Sunday, January 21, 2018

Report says Keystone pipeline likely would not worsen climate change

WASHINGTON — The State Department concluded in its final environmental assessment issued Friday that the proposed Keystone XL pipeline would be unlikely to alter global greenhouse gas emissions, but officials cautioned that they were still weighing whether or not the project would meet the test of President Barack Obama's broader climate strategy.

Though the report acknowledged that tapping the Canadian oil sands for the pipeline would produce more greenhouse gases, the assessment also said that blocking the project would not prevent development of those resources.

The report "is not a decision document," said Kerri-Ann Jones, assistant secretary of state for oceans and international environmental and scientific affairs. "This document is only one factor that will be coming into the review process for this permit" sought by TransCanada, an energy giant based in Calgary, Alberta.

The $5.4 billion pipeline, which would transport heavy crude from Canadian oil sands in Alberta into the heart of the U.S. pipeline network, has become the focus of intense controversy. Foes say it will contribute to climate change; supporters say it will secure U.S. oil supplies from a friendly neighbor and create U.S. construction jobs.

The release of the long-awaited Final Environmental Impact Statement is certain to trigger an avalanche of lobbying aimed at Secretary of State John Kerry, who has made climate change a central focus of his career and will now begin preparing a decision.

Obama said in June that he would sign off on the proposal only if it "does not significantly exacerbate the climate problem."

The decision remains politically fraught for Democrats. Environmental activists fiercely oppose it, arguing the pipeline could leak, would accelerate development of the greenhouse gas-intensive oil sands in Alberta and would increase America's dependence on fossil fuels.

Wendy Abrams, founder of the Chicago-based nonprofit group Cool Globes and a major Democratic campaign contributor, said she felt a "gut-wrenching pain for my kids" when she read the report. She said it made her question her past support for Obama and Kerry. "If they can't get it done, what am I hoping for?"

The State Department's report includes 11 volumes of analysis on how the proposed pipeline would affect heavy-crude extraction in Canada's oil sands and reaches the same conclusion as its draft report did in March: No single infrastructure project will alter the course of oil development in Alberta.

The report said that "the proposed Project is unlikely to significantly affect the rate of extraction in oil sands areas (based on expected oil prices, oil-sands supply costs, transport costs, and supply-demand scenarios)."

Last week, TransCanada began shipping oil through the southern leg of the Keystone pipeline, which runs from Cushing, Okla., to Port Arthur, Texas. But the company is still waiting for a State Department permit for the 1,179-mile northern leg that would carry heavy crude from Canada into Montana and run to the town of Steele City, Neb.

"We're very pleased with the release and about being able to move to this next stage of the process," said Russ Girling, chief executive of TransCanada.

He said it would take about two years to construct the northern leg, but he cautioned that summer is best for construction and that a long permit process could further delay the project.

Jones, the State Department official, said that the report does not answer the question of how this pipeline decision fits into the "broader national and international efforts to address climate change, or other questions of foreign policy or energy security."

Oil industry officials welcomed the fact that the department had affirmed the idea that the pipeline decision did not have a major climate impact.

"Time and time again, State reaches the same conclusion despite the unprecedented and thorough environmental review," said Cindy Schild, the American Petroleum Institute's senior manager for oil sands policy. She said that "it is hard to figure out how they could conclude that it is not in the national interest."

The EPA has questioned whether the State Department has given sufficient weight to the project's negative environmental impact. The final environmental impact statement notes that bitumen, the substance that is extracted in Canada and diluted in order to be transported to U.S. refineries, is more difficult to clean up than lighter crude if it spills.

Comments

Appeals court to hear arguments on DC sniper's sentence

A federal appeals court is set to hear arguments this week in a case focusing on the life sentences given to D.C. sniper Lee Boyd Malvo
Updated: 5 minutes ago

Britcher wins luge sprint, Geisenberger secures overall WCup

Summer Britcher dominated Sunday's sprint to make it two luge World Cup wins in as many days, while Natalie Geisenberger's third place was enough for her sixth straight overall victory
Updated: 12 minutes ago
Turkish troops enter Kurdish enclave in northern Syria

Turkish troops enter Kurdish enclave in northern Syria

Turkish troops and Syrian opposition forces have attacked a Kurdish enclave in northern Syria in their bid to drive a U.S.-allied Kurdish militia from the region
Updated: 15 minutes ago
Turkish troops enter Kurdish enclave in northern Syria

Turkish troops enter Kurdish enclave in northern Syria

Turkish troops and Syrian opposition forces have attacked a Kurdish enclave in northern Syria in their bid to drive a U.S.-allied Kurdish militia from the region
Updated: 15 minutes ago
Pence accuses Congress of playing politics with military pay

Pence accuses Congress of playing politics with military pay

U.S. Vice President Mike Pence is blasting Congress for playing politics with military pay, telling U.S. soldiers stationed in the Middle East that the Trump administration would "demand that they reopen the government."
Updated: 17 minutes ago
Pence accuses Congress of playing politics with military pay

Pence accuses Congress of playing politics with military pay

U.S. Vice President Mike Pence is blasting Congress for playing politics with military pay, telling U.S. soldiers stationed in the Middle East that the Trump administration would "demand that they reopen the government."
Updated: 17 minutes ago

South Carolina suspect found hiding behind fake wall in home

Police investigating a murder attempt were told their suspect wasn't in a house in South Carolina; a closer look found him hiding behind a false wall behind a toilet.
Updated: 18 minutes ago
US hockey GM dies unexpectedly at Colorado Springs home

US hockey GM dies unexpectedly at Colorado Springs home

Jim Johannson, the general manager of the U.S. Olympic men's hockey team, dies unexpectedly
Updated: 20 minutes ago
Slimane named new Celine designer as Paris menswear wraps up

Slimane named new Celine designer as Paris menswear wraps up

Lanvin and Paul Smith caped a masculine and utilitarian menswear season in Paris as design veteran Hedi Slimane was named the new creative chief at Celine
Updated: 21 minutes ago
Brash ex-Milwaukee sheriff David Clarke faces civil trial

Brash ex-Milwaukee sheriff David Clarke faces civil trial

Former Milwaukee Sheriff David Clarke's run-in with a 25-year-old man who shook his head at him while boarding a flight last year is headed to trial in federal court
Updated: 21 minutes ago