Make us your home page

$15,000 for a knee cooler: a case study in medical madness

Polar Care Cube chiller is $189 on Amazon.

Polar Care Cube chiller is $189 on Amazon.

Why treat someone with a $200 medical device when you can get similar results with a $17,500 gadget? The answer to that question helps explain why Americans pay far more for health care on average than anyone else in the world, and why patients' medical woes are viewed as profit centers by the roughly $3-trillion health care industry.

I wrote recently about a man named Bill Erickson, who was slapped with a bill for $15,000 for temporary use of a cooling device intended to ease the pain of knee surgery. His insurer, Anthem Blue Cross, had covered only a few thousand bucks of the total cost.

The column focused on why Erickson, 64, received such a charge for one knee when the device was provided free after his other knee was operated on in 2010. "Same doctor, same hospital, same procedure," he told me.

But dozens of readers who'd experienced similar procedures zeroed in another point: How on earth can anyone charge $15,000 for a knee cooler?

Ron Williams said his wife had both her knees replaced during the last nine months. He said he found "knee chillers" online for under $200. "This is a machine equivalent to a Dust Devil vacuum cleaner that sucks and blows ice water rather than air through a blood pressure cuff," Williams said. "If you add it all up, you can't have more than a couple hundred dollars' worth of equipment."

The device provided to Erickson after both his operations was from a company called Affiliated Home Health Care. In both cases, he said, the toaster-size machine was handed to him as he was leaving St. John's Health Center in Santa Monica, Calif.

After the 2010 operation, Affiliated billed Erickson's insurer, Anthem, $17,500 for a few weeks' use of the knee cooler. Darrel Ng, an Anthem spokesman, said the insurer paid the out-of-network Affiliated about $4,000. Erickson said he was never billed for the remaining $13,500.

Anthem said it paid Affiliated about the same amount after Erickson's second knee surgery last year. This time, though, Affiliated wanted $15,000 from Erickson to make up the difference.

Affiliated is owned by an Arizona company, Maldonado Medical. Brandon Maldonado, head of that company, told me the reason its cooling device is so pricey is because it works better than anything else available. There's just no comparison with other such devices, he said. "You're dealing with Ferraris and Chevys here."

Various knee-cooling treatments can be found on, ranging from relatively inexpensive wraps containing ice packs to portable devices that can pump chilled water to the knee for hours. One such gadget, the Polar Care Cube, can be purchased for $188.99.

Some top insurers have decided that Maldonado's device offers no appreciable advantages over other forms of cooling therapy. Anthem's Ng said the insurer checked out Maldonado's system and determined that "there is no evidence this cooling device is any more effective than an ice pack." The insurance giant Aetna similarly concluded that Maldonado's machine "provides no additional clinical utility or impact on health outcomes than the use of ice."

Maldonado dismissed such findings. He said insurance companies make such decisions based on cost, not medical efficacy.

He also said he has no intention to squeeze Erickson for the outstanding $15,000. The company will pursue the money solely from Anthem.

Maybe the biggest question is why a hospital would provide patients with a medical device that's much more expensive than other available devices and not covered by leading insurers.

A spokeswoman for St. John's said such decisions rest with individual doctors. Erickson's doctor, Andrew Yun, didn't return calls for comment. But if I had to guess, I'd say Yun had no idea how much the device cost. Many doctors have told me they typically don't check on the prices charged to patients.

And this is a key part of the problem. Think about it: A patient was handed a device that can sell for less than $200, but in this case it was one that rented for $17,500. And neither he, his doctor nor even the hospital probably was aware of the whopping price tag.

Our health system won't begin to shed its dysfunctionality until rational pricing is introduced — and until doctors and hospitals take a more active role in reducing patients' costs.

— Los Angeles Times

$15,000 for a knee cooler: a case study in medical madness 08/05/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, August 5, 2014 3:28pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Tribune News Service.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours