Thursday, January 18, 2018

Florida justices decide rear-end collision cases

TALLAHASSEE — The second driver is not automatically solely at fault in rear-end collisions, the Florida Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday as it resolved a pair of conflicting lower court decisions.

The justices unanimously agreed that juries should be allowed to compare the negligence of each driver in a lawsuit regardless of who the plaintiff is and apportion blame accordingly.

They upheld one appellate court ruling that came to the same conclusion in a Seminole County case and quashed another from Palm Beach County.

The 4th District Court of Appeal in West Palm Beach had upheld a trial judge's decision that Maria Cevallos, the rear driver, was solely at fault.

The high court's reversal of that decision will let Cevallos seek at least partial damages from the middle driver in a three-car rear end crash, Keri Ann Rideout. The defendant allegedly was on her cellphone and suddenly slammed on the brakes before also rear-ending the car in front of her. Cevallos was four car lengths behind Rideout and had slowed her vehicle approaching a hill crest but still wasn't able to stop in time, courtroom evidence indicated.

"The facts introduced into evidence at trial provided sufficient basis for the jury to conclude that the defendant failed to use ordinary care in operating her vehicle, and that this failure was at least one of the proximate causes of the collision," Justice Jorge Labarga wrote for the court.

Florida's comparative negligence law allows juries to determine how much each party in a lawsuit is at fault. For instance, if a jury finds a plaintiff is 40 percent at fault, a judgment against the defendant would be reduced by that amount.

The 4th District's now-quashed ruling said comparative negligence didn't apply to rear-end collision cases.

The Supreme Court, in an opinion also written by Labarga, upheld the Daytona Beach-based 5th District Court of Appeal's reversal of a Seminole County trial judge's summary judgment in favor of defendant Warren Birge that was similar to the 4th District's ruling.

Crystal Charron, an injured motorcycle passenger, now will be able to seek damages from Birge. Charron contends that Birge was at least partially at fault for the 2007 crash in Sanford that injured her.

The motorcycle flipped over when its driver, William Smith, unsuccessfully attempted to avoid a collision with the rear of Birge's car. Charron alleged Birge had suddenly slammed on his brakes for no apparent reason. Witness accounts differ, but the justices said a jury should decide how much Birge was to blame if at all. Smith reached a separate settlement with Birge and is not a party to Charron's case.

Comments
Deputy US marshal killed while serving Pennsylvania warrant

Deputy US marshal killed while serving Pennsylvania warrant

Authorities say a deputy U.S. marshal was shot and killed while serving a warrant in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Updated: 9 minutes ago
Prosecutor: Parents starved kids until they stopped growing

Prosecutor: Parents starved kids until they stopped growing

Prosecutors say a California couple accused of torturing a dozen of their children for years starved them to the point that their growth was stunted
Updated: 13 minutes ago

‘How dare you’: Gymnasts confront Michigan sports doctor

LANSING, Mich. — U.S. Olympian McKayla Maroney said being sexually assaulted by a Michigan sports doctor who molested her and other gymnasts scarred her mind in ways that may never heal. Dr. Larry Nassar won’t be sentenced until next week to accommod...
Updated: 13 minutes ago
'Tourniquet Killer' executed in Texas for 1992 strangling

'Tourniquet Killer' executed in Texas for 1992 strangling

A man who became known as Houston's "Tourniquet Killer" because of his signature murder technique has become the nation's first prisoner executed in 2018.
Updated: 19 minutes ago
Florida Senate changes policy, but not rules, after sexual harassment saga

Florida Senate changes policy, but not rules, after sexual harassment saga

The Florida Senate, where incidences of a hostile work environment have spawned formal and informal complaints of sexual harassment and led to the resignation of a powerful state senator last month, on Thursday decided it was time to crack down.The S...
Updated: 20 minutes ago
WTA signs lucrative 10-year deal to move finals to China

WTA signs lucrative 10-year deal to move finals to China

The WTA has signed a 10-year deal to move its season-ending WTA Finals to Shenzhen, China, in 2019. The prize money will double from $7 million to $14 million.
Updated: 22 minutes ago
WTA signs lucrative 10-year deal to move finals to China

WTA signs lucrative 10-year deal to move finals to China

The WTA has signed a 10-year deal to move its season-ending WTA Finals to Shenzhen, China, in 2019. The prize money will double from $7 million to $14 million.
Updated: 22 minutes ago

Delta jetliner makes emergency safe return to Los Angeles

A Delta Air Lines flight has safely returned to Los Angeles International Airport after it developed a hydraulic problem shortly after taking off for Detroit
Updated: 27 minutes ago
Joint Olympic flag deal angers conservatives in South Korea

Joint Olympic flag deal angers conservatives in South Korea

Athletes from both Koreas marching behind one flag was an emotional moment at 2000 Olympics, but the plan to do so again isn't generating much enthusiasm among South Koreans for Games in their own country
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Latest: Prosecutors identify man who killed US marshal

The Latest: Prosecutors identify man who killed US marshal

Prosecutors have identified a 31-year-old Philadelphia man as the shooter who killed a U.S. marshal before being shot to death by police
Updated: 1 hour ago