Tuesday, November 21, 2017

Supreme Court hears cases on drug-sniffing dogs

RECOMMENDED READING


WASHINGTON — Supreme Court justices seemed ready Wednesday to adjust the legal leash on drug-sniffing dogs, in two high-profile cases out of Florida.

Justices voiced skepticism about a Florida Supreme Court ruling that imposed strict criteria for determining when a dog is qualified to help make a drug bust. At the same time, court conservatives joined liberals in suggesting that a police canine sniffing at the front door of a suspected drug house may be a search that triggers constitutional protections.

"It seems to me crucial that this officer went onto the portion of the house as to which there is privacy, and used a means of discerning what was in that house that should not have been available," Justice Antonin Scalia said at one point.

The two cases heard separately Wednesday will help shape law enforcement agencies' growing canine dependency. Twenty-four states have sided with Florida law enforcement officials, noting in a legal brief that "drug-detecting canines are one of the essential weapons in the states' arsenal to combat this illegal traffic."

A majority of the justices who spoke Wednesday sounded protective of the privacy inherent in a home.

An assertion by attorney Gregory C. Garre, who's representing Florida in both cases, that people can't expect privacy "when it comes to contraband" was flatly rejected by Justice Anthony Kennedy, who's a frequent swing vote on close decisions. Kennedy and Scalia, both Republican appointees, joined Justice Sonia Sotomayor and several other Democratic appointees in repeatedly challenging Florida's case.

The second case heard Wednesday involved Aldo, a German shepherd who was on patrol June 24, 2006, with his human partner from the Liberty County Sheriff's Office in Florida's Panhandle. The deputy pulled over a pickup with an expired tag. Aldo alerted, and the deputy found 200 pseudoephedrine pills, which can be used to make methamphetamine.

A divided Florida Supreme Court subsequently ruled that Aldo's alert was insufficient to show probable cause for a follow-up search, because of questions about the dog's reliability. The state court spelled out a series of records that law enforcement agencies must be prepared to provide to demonstrate a drug-sniffing dog's reliability. State officials call this burdensome, and a number of justices seemed to agree.

"Why is that the right list?" Justice Stephen Breyer asked. "I mean, what in the Constitution requires that list?"

Decisions in the two cases are expected by the end of the court's term next June.

Comments

AP Top News at 7:49 a.m. EST

AP Top News at 7:49 a.m. EST
Updated: 4 minutes ago
Trump administration announces sanctions against North Korea

Trump administration announces sanctions against North Korea

The Trump administration is due to announce new sanctions on North Korea on Tuesday after declaring it a state sponsor of terrorism
Updated: 4 minutes ago
Trump administration announces sanctions against North Korea

Trump administration announces sanctions against North Korea

The Trump administration is due to announce new sanctions on North Korea on Tuesday after declaring it a state sponsor of terrorism
Updated: 4 minutes ago
The Latest: Zimbabwe Parliament opens as impeachment planned

The Latest: Zimbabwe Parliament opens as impeachment planned

The Latest: Zimbabwe's Parliament opens as ruling party seeks to impeach Mugabe
Updated: 7 minutes ago

Rapper Nelly's planned Saudi gig sparks social media stir

Rapper Nelly's planned concert in ultraconservative Saudi Arabia not welcomed by everyone
Updated: 7 minutes ago

Zimbabwe's Parliament opens as ruling party seeks to impeach longtime leader Mugabe

Zimbabwe's Parliament opens as ruling party seeks to impeach longtime leader Mugabe
Updated: 9 minutes ago

Udinese fires coach Delneri, Oddo expected to come in

Udinese has fired coach Luigi Delneri after earning only 12 points from 12 matches this season
Updated: 18 minutes ago
Kathy Griffin: Trump photo put me on 'Hollywood blacklist'

Kathy Griffin: Trump photo put me on 'Hollywood blacklist'

Kathy Griffin says she is in the middle of a "Hollywood blacklist" after taking a photo holding a fake severed head that resembled President Donald Trump
Updated: 19 minutes ago

Ikea again announces dresser recall after death of 7th child

Ikea relaunches recall of 29 million chests and dressers after death of 7th child
Updated: 19 minutes ago

FIFA bans 3 soccer officials for life for taking bribes

FIFA says three soccer officials who pleaded guilty in American courts to accepting bribes have been banned for life
Updated: 19 minutes ago