Saturday, December 16, 2017

Choice of running mate matters little in history

The political world is consumed at the moment with trying to divine the identity of Mitt Romney's vice presidential pick. Travel schedules are pored over, public statements are parsed.

Given that level of attention, you would think that the pick is of the utmost importance in the presidential race, that a look back at past picks reveals make or break moments centered on the identity of the presidential nominee's ticketmate.

But the simple reality is that the vice presidential pick, viewed through the lens of recent history, has almost no broad influence on the fate of the ticket and, to the extent the VP choice has mattered, it has been in a negative way.

"VP picks can provide a temporary burst of excitement to a ticket, but pretty soon things settle down and the race is once again about the man at the top," said Ari Fleischer, a former Bush administration official. "With communications reaching everywhere for the last few decades, the race is about the presidency, not the vice presidency."

The most common argument for why the vice presidential pick matters is geography. But, there's scant evidence in recent VP picking that geography really matters.

The last vice presidential pick who could make a real argument that he helped the presidential nominee win a swing state or one that leaned against his party was Al Gore in 1992. After the Democratic presidential nominee had lost the Volunteer State by 16 points in 1984 and 1988, Bill Clinton and Gore carried it, thanks in part to the popularity of the then Tennessee senator.

Prior to Gore, the last Democratic VP choice who can lay a solid claim to delivering a region for the presidential nominee is Lyndon Johnson for John Kennedy way back in 1960. Without Johnson, Kennedy's ability, as a blue-blooded Northeasterner, to play in the South would have been far more complicated. With Johnson, Kennedy carried Texas, Louisiana, Arkansas, Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina and North Carolina.

On the Republican side, Richard Nixon's choice of Maryland Gov. Spiro Agnew as VP in 1968 clearly played a role in his carrying the Old Line State. Of course, Agnew wasn't a positive for Nixon once the pair got into office.

A look at the VP picks of the last decade suggests the presidential nominees, and their senior staffs, grasp the declining importance of geography.

In 2000, George W. Bush went with Dick Cheney of Wyoming (not a swing state) while Al Gore chose Joe Lieberman of Connecticut (also not a swing state).

Four years later, Massachusetts Sen. John Kerry chose then North Carolina Sen. John Edwards and promptly lost the Tar Heel State by 12 points. (In Kerry's defense, he didn't pick Edwards in hopes of carrying North Carolina.)

In 2008, President Barack Obama picked Joe Biden (of strongly Democratic Delaware) while Arizona Sen. John McCain went with Sarah Palin (of strongly Republican Alaska).

The other major argument from the "VP picks matter" camp is that the vice presidential selection is the only major decision a presidential nominee makes in the course of the campaign that provides a window into how he would govern.

The line of reasoning goes like this: Unlike most policy proposals made during a race, which tend to be abandoned or drastically overhauled as campaigning turns to governing, the VP will serve in a critical capacity if the ticket is elected. So, who the nominee picks for such an important role does matter. And how they go about making that selection does too.

True enough. But, that theory assumes that voters are motivated to choose which candidate they would like to be president based on who the guy next to the guy is. And, they aren't.

Here's our analogy: Mrs. Fix is a field hockey coach. When recruits come to visit the program, they may get a tour from an assistant or someone else in the athletic department. But, when they get to the final decision about where to go to school, it's the head coach that is the biggest factor in their choice.

All of the above is not to say the media won't continue to cover the heck out of the Romney veepstakes. Because we will. (I mean, let's just be honest about it.)

Rather, it's simply to remind people that no matter whom Romney ultimately picks, recent history suggests it won't be a game-changing sort of event in the November election. The choice before voters is between President Barack Obama and Mitt Romney.

Comments
Kitija Laksa’s 11 consecutive treys an NCAA record

Kitija Laksa’s 11 consecutive treys an NCAA record

Turns out, USF junior Kitija Laksa wasn't merely unconscious from behind the 3-point line Friday night, she was unprecedented.Laksa's 11 consecutive 3-pointers in the Bulls' 108-48 home romp of Southern University broke the NCAA's single-game record ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
College Football Bowls: Tampa Bay Times staff picks for Week 1

College Football Bowls: Tampa Bay Times staff picks for Week 1

College football bowl season gets underway Saturday with six games. Here's the Tampa Bay Times college football coverage team's picks for those and five other games the first week of bowl season. GameMartin Fennelly @mjfennellyTraci Johnson @TBH...
Updated: 1 hour ago

AP Top News at 11:58 a.m. EST

AP Top News at 11:58 a.m. EST
Updated: 10 minutes ago
After Alabama, abortion may be backseat issue in 2018 races

After Alabama, abortion may be backseat issue in 2018 races

Both Democratic and Republican operatives say abortion may take a backseat to other issues in 2018 now that conservative Alabama has elected a Democrat who supports abortion rights
Updated: 11 minutes ago
New Austrian government pledges pro-EU approach, more police

New Austrian government pledges pro-EU approach, more police

The new Austrian government led by a conservative and a nationalist party is pledging to tighten the country's asylum and immigration regulations while maintaining a firm commitment to the European Union
Updated: 12 minutes ago
Bayern stretches Bundesliga lead, Cologne grabs 1st win

Bayern stretches Bundesliga lead, Cologne grabs 1st win

Bayern Munich goalkeeper Sven Ulreich saved a penalty in injury time as the Bundesliga leader stretched its lead to 11 points with a 1-0 win at Stuttgart
Updated: 14 minutes ago
The one that got away: Not the fish, but the $2.8M prize

The one that got away: Not the fish, but the $2.8M prize

For the last two years, the most dramatic moments of the White Marlin Open have been on dry land _ not off the coast of Ocean City, Maryland
Updated: 21 minutes ago
California's wildfire now ranks as state's third-largest

California's wildfire now ranks as state's third-largest

The third-largest wildfire in California history continues to grow and threaten thousands of homes despite armies of fire crews and fleets of bulldozers and aircraft
Updated: 23 minutes ago
South Africa ruling party's fight for its future kicks off

South Africa ruling party's fight for its future kicks off

South Africa ruling party's fight for its future kicks off in the face of possible split
Updated: 24 minutes ago
Ex-wife of Lorenzen Wright charged with murder in 2010 death

Ex-wife of Lorenzen Wright charged with murder in 2010 death

Authorities say the ex-wife of former NBA player Lorenzen Wright has been charged with first-degree murder in his death more than seven years ago
Updated: 28 minutes ago