Tuesday, November 21, 2017

Too stoned to be on the road?

RECOMMENDED READING


Josephine Drum says her daughter was "cheated out of life" when she was killed while driving to work in Seattle in 2012, hit by a man in a Jeep whose blood tested positive for marijuana. "I feel if you smoke marijuana and you have to smoke it, that you should not be able to drive under the influence," said Drum, of Stockton, Calif. "I'm 84 years old. To have lost my daughter is something hard for me to accept."

With the push to legalize marijuana surging in popularity, states want to assure the public that roads will be safe. But they face a perplexing question: How stoned is too stoned to drive?

"The answer is: Pretty damned stoned is not as dangerous as drunk," said Mark Kleiman, professor of public policy at the University of California, Los Angeles, who served as Washington state's top pot consultant.

He said Washington state has a law that's far too strict and could lead to convictions of sober drivers, with many not even knowing whether they're abiding by the law.

With no conclusive research, states are all over the map as they try to assess intoxication by measuring blood levels of THC, the main ingredient in marijuana. There's no easy way to do it, with marijuana stored in fat cells and detectable in blood long after it's smoked or consumed, depending on individual tolerance and level of use.

Washington state and Colorado, the only two states to fully legalize marijuana, have set a limit of 5 nanograms of active THC per milliliter of blood. In Washington state, legalization proponents included the language in the ballot initiative approved by voters in 2012. "It appealed to the voters, but it's nonsense — it's not a good measure of whether somebody's impaired or not," Kleiman said.

In California, lawmakers recently rejected an even tougher standard. The state's Assembly Committee on Public Safety voted to kill a bill that would have set the limit at 2 nanograms per milliliter of blood. And in Arizona, the state Supreme Court last month struck down part of the state's zero-tolerance law, saying it could result in convictions of sober drivers.

"What we have to understand is that arbitrary rules or zero tolerance lead to unconstitutional policing," said Diane Goldstein of Tustin, Calif., a former police lieutenant and a member of Law Enforcement Against Prohibition, a pro-legalization group that opposes the laws.

While police can use Breathalyzers to easily measure the amount of alcohol in one's bloodstream, the best way to determine marijuana intoxication is by examining a blood sample. Last year, the U.S. Supreme Court complicated the situation for states by ruling that police must get a warrant before testing blood for a DUI.

"Drawing blood is not a roadside activity for a cop," Kleiman said. "Drawing blood is a medical procedure and you need a licensed phlebotomist. So you're not going to be able to do stoned-driving checkpoints."

Ultimately, he said, a mouth swab that uses a driver's saliva to detect the presence of marijuana may be the answer, if test results can be used to track impairment.

"The problem is that science is lagging really far behind with drugs versus alcohol," Goldstein said.

• • •

As the debate heats up, both sides can point to competing research.

In February, researchers from Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health reported that fatal crashes involving marijuana use had tripled over the past decade, with 1 of every 9 drivers now involved in a deadly accident testing positive for pot.

But legalization advocates cite statistics showing that the number of DUI fatalities has decreased slightly in both Washington state and Colorado since 2012.

Kleiman of UCLA sees good news and bad news in the issue. "The bad news is at the moment we don't have anything sensible to do about stoned driving," he said. "The good news is that it's only a moderate-sized problem. . I would be nervous about over-criminalizing it."

Comments
Making sense of the latest Chip Kelly-Florida news

Making sense of the latest Chip Kelly-Florida news

Florida is prepared to look beyond Chip Kelly as its next coach, Yahoo! Sports reported Tuesday afternoon.Of course the Gators are. They have to be. UCLA is a feasible landing spot for Kelly, the former Oregon coach. UF athletic director Scott Strick...
Updated: 17 minutes ago
Spurs win Champions League group beating Dortmund 2-1

Spurs win Champions League group beating Dortmund 2-1

Tottenham Hotspur has come from behind to beat Borussia Dortmund 2-1 and book its place in the Champions League last-16 as group winner ahead of Real Madrid
Updated: 3 minutes ago

MS-13 gang leader convicted of encouraging rival killings

A man who led a local chapter of violent Central American street gang MS-13 has been convicted of racketeering conspiracy in Boston federal court
Updated: 3 minutes ago
Man arrested in cop killing; mom accused of helping him flee

Man arrested in cop killing; mom accused of helping him flee

Tips from informants led law enforcement to a home where they found a man accused of fatally shooting a rookie police officer in suburban Pittsburgh during a traffic stop last week
Updated: 3 minutes ago

Diary: Inmate got over-the-counter drugs before cancer death

A Vermont inmate who died of cancer at a Pennsylvania prison wrote in a diary that he repeatedly asked for medical care but was denied and given ibuprofen and Tylenol for his pain
Updated: 3 minutes ago

AP Top News at 4:47 p.m. EST

AP Top News at 4:47 p.m. EST
Updated: 6 minutes ago
US slaps new sanctions on North Korean, Chinese companies

US slaps new sanctions on North Korean, Chinese companies

The Trump administration has imposed new sanctions on a slew of North Korean shipping firms and Chinese trading companies in its latest push to isolate the rogue nation over its nuclear weapons development and deprive it of revenue
Updated: 6 minutes ago
The Latest: Lebanese PM returns home after shock resignation

The Latest: Lebanese PM returns home after shock resignation

Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri has returned to Beirut more than two weeks after announcing while in Saudi Arabia that he had resigned his post
Updated: 6 minutes ago
Pasco Deputies: Man climbs into bed with sleeping woman after multiple burglaries

Pasco Deputies: Man climbs into bed with sleeping woman after multiple burglaries

NEW PORT RICHEY — A man who ended a series of burglaries by breaking into the home of a sleeping woman, where he climbed into her bed, was arrested Monday afternoon, the Pasco County Sheriff’s Office said.Russel Smith, 42, now faces three felony char...
Updated: 7 minutes ago
Mugabe leaves legacy of economic ruin, upheaval in Zimbabwe

Mugabe leaves legacy of economic ruin, upheaval in Zimbabwe

From magnanimous liberator to despotic dictator, Robert Mugabe's 37-year rule of Zimbabwe has been one of Africa's most controversial and influential
Updated: 7 minutes ago