Friday, April 20, 2018

Tough class? That's how to learn

My wife surfs the Internet more than I do and delights in sharing her discoveries. "You'll like this comment," she said last week. A reader wrote that the rising number of students failing Advanced Placement tests "could be a response to Jay Mathews' ridiculous Challenge Index."

It was nice to be noticed, and the reader had a point. As an education columnist for the Washington Post, I have been rating high schools since 1998 with an index that measures the portion of students taking AP, International Baccalaureate and Advanced International Certificate of Education courses and tests, not how well the students perform on them. The reader was commenting on a post by an education blogger expressing concern about "putting students in a class they're not prepared for," such as AP.

Many people wonder why schools do that. Doesn't that discourage the kids? Isn't it a waste of their time to try to learn something so far above their level? Those are legitimate worries.

But after 31 years watching and interviewing hundreds of AP and IB teachers who welcome everyone into their classes, I am convinced that schools that challenge average or even below-average students that way have the right idea. What critics of that approach don't understand are nuances in what motivates teen-agers and what happens when courses lack the incorruptible exams provided by AP, IB and AICE.

I invented the Challenge Index on washingtonpost.com to dramatize the success of schools like Garfield High School in East Los Angeles. Most education experts assumed Garfield students were not ready for the heavy homework and long exams in AP. Yet in 1987, two teachers at that school, Jaime Escalante and Ben Jimenez, produced 26 percent of all the Mexican-American students in the country who passed an AP Calculus test with a score of 3 or higher.

How did Garfield succeed when other schools with ill-prepared students did not? When the film Stand and Deliver was made about Escalante, the popular explanation was that he had a genius that other teachers could not replicate. Few noticed that Jimenez, no different from thousands of other good teachers, got the same results doing what Escalante did, giving kids more encouragement and time to learn.

If you visit schools that do that today, you will discover that the students who struggle in AP classes are not discouraged by the difficulty of the material when they are taught by encouraging teachers. AP to them is like going one-on-one against LeBron James. They don't score much, but they improve and are proud to have a tough challenge.

AP, IB and AICE exams are written and graded by outside experts. They cannot be dumbed down by classroom teachers. Schools that try somewhat less-challenging courses and tests to suit their less-prepared students find that doesn't work. The temptation to go easy on such kids is too strong when there is no independent exam to keep them honest.

AVID, the nation's largest college-readiness program, insists that average students be put in AP or IB but gives them extra tutoring. I have yet to find any schools making more progress by challenging their students less. — Washington Post

Comments
Romney seeks Utah Republican Party nomination at convention

Romney seeks Utah Republican Party nomination at convention

Mitt Romney has one of the best-known names in politics, but he still must face down nearly a dozen Utah contenders in his bid to restart his political career with a U.S. Senate seat
Updated: 1 hour ago

Tobin Heath returns to the Thorns after ankle surgery

Tobin Heath came in off the bench Friday night for the Portland Thorns' match against the Washington Spirit, making her first appearance of the season
Updated: 1 hour ago
Avalanche stay alive, beat Predators 2-1 to force Game 6

Avalanche stay alive, beat Predators 2-1 to force Game 6

Sven Andrighetto scored with 1:28 left to give the Colorado Avalanche a 2-1 victory over Nashville Predators 2-1, sending the first-round series back to Denver for Game 6.
Updated: 1 hour ago
Baez, Schwarber homer, Cubs beat Rockies 16-5

Baez, Schwarber homer, Cubs beat Rockies 16-5

Kyle Hendricks pitched effectively for five innings, Javier Baez and Kyle Schwarber both homered and the Chicago Cubs rode a seven-run sixth inning to a 16-5 victory over the Colorado Rockies on Friday night
Updated: 1 hour ago
4 Palestinians killed by Israeli fire in Gaza border protest

4 Palestinians killed by Israeli fire in Gaza border protest

Gaza health officials say 4 Palestinians, including 15-year-old boy, killed by Israeli army fire as thousands join fourth weekly protests on Gaza border
Updated: 1 hour ago
4 Palestinians killed by Israeli fire in Gaza border protest

4 Palestinians killed by Israeli fire in Gaza border protest

Gaza health officials say 4 Palestinians, including 15-year-old boy, killed by Israeli army fire as thousands join fourth weekly protests on Gaza border
Updated: 1 hour ago
Moreland's slam, Red Sox beat A's 7-3 for 8th straight win

Moreland's slam, Red Sox beat A's 7-3 for 8th straight win

Mitch Moreland hit a grand slam, Jackie Bradley Jr. added a three-run homer and the streaking Boston Red Sox won their eighth in a row, beating the Oakland Athletics 7-3
Updated: 1 hour ago
Nats beat Dodgers 5-2 in uneven matchup of Scherzer, Kershaw

Nats beat Dodgers 5-2 in uneven matchup of Scherzer, Kershaw

Max Scherzer scattered four hits over six innings against Clayton Kershaw in the 13th all-time meeting of three-time Cy Young Award winners and the Nationals beat the Dodgers 5-2
Updated: 1 hour ago

White Sox reliever Farquhar passes out in dugout

White Sox reliever Danny Farquhar taken to hospital after passing out in dugout
Updated: 2 hours ago
Defense found: Bucks overwhelm Celtics for 116-92 win

Defense found: Bucks overwhelm Celtics for 116-92 win

Khris Middleton scored 23 points and the Milwaukee Bucks rode a dominating first half to overwhelm the Boston Celtics for a 116-92 win, narrowing the deficit in the first-round playoff series to 2-1
Updated: 2 hours ago