Sunday, January 21, 2018
tbt*

NFL cheerleaders kick up a workers' revolt

In 2014, the cheerleaders revolted.

This January, rookie NFL cheerleader Lacy T. kicked things off when she filed a class-action lawsuit against the Oakland Raiders, alleging the team fails to pay its Raiderettes minimum wage, withholds their pay until the end of the season, imposes illegal fines for minor infractions (like gaining 5 pounds) and forces cheerleaders to pay their own business expenses (everything from false eyelashes to monthly salon visits). Within a month, Cincinnati Bengals cheerleader Alexa Brenneman had filed a similar suit against her team, claiming the Ben-Gals are paid just $2.85 an hour for their work on the sidelines.

And this week, five former Buffalo Bills cheerleaders filed suit against their own team, alleging the Buffalo Jills were required to perform unpaid work for the team for about 20 hours a week. Unpaid activities included: submitting to a weekly "Jiggle Test"; parading around casinos in bikinis; and offering themselves up as prizes at a golf tournament. The Buffalo Jills cheerleaders take home just $105 to $1,800 for an entire season.

Why are NFL cheerleaders putting down their pom-poms all of a sudden? Cheating cheerleaders out of a living wage is an American tradition almost as old as football itself. When I reported on the long hours and low pay of the Washington, D.C., team's cheerleaders in 2011, nobody seemed too upset that they made just $75 a game while working for a team that brings in $76 million a year — especially not the squad members themselves, who told me they appreciated the opportunity to cheer, regardless of the monetary benefits.

First, it's worth examining why NFL teams ever thought it was okay to treat cheerleaders this way. When cheerleaders first took to the field in the early days of the NFL, it was a volunteer position staffed by local high school and college squads, and football players and coaches weren't making bank, either. But after television turned football into big business, cheerleading got serious: In the 1970s, the Dallas Cowboys led the league by transforming NFL cheerleading from an extracurricular activity into professional sideline entertainment, and other teams followed with their own glam squads. And yet, cheerleading wages remained scandalously low. That's partly because labor organization in the NFL focused on the rights of the players, and since they're the main product of a most dangerous game, that makes sense. (The Players Association does not represent cheerleaders.) It's also because the job description of the modern cheerleader is a hyper-glamorized version of what American women were traditionally expected to do for free, before they entered the workforce en masse: namely, look pretty and support their men.

NFL teams stepped easily into the creepy patriarch role. Today, they enforce expectations for the way their cheerleaders look (according to the suit, the Jills' guidebook mandates everything from nail-polish color to how they clean their vaginas) while rewarding them, not with money, but with the supposed prestige of appearing as one of their city's most desirable women. NFL teams like the Raiders extend the patriarch metaphor by encouraging cheerleaders to see the team as a "family" and implying that they'll break the "sisterhood bond" if they step out of line. Cheerleaders are constantly reminded they are letting down their teammates when they are benched and fined for weight gain, and, by the way, hundreds of women would be happy to take their spot for free. The old stereotype of cheerleaders as bimbos has also worked in the NFL's favor. NFL cheerleading is such an obviously raw deal, some might assume that women must be stupid to agree to it. (Tell that to Dr. Monica Williams, who cheered for the Tennessee Titans while fulfilling a research fellowship at Vanderbilt.)

So what's changed?

"It's a reflection of the Occupy Movement," Frank Dolce, a lawyer for the five Buffalo Jills, posited. "There's an increasing public realization of the tremendous unfairness of America's present economic situation, and as we grow more and more unequal as a society, those tensions are becoming more pronounced. Professional cheerleading is symbolic of the abuse of workers everywhere by the powerful, greedy people who control the purse strings." And the plight of the cheerleaders — who are forced to look so sunny and glamorous while making so little — presents a particularly ironic hook for telling this story. It helps that the cheerleader lawsuits are hitting at a time of scrutiny of the NFL overall.

There's another reason it's taken so long for the cheerleaders to speak up: feminism. Professional cheerleaders have always presented a dilemma for the traditional feminist movement. On the one hand, feminism is committed to fighting for fair pay for women in all areas where they are discriminated against because of their gender. On the other hand, this particular kind of labor — one where women, not men, are enlisted to jiggle their assets — suggests another kind of gendered exploitation, and one that's hard for some feminists to rush to defend. Lately, it seems the feminist movement has caught up to the cause; it's no longer particularly controversial to stand up for the legal rights of the women who perform work that nevertheless fails to reflect the ideal, gender-equitable society. Earlier this year, more than 100,000 people signed a Change.org petition urging the NFL to give cheerleaders a raise. (Still, one former Raiderettes cheerleader — who opposes the class-action suit because she fears it will compel teams to disband their cheerleading squads instead of paying up — told me that she thinks these lawsuits are a feminist conspiracy to attempt to end cheerleading for good.)

Ultimately, though, the culture of silence around NFL cheerleading was broken by the courage of one woman — 28-year-old Raiderette Lacy T. — who took personal risks to stand up for all of the workers in her field. "I cheered for the love of dance, not for money," says Sarah G., another former cheerleader for the Raiderettes. But until she read Lacy's lawsuit, "I just had absolutely no idea it was illegal."

Amanda Hess blogs for Slate's DoubleX blog on sex, science and health.

Comments
Bar review: Florida spirits and brews at the newest Local Draught House in Tampa

Bar review: Florida spirits and brews at the newest Local Draught House in Tampa

I don’t consider myself "old" — though I have gotten into a bad habit of informing door people insistent on checking my ID that I’m halfway to 70. But I’m frequently made aware of how far removed my lifestyle is from that of my 20s.So when I walked i...
Published: 01/18/18
Local craft beer of the week: Electric Wizard IPA from 7venth Sun Brewery

Local craft beer of the week: Electric Wizard IPA from 7venth Sun Brewery

The past six months have been kind to Dunedin’s 7venth Sun Brewery. In August, the brewery’s long-awaited Tampa expansion finally happened, with its much larger Seminole Heights facility and tasting room opening in a town eager to try its range of ul...
Published: 01/18/18
Have pro wrestling mania? Central Florida is in the ring

Have pro wrestling mania? Central Florida is in the ring

KISSIMMEE — A masked wrestler named Carrion stands atop the ring, setting up for a devastating shooting-star press onto his rival, Blanco Loco, lying motionless on the mat. Nearby, a family cheers between bites of dessert. It’s pro wrest...
Published: 01/11/18
Updated: 01/12/18
Local craft beer of the week:  Bean Porter, Pinellas Ale Works

Local craft beer of the week: Bean Porter, Pinellas Ale Works

When St. Petersburg’s Pinellas Ale Works held its grand opening in May 2016, it featured a baltic porter treated with vanilla and coffee that proved to be a crowd favorite. The response was so positive that the brewery made another batch of Bean Port...
Published: 01/11/18
Florida’s wild monkeys carry herpes virus, a concern to humans

Florida’s wild monkeys carry herpes virus, a concern to humans

Wildlife managers in Florida say they want to remove roaming monkeys from the state in light of a new study published Wednesday that finds some of the animals are excreting a virus that can be dangerous to humans. Scientists studying a growing popula...
Published: 01/10/18
Local craft beer of the week: So, it’s barleywine you like? Get the Obscure at Green Bench

Local craft beer of the week: So, it’s barleywine you like? Get the Obscure at Green Bench

Perhaps the most famous name in barleywine belongs to an English poet and novelist: Thomas Hardy. The beer named after him was originally brewed by the Eldridge Pope brewery in the late ’60s in Dorchester, England, to commemorate the 40th anniversary...
Updated one month ago
Bar review: So much to pour at pay-by-the-ounce Pour Taproom

Bar review: So much to pour at pay-by-the-ounce Pour Taproom

As a perpetual sampler, I’m accustomed to paying a premium for variety. It’s the rare beer bar that serves 16-ounce flights without at least a 133 percent markup. That’s fine with me, if it means that I don’t have to choose ju...
Updated one month ago
Local craft beer of the week: Trois IPA, Escape Brewing in Trinity

Local craft beer of the week: Trois IPA, Escape Brewing in Trinity

A few years ago, a tiny hiccup occurred in the brewing world. The trois strain of brettanomyces (a type of "wild" yeast) was revealed to actually be a strain of saccharomyces — standard brewer’s yeast.The confusion came from trois’ unusual fermentati...
Updated one month ago