Is its main purpose to educate and remind us? If a viewer knew nothing of the Holocaust, the way this art is seen would be a different experience with different criteria.

Consider Picasso's Guernica, painted in direct response to the bombing of a Spanish village during the Spanish Civil War. Most people who see it today don't know its literal context; they only know they are witnessing a scene of senseless death, violence and desolation that can be grasped and understood universally. Guernica's destruction was a minor event by war standards, yet the painting commemorating it has made a more pervasive statement about evil and senseless annihilation than any other dealing with bigger subjects. It's one of the few works of art I can think of that effectively commemorates a specific event and universalizes it. (Worth noting is that no great art has yet emerged dealing with the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11.)

Art like Liberman's should be valued in the same way we value all meaningful responses to tragedy. I also believe that art like this is better served in group shows in which the artistic responses are varied and individual. They represent the truth we need to remember: In the mind-numbing numbers of the Holocaust, each one represents an individual death.

Lennie Bennett can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8293.

Comments
Franklin on Twiggs restaurant opens in former downtown Tampa Pita Pit location

Franklin on Twiggs restaurant opens in former downtown Tampa Pita Pit location

DOWNTOWN — After a falling out with the Pita Pit corporate offices, Andrew Turek, the former owner of the SoHo location sold the property to Shula Burger and decided to open a new eatery and market called Franklin on Twiggs in the former downt...
Updated: 7 hours ago
At 50, Clearwater's real-life superhero is hanging up his super suit

At 50, Clearwater's real-life superhero is hanging up his super suit

CLEARWATER — For two decades, Dale Pople patrolled the streets feeding the homeless, helping old people carry groceries, extinguishing a car fire. He wore a red, yellow and blue Spandex outfit with an SH emblem: "Super Hero." Now, Clearwater&...
Published: 09/21/18
Reality bites: SeaWorld abandons virtual reality headsets on Kraken coaster

Reality bites: SeaWorld abandons virtual reality headsets on Kraken coaster

SeaWorld has ditched the experiment that made it the first major ride in Florida to incorporate virtual reality.Last June, the theme park announced with much fanfare a new feature that would project an undersea showdown on Kraken, incorporating VR he...
Published: 09/20/18
Updated: 09/21/18
Bar review: Punk meets Pilsner at Antibrewery in Dunedin

Bar review: Punk meets Pilsner at Antibrewery in Dunedin

I’ve had readers jokingly complain that I’ve exposed their off-the-radar watering holes that already are a carful away from becoming overcrowded. It’s like watching your favorite indie band achieve mainstream success: It’s good for them, but now you’...
Published: 09/20/18
The making of a nightmare: Behind the scenes at Busch Gardens Howl-O-Scream

The making of a nightmare: Behind the scenes at Busch Gardens Howl-O-Scream

TAMPA — Once the scare actors were made up, they headed toward the haunted house to rehearse.But it wasn’t quite time for them to be scary yet. Busch Gardens, which opens its Howl-O-Scream Halloween scarefest on Friday, was still open for regular bus...
Published: 09/20/18
Disney will close Epcot’s popular fireworks show IllumiNations after nearly 20 years

Disney will close Epcot’s popular fireworks show IllumiNations after nearly 20 years

After nearly 20 years, the popular Epcot fireworks show, IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth, will go dark next summer. The Disney Parks Blog announced this week that the award-winning complex show that incorporates fire, water and video effects will...
Published: 09/19/18
Updated: 09/21/18
Five ideas for date-night dinners at home

Five ideas for date-night dinners at home

For your next date night with your significant other, try staying in and cooking together. Meals eaten with your loved one are always sweeter. Literally."When we are in love … food tastes better," said Rachel Herz, an adjunct professor of psychiatry ...
Published: 09/19/18
Updated: 09/21/18
Mark your calendar for these Halloween events

Mark your calendar for these Halloween events

13 Ugly Men Halloween PartyThese "ugly" men sure know how to party with three floors offering new tricks and treats, DJ dancing and a light show making the 10th annual Halloween party a "Party with a Purpose." Benefits Beat NB. 8 p.m. Oct. 26. Ybor’s...
Published: 09/19/18
Despite the razzle-dazzle, ‘Chicago’ is starting to feel dated

Despite the razzle-dazzle, ‘Chicago’ is starting to feel dated

TAMPA — There’s a reason Chicago has been delighting audiences since 1975, and is one of the longest-running musicals in Broadway history. Jaded and funny, fast-paced and flamboyant, this sentimental journey to the tabloid culture still seems ahead o...
Published: 09/19/18

He behaved badly, big time. How to come clean?Q: When I was about 20, I got my girlfriend pregnant. She was 23 and wanted the baby, whereas I was not ready to be a father, so she broke up with me and had the baby pretty much on her own. Her family he...
Published: 09/19/18