Monday, June 25, 2018

Appeals court strikes down California ban on gay marriage

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal appeals court on Tuesday declared California's 2008 voter-approved ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional, concluding the prohibition served no purpose other than to "lessen the status and human dignity of gays and lesbians."

The 2-1 ruling by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals was narrowly written to limit its scope to California's borders and possibly even avoid review by the U.S. Supreme Court, legal experts said. Nonetheless, gay-rights advocates hailed the decision as historic, while supporters of Proposition 8 vowed to appeal.

Instead of expanding the constitutional rights of gays and lesbians, the court based its decision on a 1996 U.S. Supreme Court precedent that said a majority may not take away a minority's rights without legitimate reasons.

"Proposition 8 operates with no apparent purpose but to impose on gays and lesbians, through the public law, a majority's private disapproval of them and their relationships," Judge Stephen Reinhardt wrote for the court.

The ruling won't take effect for about three weeks to give the sponsors of Proposition 8 time to appeal.

Though divided on the constitutional question, the three-judge panel unanimously agreed that ProtectMarriage, the backers of Proposition 8, had the right or legal "standing" to appeal Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker's 2010 ruling against the ballot measure.

The panel also unanimously rejected a challenge by ProtectMarriage that Walker's ruling should be set aside because he failed to disclose he was in a same-sex relationship. Walker, who has since retired, ruled after an unprecedented, two-week trial that examined the meaning of sexual orientation and the history of marriage and gay rights.

Some lawyers and legal scholars said the 9th Circuit might have the final word on Proposition 8 because the ruling was so pointedly limited to California.

Proposition 8 passed as a constitutional amendment six months after the California Supreme Court struck down a state law that limited marriage to a man and a woman, and an estimated 18,000 same-sex couples married during that time.

"That legal background does not exist in most states," said University of Minnesota Law School professor Dale Carpenter, who has followed the case.

Douglas NeJaime, a professor at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles, agreed, noting that Tuesday's decision allows the U.S. Supreme Court to postpone a pronouncement on same-sex marriage until a more sweeping case comes along.

Comments

AP Top News at 2:37 a.m. EDT

AP Top News at 2:37 a.m. EDT
Updated: 1 hour ago
Walk or die: Algeria abandons 13,000 migrants in the Sahara

Walk or die: Algeria abandons 13,000 migrants in the Sahara

Algeria's government has expelled over 13,000 migrants in the Sahara Desert in the past 14 months, giving them little choice but to walk for miles across the border in the blistering sun to Niger or Mali or die trying
Updated: 1 hour ago

Algeria abandons more than 13,000 migrants in the Sahara Desert, in a forced march that often turns deadly, AP finds

Algeria abandons more than 13,000 migrants in the Sahara Desert, in a forced march that often turns deadly, AP finds
Updated: 1 hour ago
Indonesia identifies likely location of ferry in crater lake

Indonesia identifies likely location of ferry in crater lake

Indonesia has identified the suspected location of an overcrowded passenger ferry that sank last week in a deep volcanic crater lake but will need international help to recover the wreckage, official says
Updated: 1 hour ago
Murphy's 2-run single lifts Nationals past Phillies 8-6

Murphy's 2-run single lifts Nationals past Phillies 8-6

Daniel Murphy's two-run single drove in the tying and go-ahead runs in the eighth inning and the Washington Nationals rallied past the Philadelphia Phillies 8-6
Updated: 1 hour ago
Turkey's victorious Erdogan set to assume sweeping powers

Turkey's victorious Erdogan set to assume sweeping powers

Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who has dominated Turkish politics for the past 15 years, is set to extend his rule with sweeping powers after winning landmark presidential and parliamentary elections
Updated: 1 hour ago
Indonesia identifies likely location of ferry in crater lake

Indonesia identifies likely location of ferry in crater lake

Indonesia has identified the suspected location of an overcrowded passenger ferry that sank last week in a deep volcanic crater lake but will need international help to recover the wreckage, official says
Updated: 2 hours ago

Jordan says it won't take in Syrians fleeing new offensive

Jordan warns it can't take in Syrian refugees fleeing President Assad's offensive in southern province of Daraa
Updated: 2 hours ago

Water, mud block rescue attempt for 12 boys inside Thai cave

Officials say multiple attempts to locate 12 boys and their soccer coach missing in a flooded cave in northern Thailand for nearly two days have failed, but that they will keep trying
Updated: 2 hours ago
Asian stocks fall, oil gives up some gains after China move

Asian stocks fall, oil gives up some gains after China move

Asian stock markets have fallen and oil prices gave up some of their gains after Chinese regulators freed up extra money for bank lending amid a trade dispute with Washington
Updated: 2 hours ago