Wednesday, May 23, 2018

Aereo loses to broadcasters in Supreme Court decision

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled against video startup Aereo in a sweeping decision that will maintain the status quo for television viewers even as they grow increasingly impatient with the slow movement of TV entertainment away from traditional television services and onto the Internet.

Aereo, a small streaming video service, provided one crucial piece of content that could prompt more consumers to cancel their cable subscriptions: live television. It allowed users to view — at their convenience — sports games, awards shows and other programs on the device of their choice for a monthly fee of $8 to $12. Aereo, along with Netflix or Hulu and a broadband Internet subscription, promised for some consumers a cheaper a la carte alternative to big cable bundles.

But in a 6-3 decision, the justices ruled that Aereo violated copyright law because it did not pay the same licensing fees that cable television providers do for the right to retransmit the programs of broadcast networks.

"Aereo performs petitioners' works publicly," Justice Stephen Breyer wrote in the court's opinion. Whether Aereo provided "public" performances of broadcasters' programs was central to the case. Aereo argued that it provided "private" performances and that its individually assigned tiny antennas and storage files for viewers put consumers in control of what programs they chose to watch. The company equated its technology to an antenna and cloud storage rental service.

But the court disagreed, saying Aereo looks similar to a cable television provider, which under copyright law must pay licensing fees to broadcast networks to carry their programs to subscribers.

"It does not merely supply equipment that allows others to do so," Breyer wrote.

Aereo CEO Chet Kanojia called the decision a "massive setback for the American consumer" and warned that the high court "sends a chilling message to the technology industry.

He did not discuss the company's plans, but said, "Our work is not done. We will continue to fight for our consumers and fight to create innovative technologies that have a meaningful and positive impact on our world."

"We worked diligently to create a technology that complies with the law, but today's decision clearly states that how the technology works does not matter," he said.

For now, it should be business as usual for Aereo customers, who live in places such as Baltimore, Atlanta and New York. (It is not available in the Tampa Bay area.) But Aereo's future is unclear, given that its entire cost structure will have to change as a result of the Supreme Court ruling.

The decision was a major victory for broadcasting giants, whose stocks soared after the court's decision. Shares of CBS rose 7 percent to $63.75; the Walt Disney Co., which owns ABC, rose nearly 3 percent to $84.32.

Broadcasters waged a two-year battle against Aereo in multiple lower courts as the specter of Aereo — and any copycats of the company's methods and technology — posed a major threat to their business models.

"Today's decision is a victory for consumers," Paul Clement, the attorney representing the broadcasters, said in a statement. "The Court has sent a clear message that it will uphold the letter and spirit of the law just as Congress intended."

The Disney Co. added in a statement, "We're gratified the court upheld important Copyright principles that help ensure that the high-quality creative content consumers expect and demand is protected and incentivized."

The decision did protect cloud Internet services, however, giving relief to storage providers such as DropBox and Google, which justices were careful to keep out of the case.

"We have said that it does not extend to those who act as owners or possessors of the relevant product," such companies that provide the remote storage of content, the court wrote.

The case drew keen interest from high-tech, media and telecommunications companies for its potential to disrupt the entire television business, an intricate system of relationships between programmer and distributors.

Cable companies have groused about increasing licensing fees and could have used Aereo as leverage in negotiations with broadcasters. Fights over licensing fees have resulted in blackouts, with consumers stuck in the middle; these disputes are expected to become a bigger source of friction, with broadcasters charging more each year for programming.

Retransmission fees reached $3.3 billion last year and are expected to grow to $7.6 billion in five years, according to media research firm SNL Kagan.

And consumers, looking for alternatives to the expensive bundle of cable channels, could have seen the combination of Aereo, Hulu and Netflix, for instance, as sufficient services to replace their cable subscriptions.

Aereo provided an opportunity for "more consumer choices, sovereignty, and control over what they want to watch and to whom and how much they want to pay," said Gene Kimmelman, president of public interest group Public Knowledge.

Comments
Stock up for hurricanes, Buckhorn warns, or ‘we may be coming for you in a body bag’

Stock up for hurricanes, Buckhorn warns, or ‘we may be coming for you in a body bag’

TAMPA — Stuff that hurricane kit full of batteries, pen that emergency plan and, for goodness sake, get as many gallons stored in the garage as possible while the skies are blue and clouds are fluffy white. That was the message Tampa Mayor Bob Buckh...
Updated: 6 minutes ago

Test & Head& &&&& &

gnsnhstrgfnsfhnmd
Updated: 9 minutes ago
Woman fatally struck while pushing stroller on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa

Woman fatally struck while pushing stroller on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa

TAMPA— A mother was killed Wednesday when she was struck by a vehicle while pushing a stroller on Bayshore Boulevard, according to the Tampa Police Department.The crash occurred around 11:43 near W Knights Avenue, police said.The woman and child were...
Updated: 10 minutes ago
Rick Scott overrules elections chief, directs Florida to seek cyber-security money

Rick Scott overrules elections chief, directs Florida to seek cyber-security money

FORT LAUDERDALE — Gov. Rick Scott on Wednesday directed the state's chief elections official to seek $19.2 million in federal money to help counties protect against possible cyber-security attacks in the 2018 election.Scott's action came hours ...
Updated: 10 minutes ago
State softball: Land O’Lakes advances to second straight title game

State softball: Land O’Lakes advances to second straight title game

VERO BEACH — Land O'Lakes had just finished a hard-fought 5-0 victory over Clay in the Class 6A state semifinal. Callie Turner threw a no-hitter. Jolene Bodner had a two-run single.The win was big, clinching the Gators' second straight champion...
Updated: 11 minutes ago
USF Sun Dome to increase security for Pasco County high school graduations

USF Sun Dome to increase security for Pasco County high school graduations

Concerns still high over security at high profile school events, the USF Sun Dome plans to increase safety measures for this week's Pasco County high school graduation ceremonies.Family and friends might want to arrive a bit early to be sure to ...
Updated: 14 minutes ago
Waiting for ‘Godot’ to end: Half-okay performances mar an already irritating classic at Hat Trick

Waiting for ‘Godot’ to end: Half-okay performances mar an already irritating classic at Hat Trick

CLEARWATER — Hat Trick Theatre, the resident company of Ruth Eckerd Hall, closes out its season with Samuel Beckett’s Waiting for Godot. I must say it’s a stark choice, mainly because I can’t get two sentences into this without using the word "stark....
Updated: 22 minutes ago
Oil drilling ban in eastern gulf is shot down

Oil drilling ban in eastern gulf is shot down

WASHINGTON – A bipartisan Florida effort to permanently ban oil drilling in the eastern Gulf of Mexico has been blocked from consideration."House Republicans blocked my bipartisan amendment to ban oil drilling off the coast of Florida late...
Updated: 27 minutes ago
State baseball: Carrollwood Day comes up a run short in semifinals

State baseball: Carrollwood Day comes up a run short in semifinals

FORT MYERS — One swing.That's all it took for Carrollwood Day's historic season to come to an end.With two outs and two runners on in the third inning of the Class 3A state semifinal against Tallahassee North Florida Christian, Patriots starter...
Updated: 27 minutes ago
No. 2-seeded USF falls to Wichita State in AAC tourney opener

No. 2-seeded USF falls to Wichita State in AAC tourney opener

Second-seeded USF was greeted Wednesday morning at the American Athletic Conference tournament by a bright sky and bracket poised to burst.Yet on a day the Bulls (32-19-1) could've made real noise in this eight-team event, their bats elicited nary a ...
Updated: 27 minutes ago