Make us your home page

Mere feet apart on the field; miles apart in life

A Derek Jeter news conference is always better than an A-Rod one.


A Derek Jeter news conference is always better than an A-Rod one.

In the middle of a perfect news conference, the last perfect Yankee of them all suddenly stopped what he was saying. A far more noble purpose than talk of retirement had popped into his mind.

And now Derek Jeter was telling his teammates they could leave, that they could get back to work instead of paying attention to whatever small things he had to say at his news conference.

Go field a ground ball. Go hit a thrown one. Whatever you do, don't create a fuss.

It was, of course, the perfect Jeter moment, one of those moments where a member of baseball's royalty played the part of a serf.

And you could not help but wonder:

How would Alex Rodriguez have handled it?

Would he have autographed a few photos for the boys? Would he have lied? Would he have tripped? How, exactly, would the Banished One have conducted the same news conference that Jeter did on Wednesday?

It is odd. The two men have spent most of a decade a few feet from each other, and yet, their legacies are polar opposites.

Yes, they have both compiled amazing numbers. Yes, they have both made untold millions of dollars. Yes, they have dated a lot of beautiful women. Yes, they both have unchallenged celebrity.

And yet, Jeter is the admired one. A-Rod is the reviled.

As Jeter spoke Wednesday, it was impossible not to compare the two once again. Why would one man be so universally admired while the other, playing on the same team in the same city, would be so despised? Why would one player represent so much that is good, while the other represents all that is bad?

It's easy.

It's called "credibility.''

There is substance to Jeter. There is character. When Jeter talks, and when Jeter plays, you can believe in what you see, in what you sense. No, he is not the greatest player in the history of baseball. No, he is not the greatest Yankee, not as long as Babe Ruth played there. The website quotes sabermetrician Jay Jaffe as listing Jeter as only the 12th-ranked shortstop in baseball history.

And, yet, Jeter has turned that into a career as admired as any player in the history of the game. He has never had a major scandal, like Rodriguez. He has never been accused of dogging it on the basepaths, like Robinson Cano. He has never been accused of beating his own chest, like Reggie Jackson.

Jeter showed up. He played hard. He was a tough out, especially in the seventh inning or later. He conducted himself like a Boy Scout. Forever, fans will remember his regal nature.

A-Rod? He was fake money. He was fool's gold. He cheated. He lied. He backed down. Who knows which of his numbers to believe anymore? Except, of course, those of his salary.

You wonder if Rodriguez ever watches Jeter at work and thinks that it could have been him. It could have, you know. If he had stayed clean, if he had said the right thing, if he were not quite so clumsy at all the wrong moments.

Jeter is the great shining light of baseball, the reminder of how every player should approach his job. You didn't have to like the Yankees to appreciate Jeter. He is universal.

It's odd. Every now and then, one of the stat guys who follow baseball will attempt to inject a bit of reality into the Jeter conversations. You know, the Emperor doesn't wear a glove. They'll talk about Jeter's lack of range, and that he isn't all that much defensively. They'll mention that he never won a league MVP (He was in the top three three times).

But here's the thing: No one wants to hear any of it. People want to admire Jeter, which may be the most admirable thing about him. They yearn to think of Jeter as a winner, as a leader, as an elegant champion.

And all of that is great, too. Goodness knows, there isn't enough to admire in sports. You might as well admire Jeter. He's given you more reason than most.

There are 162 more chances to see him play. Try to appreciate him while you can.

Mere feet apart on the field; miles apart in life 02/19/14 [Last modified: Wednesday, February 19, 2014 8:27pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours