Thursday, April 19, 2018

Scalia has become Mr. Anti-Search

Justice Antonin Scalia, the Supreme Court's new champion of the Fourth Amendment, is likely to play a crucial role today when the court hears this year's most important search case: whether the police may routinely examine the digital contents of a cellphone confiscated during an arrest.

Under current law, officers may search a person under arrest, checking pockets and looking through a wallet or purse. The question is whether a smartphone carried by the person is also fair game.

"It's all of your personal information," said Norman Reimer, executive director of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, which opposes giving police such powers. "It's an incredible exposure of your privacy."

In the past, defense lawyers did not look first to the conservative Scalia as an ally. But in recent years, he has insisted on forbidding the kinds of "unreasonable searches" that he says would have troubled the framers of the Constitution.

Last week, he slammed the high court's majority for serving up a "freedom-destroying cocktail" in an opinion that gave police a free hand to stop cars on the highway based solely on an anonymous tip. Last year, he fired off a fierce dissent when the court ruled that police may routinely take DNA swabs from people who are arrested.

He wrote the decision that accompanied a 5-4 ruling last year banning police from using drug dogs to sniff at the front of a house and a 2012 ruling barring police from attaching a GPS tracking device to a car.

With an eye toward Scalia, lawyers in the cellphone case have carefully quoted the Fourth Amendment, which protects the "right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects." In the 21st century, they say, many people store their "papers and effects" on a mobile device.

"Private information used to be kept at home on paper, including your photos," said Elizabeth Wydra, counsel for the Constitutional Accountability Center. "Now they're in your pocket on a phone. With a smartphone, you can literally look into a person's home."

She noted that her phone features an app that allows her to monitor video of her home so she can keep an eye on her dogs.

Comments
Rick Scott says cutting a Medicaid program will save Florida $98 million –about $400 million less than what experts say it will cost applicants

Rick Scott says cutting a Medicaid program will save Florida $98 million –about $400 million less than what experts say it will cost applicants

When it comes to health-care math, sometimes the numbers don't add up for Florida Gov. Rick Scott.As Scott's administration this week submits a request to the federal government to trim the amount of time people have to apply for Medicaid coverage, t...
Updated: 10 minutes ago
Trump in Key West today, and Curbelo will join him

Trump in Key West today, and Curbelo will join him

Rep. Carlos Curbelo is headed to Key West with President Donald Trump today, but don't expect the duo to applaud the sunset at Mallory Square.The president will visit Naval Air Station Key West for a few hours to receive a briefing from the Joint Int...
Updated: 11 minutes ago
Persall: Upon retirement, a look back at a star-quality career

Persall: Upon retirement, a look back at a star-quality career

Do you see what I did there? The comma and extra "E" in my byline? One last pun, just for fun. It’s the end, fin in French, and something unfortunately ruder in Swedish. Time to retire, nearly 25 years to the day after starting work as the T...
Updated: 22 minutes ago
Former chief Jane Castor makes it official: She’s in the race for Tampa mayor

Former chief Jane Castor makes it official: She’s in the race for Tampa mayor

For months, Tampa political aficionados have speculated: Will she or won't she?Does Jane Castor, the city's first woman police chief, and presumed heavyweight mayoral candidate, really want the job? Not to mention the stress of a high-profile campaig...
Updated: 1 hour ago
2018 NFL draft countdown: Bucs GM Jason Licht speaks

2018 NFL draft countdown: Bucs GM Jason Licht speaks

We're a week away from the NFL draft in Dallas …Bucs general manager Jason Licht will speak to the media at 11:30 a.m. today at One Buc Place in Tampa. He'll take questions for about 20 minutes and use a lot of words to say nothing.That's the g...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Eva Longoria’s American ‘Gran Hotel’ adaptation in Miami: What we know so far

Eva Longoria’s American ‘Gran Hotel’ adaptation in Miami: What we know so far

I forever sing the praises of Gran Hotel, the gasp-inducing Spanish drama that is hands-down the most addicting show I have ever binged. It's been remade in Italy, Mexico (as El hotel de los secretos) and Egypt (as Grand Hotel but on Netflix as Secre...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Lightning hold off Devils and David Puddy

Lightning hold off Devils and David Puddy

NEWARK, N.J. – The Devils pulled out all the stops for Wednesday's Game 4 of their Stanley Cup quarter final series with the Lightning by inviting David Puddy at the Prudential Center.For those who do not know who he is, Puddy was Elaine's boyf...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Men arrested at Starbucks say they feared for their lives

Men arrested at Starbucks say they feared for their lives

PHILADELPHIA — Rashon Nelson initially brushed it off when the Starbucks manager told him he couldn’t use the restroom because he wasn’t a paying customer. He thought nothing of it when he and his business partner, Donte Robinson, were approached at ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Global stocks take a breather as oil price rally continues

Global stocks take a breather as oil price rally continues

Global stock markets traded in fairly narrow ranges Thursday following a solid rebound based on waning fears about a trade war
Updated: 1 hour ago

Lawsuit challenges ban of handguns in home day cares

Several gun rights groups have joined a central Illinois couple in a federal lawsuit challenging a ban on handguns in home day cares
Updated: 1 hour ago