Wednesday, November 22, 2017

Catholic institutions sue over contraceptive rule

RECOMMENDED READING


WASHINGTON — The battle between the Obama administration and the Catholic Church hierarchy intensified as 43 groups — including the archdioceses of Washington and New York and the University of Notre Dame — filed lawsuits Monday challenging a new rule that requires employers or their health insurers to offer birth-control coverage to workers.

The Catholic organizations, which filed the suits in federal courts across the country, argue that the federal mandate infringes on their religious freedom because it violates church teachings.

At issue is a rule in the Obama 2010 health care law requiring contraception coverage, including the morning-after pill, at no cost. Under rules released last August, churches, mosques and other places of worship would be exempt, but not religiously affiliated groups, such as hospitals and universities.

But that did not satisfy some prominent Catholic officials. In response, the administration softened the rule this year so that religiously affiliated employers could shift the requirement for paying for contraceptive coverage onto their insurers.

Although some religious employers, such as the Catholic Health Association, which represents Catholic hospitals, gave the eased rule a good reception, it still drew fire from the nation's Catholic bishops.

What's more, many plaintiffs in the suits argue that because they self-insure — meaning that they don't use insurance companies to assume the risk of paying their employees' health bills — even agreeing to the softened rule violates their religious beliefs. An administration official said the government wants to work with Catholic organizations on rules for self-insured organizations.

The mandate takes effect in August 2013.

"Time is running out, and our precious ministries and fundamental rights hang in the balance, so we have to resort to the courts now," said Cardinal Timothy Dolan, the archbishop of New York. In a prepared statement, he said the lawsuits reflect the dioceses' frustration with the administration and Congress.

Comments
Syria's opposition, divided and varied, to get a new face

Syria's opposition, divided and varied, to get a new face

Syria's notoriously fragmented opposition is gathering in the Saudi capital for a meeting intended to close ranks and come up with a unified vision ahead of a new round of peace talks in Geneva
Updated: 10 minutes ago
The Latest: Zimbabwe's incoming leader returning shortly

The Latest: Zimbabwe's incoming leader returning shortly

The Latest: Zimbabwe's incoming leader takes off from South Africa, returning home shortly
Updated: 10 minutes ago

AP Top News at 7:30 a.m. EST

AP Top News at 7:30 a.m. EST
Updated: 11 minutes ago

Philippines to extradite priest accused of molesting US boys

An official says the Philippine government is preparing to extradite to the United States a recently arrested Filipino Catholic priest who faces charges of sexually molesting two boys in North Dakota churches in the 1990s
Updated: 11 minutes ago
The Latest: Triumphant Hariri declares

The Latest: Triumphant Hariri declares "Lebanon First!"

Lebanon's Prime Minister Saad Hariri stands before thousands of supporters, pledging to stay in Lebanon and declares: "Lebanon First."
Updated: 16 minutes ago

AP witness: Zimbabwe's incoming leader Mnangagwa has departed South Africa for his return

AP witness: Zimbabwe's incoming leader Mnangagwa has departed South Africa for his return
Updated: 16 minutes ago
The Latest: Triumphant Hariri declares

The Latest: Triumphant Hariri declares "Lebanon First!"

Lebanon's Prime Minister Saad Hariri stands before thousands of supporters, pledging to stay in Lebanon and declares: "Lebanon First."
Updated: 16 minutes ago
UK Treasury chief between rock and hard place on budget

UK Treasury chief between rock and hard place on budget

Britain's Treasury chief under pressure to ease austerity in budget, but has little room for spending increases as Brexit shock looms
Updated: 22 minutes ago

Egypt detains 29 on charges they spied for Turkey

Egypt detains 29 suspected Brotherhood member for allegedly spying for Turkey, creating anti-government media platforms
Updated: 24 minutes ago
N. Korea criticizes US over designation as terror sponsor

N. Korea criticizes US over designation as terror sponsor

North Korea has called U.S. President Donald Trump's decision to relist the country as a state sponsor of terrorism a "serious provocation" that justifies its development of nuclear weapons
Updated: 25 minutes ago