Friday, December 15, 2017

Tough class? That's how to learn

My wife surfs the Internet more than I do and delights in sharing her discoveries. "You'll like this comment," she said last week. A reader wrote that the rising number of students failing Advanced Placement tests "could be a response to Jay Mathews' ridiculous Challenge Index."

It was nice to be noticed, and the reader had a point. As an education columnist for the Washington Post, I have been rating high schools since 1998 with an index that measures the portion of students taking AP, International Baccalaureate and Advanced International Certificate of Education courses and tests, not how well the students perform on them. The reader was commenting on a post by an education blogger expressing concern about "putting students in a class they're not prepared for," such as AP.

Many people wonder why schools do that. Doesn't that discourage the kids? Isn't it a waste of their time to try to learn something so far above their level? Those are legitimate worries.

But after 31 years watching and interviewing hundreds of AP and IB teachers who welcome everyone into their classes, I am convinced that schools that challenge average or even below-average students that way have the right idea. What critics of that approach don't understand are nuances in what motivates teen-agers and what happens when courses lack the incorruptible exams provided by AP, IB and AICE.

I invented the Challenge Index on washingtonpost.com to dramatize the success of schools like Garfield High School in East Los Angeles. Most education experts assumed Garfield students were not ready for the heavy homework and long exams in AP. Yet in 1987, two teachers at that school, Jaime Escalante and Ben Jimenez, produced 26 percent of all the Mexican-American students in the country who passed an AP Calculus test with a score of 3 or higher.

How did Garfield succeed when other schools with ill-prepared students did not? When the film Stand and Deliver was made about Escalante, the popular explanation was that he had a genius that other teachers could not replicate. Few noticed that Jimenez, no different from thousands of other good teachers, got the same results doing what Escalante did, giving kids more encouragement and time to learn.

If you visit schools that do that today, you will discover that the students who struggle in AP classes are not discouraged by the difficulty of the material when they are taught by encouraging teachers. AP to them is like going one-on-one against LeBron James. They don't score much, but they improve and are proud to have a tough challenge.

AP, IB and AICE exams are written and graded by outside experts. They cannot be dumbed down by classroom teachers. Schools that try somewhat less-challenging courses and tests to suit their less-prepared students find that doesn't work. The temptation to go easy on such kids is too strong when there is no independent exam to keep them honest.

AVID, the nation's largest college-readiness program, insists that average students be put in AP or IB but gives them extra tutoring. I have yet to find any schools making more progress by challenging their students less. — Washington Post

Comments

Pakistan court rejects petition to disqualify well-known pol

Pakistan's top court rejects petition seeking to disqualify from office a famous cricketer-turned opposition leader for concealing foreign assets
Updated: 9 minutes ago

Russia to resume flights to Egypt, halted after 2015 bombing

Russia's transportation minister says Moscow will resume flights to Cairo, suspended after 2015 IS bombing
Updated: 16 minutes ago
Missing Child Alert issued for Port St. Lucie girl, 17

Missing Child Alert issued for Port St. Lucie girl, 17

A Florida Missing Child Alert has been issued for a 17-year-old Port St. Lucie girl who was last seen on Thursday.Heaven Flores was last seen near the 1400 block of SW Cashmere Boulevard in Port St. Lucie, according to the Florida Department of Law E...
Updated: 16 minutes ago
EU official: unprecedented step warning Poland is likely

EU official: unprecedented step warning Poland is likely

A top European Union official says the bloc's executive Commission will decide next week whether to trigger an unprecedented procedure against Poland that could see the country lose its voting rights in the EU
Updated: 19 minutes ago

They'll be no homecoming for former Gamecocks coach

New College of Charleston baseball coach Chad Holbrook won't return to his former home field at South Carolina next season
Updated: 21 minutes ago
Ex-Russian minister jailed for 8 years over $2 million bribe

Ex-Russian minister jailed for 8 years over $2 million bribe

Russia's former economics minister has been sentenced to eight years in maximum security prison after being convicted of accepting a $2 million bribe
Updated: 22 minutes ago

AP News in Brief at 6:04 a.m. EST

AP News in Brief at 6:04 a.m. EST
Updated: 24 minutes ago
10 Things to Know for Today

10 Things to Know for Today

Among 10 Things to Know: Marco Rubio's potential defection puts a speed bump into tax overhaul; Charges upgraded to first-degree murder for man accused of ramming crowd at Charlottesville rally; Disney-Fox deal dramatically redraws film industry map
Updated: 26 minutes ago

AP Top News at 6:02 a.m. EST

AP Top News at 6:02 a.m. EST
Updated: 26 minutes ago

Spain: Homicide suspect sought for months by Italy is arrested in Spain after 3 new killings

Spain: Homicide suspect sought for months by Italy is arrested in Spain after 3 new killings
Updated: 27 minutes ago