Monday, November 20, 2017

Warning: This may be upsetting to you

RECOMMENDED READING


Academia has always been an easy target for mockery. Henry Kissinger observed that university politics are so vicious precisely because the stakes are so low, and one logical extension is that liberal arts departments are steeped in self-importance precisely because their impact on the "real world" is negligible.

Ergo, the recent campus phenomenon known as the "trigger warning." Originating on certain feminist, self-help and social activist blogs, trigger warnings are meant to inform readers that the ensuing material deals with subjects, such as war or sexual violence, that might upset those suffering from post-traumatic stress related to those issues.

Now the practice is creeping toward liberal arts syllabi. The University of California-Santa Barbara student Senate recently passed a resolution calling for professors to label potentially upsetting course material and even excuse "triggered" students from some classes. Oberlin College in Ohio has already implemented such guidelines.

Distressing as such potential incursions on academic freedom and inquiry may be, the real trend here may not be trigger warnings but the torrent of outrage they've set off. They're ripe for bemused chatter, to say the least. A New Republic article supplied a list of warning-worthy triggers: bullying, sizism, ablism, transphobia, slut shaming, alcohol and (seriously) animals in wigs. Even the satirical Onion has been called out for failing to warn readers about disturbing content in fake stories.

I'll admit that some colleges indulge students as much as educate them, but I'd venture to say this isn't a grand mal social movement as much as it is just two overreacting schools. Like Antioch College in Ohio, whose bizarre sexual-offense policy of 1991 wrongly gave the impression that every liberal arts student in America was required to ask their intimate partners questions like "can I touch you here?" during intimate moments, Oberlin's trigger warnings surely have more to do with Oberlin itself than anything else.

But as much as we might enjoy poking fun at delicate English majors, the truth is we're all on a hair trigger these days. We customize our information delivery systems so we mostly see, hear and read what won't upset us too much.

Liberals stay away from Fox News. Conservatives shield themselves from MSNBC. We choose to live in particular neighborhoods or regions in part because we want neighbors who share our values. We rant away on social media, but we're usually just talking to people who already agree with us.

How much difference is there, really, between refusing to read Chinua Achebe's Things Fall Apart (a trigger targeted novel at Oberlin) because it deals with troubling racial and religious issues and refusing to listen to opposing views that might make you angry?

That's not to compare classic literature to cable news. Given the choice between Fox or MSNBC, we'd be better off skipping both and reading a good book instead. But as we indulge in the great American pastime of accusing young people of being made of weaker stuff than their elders, we'd also do well to examine our own avoidance mechanisms.

— Los Angeles Times

Comments
Adam Putnam, Dennis Ross blast lack of citrus aid

Adam Putnam, Dennis Ross blast lack of citrus aid

Florida Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam and Congressman Dennis Ross on Friday criticized a lack of funding for the state's storm-ravaged citrus industry in the latest disaster-relief package proposed by the White House.Putnam said a $44 billion ...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Zimbabwe ruling party official: Impeaching Mugabe should take just 2 days, starting Tuesday

Zimbabwe ruling party official: Impeaching Mugabe should take just 2 days, starting Tuesday
Updated: 5 minutes ago

Jury selection beginning in Iran sanctions case

Jury selection is beginning in a trial surrounding a conspiracy to help Iran evade economic sanctions without the star defendant, an international gold trader
Updated: 6 minutes ago
Iran, Lebanon reject Arab League criticism as tensions mount

Iran, Lebanon reject Arab League criticism as tensions mount

Iran says a statement by Arab League foreign ministers condemning the Islamic Republic and its proxy Hezbollah is "full of lies" and the product of Saudi "pressure and propaganda."
Updated: 7 minutes ago

Argentina says that satellite calls did not come from missing submarine with 44 crew members on board

Argentina says that satellite calls did not come from missing submarine with 44 crew members on board
Updated: 8 minutes ago

Man accused of shooting girlfriend's car on interstate found

Police in New Hampshire have arrested a man suspected of firing multiple shots at his girlfriend's car on Interstate 89 hours after they told residents to lock their homes and a school district canceled classes
Updated: 15 minutes ago
The Latest: Zimbabwe ruling party's lawmakers gather

The Latest: Zimbabwe ruling party's lawmakers gather

The Latest: Zimbabwe ruling party's lawmakers gather as impeachment of Mugabe a possibility
Updated: 17 minutes ago

AP Top News at 9:23 a.m. EST

AP Top News at 9:23 a.m. EST
Updated: 21 minutes ago
Roy Moore accuser says she was not paid to tell her story

Roy Moore accuser says she was not paid to tell her story

A woman accusing Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore of initiating sexual contact when she was 14 says she was "absolutely not" paid to tell her story
Updated: 26 minutes ago
Roy Moore accuser says she was not paid to tell her story

Roy Moore accuser says she was not paid to tell her story

A woman accusing Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore of initiating sexual contact when she was 14 says she was "absolutely not" paid to tell her story
Updated: 26 minutes ago