Make us your home page

Too few Medals of Honor for Iraq, Afghan war valor?

WASHINGTON — Eight years of war in Afghanistan and Iraq. About 4,000 members of the U.S. military killed in action. More than 34,000 wounded. Just six considered worthy of America's highest military award for battlefield valor.

For some veterans and members of Congress, that last number doesn't add up.

They question how so few Medals of Honor — all awarded posthumously — could be bestowed for wars of such magnitude and duration.

Pentagon officials say the nature of war has changed. Laser-guided missiles destroy enemy positions without putting soldiers in harm's way. Insurgents deploy roadside bombs rather than engage in firefights they're certain to lose.

Those explanations don't tell the whole story, said Rep. Duncan Hunter, a first-term lawmaker who served combat tours as a Marine in Iraq and Afghanistan. He has sponsored legislation that directs the defense secretary to review current trends in awarding the Medal of Honor.

The bill passed the House. If Senate negotiators go along, Secretary Robert Gates would have to report back by March 31.

"The basis of warfare is you've got to take ground and then you've got to hold it. That takes people walking into houses, running up hills, killing bad guys and then staying there and rebuffing counterattacks," said Hunter, R-Calif. "That's how warfare has always been, no matter how many bombs you drop and how many Predators you have flying around."

Military officials said they welcome the opportunity to conduct an in-depth review.

"Nominations go through no more or less scrutiny than in the past," said Eileen Lainez, a Pentagon spokeswoman. "The standard for the Medal of Honor is high, as one would expect for our nation's most prestigious military decoration."

Fast facts

Medal of Honor

The Medal of Honor has been awarded 3,467 times since the Civil War. Almost half — 1,522 — were awarded in that conflict alone. The next highest tally came from World War II — 464. In the Vietnam War, 244 were awarded.

To earn the medal, at least two eyewitnesses have to view a deed so outstanding that it clearly distinguishes gallantry above and beyond the call of duty. No margin of doubt is allowed. Nominations make their way through military channels until eventually they're approved at the highest levels of the Pentagon and then by the president.

Recent recipients

Six members of the U.S. military who were killed in action have been chosen for the Medal of Honor during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan:

• Lt. Michael P. Murphy, Navy. (Afghanistan)

• Cpl. Jason L. Dunham, Marine Corps. (Iraq)

• Pfc. Ross A. McGinnis, Army. (Iraq)

• Petty Officer 2nd Class Michael A. Monsoor, Navy. (Iraq)

• Sgt. 1st Class Paul R. Smith, Army. (Iraq)

• Staff Sgt. Jared C. Monti, Army. (Afghanistan)

Too few Medals of Honor for Iraq, Afghan war valor? 08/01/09 [Last modified: Saturday, August 1, 2009 10:09pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Associated Press.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours