Thursday, September 20, 2018

Landowners oppose oil pipeline before Iowa Supreme Court

DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — A group of Iowa landowners and an environmental group asked the Iowa Supreme Court Wednesday to declare a crude oil pipeline permit illegal under the Iowa Constitution, a decision that could force the pipeline in operation for more than a year to be turned off.

The attorney for a group of landowners who opposed construction of the Dakota Access oil pipeline through their property told the court since the pipeline provides no direct use to Iowans the decision of the Iowa Utilities Board to grant a permit should be reversed.

"The pipeline crosses the state with no oil wells, no refineries, this pipeline has no onramps and no offramps," said Bill Hannigan. "Iowans have no direct use."

The farmers' land was taken through eminent domain approved by the state utilities board, which concluded that the $4 billion, 1,172-mile underground pipeline transporting over 450,000 barrels per day of domestic crude oil from North Dakota to Illinois provides was necessary.

An Iowa court judge in February 2017 concluded the board properly considered public benefits of the pipeline. The landowners and the environmental group Sierra Club of Iowa appealed. Sierra Club wants the entire pipeline closed down. The landowners want the sections taken by eminent domain removed from their land.

"I want them out. I want them gone. They had no right to come do this," Fairfield farmer Steven Hickenbottom said after the court arguments.

The company took about eight acres across a 170-acre tract of his land, which totals about 1,000 acres in southeast Iowa.

The pipeline has been carrying oil since June 2017.

The state utilities board concluded that since pipelines are safer than rail transportation and there are economic benefits to the pipeline, the use of eminent domain was justified.

"The board position is there is substantial evidence in the record to support their decisions," said board lawyer Cecil Wright

The high court may choose to use the case to determine whether the state eminent domain laws are lawful under the Iowa Constitution.

Justice Brent Appel challenged the Dakota Access argument.

"It seems to me your argument is whenever the state decides that there's some remote or incidental benefit they can come and take your property," he said. "You might as well just say your right to property is not a constitutional right but subject to the legislative dictate."

Dublinske said there are legislative limits to the power through the utilities board process in which a permit applicant must prove there will be a public use to the project.

The Sierra Club also argued that because the pipeline risks contaminating drinking water for thousands of Iowans, the permit should be overturned.

The Iowa case isn't the only legal challenge to the pipeline.

The Standing Rock Sioux tribe continues its federal court lawsuit in the District of Columbia and is joined by three other Dakotas tribes seeking to shut down the pipeline.

___

Follow David Pitt on Twitter: https://twitter.com/davepitt

Comments
From the anonymity of academia to the center of a Supreme Court confirmation

From the anonymity of academia to the center of a Supreme Court confirmation

The text message from Christine Blasey Ford this summer worried her college best friend, Catherine Piwowarski.Over their years of friendship -- as roommates, bridesmaids and parents on opposite coasts -- Dr. Blasey wanted to know, had she ever confid...
Updated: 17 minutes ago
Tampa City Council approves liquour and rezoning for Stovall House making it private club

Tampa City Council approves liquour and rezoning for Stovall House making it private club

It took nearly 13 hours over three weeks, but developer Blake Casper won City Council approval to convert the historic Stovall House on Bayshore Boulevard to a private club.On Thursday, council members listened to nearly six hours of testimony on the...
Updated: 17 minutes ago
Grab Bag: Forfeit games and risk your playoff chances

Grab Bag: Forfeit games and risk your playoff chances

When it comes to football playoffs, forfeit a game and you may as well forfeit your season.Northside Christian recently was fined $2,302 and slapped with a three-year postseason ban by the Florida High School Athletic Association after forfeiting a S...
Updated: 25 minutes ago
He claims ghosts ask him to restore their dignity. So he digs into their stories.

He claims ghosts ask him to restore their dignity. So he digs into their stories.

TAMPA — Ray Reed claims to see dead people. And he does all he can to introduce them to the living.Reed leads volunteers who have uncovered hundreds of grave markers at the Cemetery for All People, known in the early 1900s as the Poor Farm Cemetery. ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
For starters: Rays at Blue Jays, looking to keep rolling

For starters: Rays at Blue Jays, looking to keep rolling

Having won five straight, a majors-best 14 in 17 September games, and 23 of their past 28 overall, the Rays are looking to keep rolling as they open a four-game series tonight against the Blue Jays in Toronto.Obviously they need to to continue their ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Latest: Mom slams college months after teens patted down

The Latest: Mom slams college months after teens patted down

The mother of two Native American teens pulled from a Colorado State University tour last spring says she's disappointed the school hasn't taken more steps to prevent other racial profiling incidents
Updated: 1 hour ago
Confederate group banned from Temple Terrace country club, may take legal action

Confederate group banned from Temple Terrace country club, may take legal action

TEMPLE TERRACE — After complaints from city residents, the Temple Terrace Golf & Country Club has notified the City Council that it will not rent space again to the Sons of Confederate Veterans for its annual banquet.The country clubȁ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Latest: Wife of gunman says she's OK after shooting

The Latest: Wife of gunman says she's OK after shooting

Three civilians wounded when a gunman opened fire outside a crowded Pennsylvania courtroom are now out of the hospital
Updated: 1 hour ago

Trump backs 'outstanding' Webber in House race vs. Sherrill

President Donald Trump has weighed in on one of the most watched House races in this year's election to endorse Republican Assemblyman Jay Webber over Democrat Mikie Sherrill
Updated: 1 hour ago

The Latest: Thermal spring erupts at Yellowstone

A Yellowstone National Park official says a thermal spring near Old Faithful is erupting for the first time in 14 years
Updated: 1 hour ago