Wednesday, September 19, 2018
News Roundup

Romano: How long before you take a selfie in front of pier art?

You go to Harvard to study art. You move to Hong Kong and Bali to further your education. You are invited by the Fulbright Scholar Program to lecture about art in India.

Finally, you return to the United States where you are asked to produce a sculpture that will serve as the centerpiece of a large city park in a thriving downtown in the American West.

And someone says it resembles cow poop.

Or a jellyfish.

Also a condom.

Welcome to Janet Echelman’s world.

And perhaps the St. Petersburg waterfront.

In this case, the monument to cow patties was a floating sculpture of colorful nets suspended above a new park in downtown Phoenix. And, similar to the conversation about Echelman’s proposed artwork for St. Pete’s Pier District, the initial chatter in Phoenix was mixed, at best.

This was more than 10 years, and several prestigious awards, ago. Back then, there were people ridiculing Echelman’s concept for Phoenix as too expensive and too weird. Also, there were questions about its durability and susceptibility to the elements.

Sound familiar?

Echelman’s $2.4 million Phoenix proposal was briefly canceled by the city manager’s office in 2007 before public outcry revived the idea within a week. It’s now been standing for almost nine years.

"The conversation we had in Phoenix is one you can find anywhere in the nation when you’re talking about newer works that defy expectations and have never been seen before,’’ said Ed Lebow, the public art program director at the Phoenix Office of Arts and Culture.

"I can’t speak for everybody, but … the lighting for it is beautiful, it’s a very soft, colorful glow that is quite subtle. It’s beautiful during the daytime too, but it is very popular at night.’’

The best art is rarely universal. To create something special, you literally need to color outside the lines. It’s the difference between the comfort of a chain restaurant and the uniqueness of a local favorite.

This type of criticism is nothing new for Echelman. It’s the price of creating something unique.

The reward, she says, is when the sculpture is completed and people can experience it firsthand instead of trying to critique a rendering.

"The (Phoenix) city manager recently introduced me for an international conference for city managers that happened to be held in Phoenix,’’ Echelman wrote in an email. "He started by saying that he initially opposed the project, and that now he loved it and could not imagine the city without it. That meant a lot.’’

The Phoenix project is instructive because of the similarities, in both concept and development, to the pier. Both were funded (at least partially) with tax dollars, and both were going on public land.

Echelman’s work in Seattle, for instance, was privately funded by Bill Gates on a corporate campus. The Greensboro, N.C., project used money bequeathed to the city. Other projects have been temporary (Boston) or smaller (San Francisco).

Like Phoenix, the pier proposal is meant to be iconic. It is less a complement, and more an attraction.

Is it expensive? Yes, but in this case the cost is somewhat offset. More than half of the $2.8 million price tag will be covered by local benefactors. Public financing will account for about $1.3 million.

Will it withstand wind and sun? Phoenix has already replaced the nets, but that material was cheaper and meant to be recyclable. Echelman says the material she wants to use in St. Petersburg will better withstand the sun.

Is it a risk? I suppose, but it’s a calculated risk. The public cost is not excessive considering Echelman’s reputation and track record, and it’s not like it will forever alter the waterfront. It would be fairly easily removed. On the other hand, it has the potential to be a major public draw.

Admittedly, the finer points of art are lost on me. I sometimes oooh, and occasionally aaah, but I’m an unwitting philistine most of the time. My first impression of the rendering was that it resembled a Grateful Dead T-shirt I once owned.

But, speaking for the culturally bereft, I’m intrigued. It’s original. It’s colorful. It’s got a chance to make St. Pete’s waterfront instantly identifiable. It will become the overhead shot most TV cameras seek out for Tampa Bay sporting events, and it’s almost guaranteed to show up in Facebook selfies daily.

I’m neither critic nor expert, but I do like to gamble occasionally.

And this feels like a bet worth making.

This column has been revised to reflect the following clarification: The material for Janet Echelman’s proposed artwork in St. Petersburg is different and more resistant to UV light than what she used for her Phoenix sculpture. That point was not clear in an earlier version of this column.

 
Comments
Blake Snell wins major-league-leading 20th in 4-0 win over Rangers

Blake Snell wins major-league-leading 20th in 4-0 win over Rangers

ARLINGTON, Texas — One of the things that has made Blake Snell so good this season for the Rays is his refusal to be satisfied with anything he does.No matter how well he pitches, he finds flaws in his performance and identifies something ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Lightning journal: Alex Killorn’s just puttin’ on the Fitz

Lightning journal: Alex Killorn’s just puttin’ on the Fitz

TAMPA — How big is FitzMagic? It has hit the Lightning, too.Proving that Harvard guys stick together, Lightning forward Alex Killorn showed support for fellow Harvard grad Ryan Fitzpatrick by, sort of, dressing up the way Fitzpatrick did after ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Tuesday’s Rays-Rangers game

Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Tuesday’s Rays-Rangers game

LHP Blake Snell certainly gets the bulk of the credit for his remarkable season, and there's definitely some due to pitching coach Kyle Snyder. But don't ignore C Jesus Sucre, who Snell likes throwing to and has been both a good target and a calming ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Bucs’ Jameis Winston sued by Arizona Uber driver in alleged groping incident

Bucs’ Jameis Winston sued by Arizona Uber driver in alleged groping incident

TAMPA — Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston was sued Tuesday by the Arizona Uber driver who has accused him of sexual assault by groping her in March 2016.The woman — identified only as Kate P. in the federal court papers — is seeking m...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Rays journal: Ji-Man Choi impresses fellow South Korean major-leaguer

Rays journal: Ji-Man Choi impresses fellow South Korean major-leaguer

ARLINGTON, Texas — DH Ji-Man Choi has impressed a lot of people with his increasing offensive production since joining the Rays in July.That includes fellow South Korean Shin-Soo Choo, the Rangers' veteran outfielder/DH who has been keeping tab...
Updated: 3 hours ago

Volleyball: PHU continues mastery of St. Petersburg with 3-0 win

ST. PETERSBURG — The much anticipated showdown between Class 8A, District 10 rivals Palm Harbor University and St. Petersburg ended up being a 25-21, 25-23, 25-20 sweep for the Hurricanes. It was the first loss of the season for the Green Devil...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Updated: 7 hours ago
For starters: Rays at Rangers, with Snell going for No. 20

For starters: Rays at Rangers, with Snell going for No. 20

UPDATE, 6:53: Cash said he and others around the team are excited about the possibility of Snell getting his 20th win, and also that they obviously want to win the game. Cash showed it by starting C Jesus Sucre, who Snell likes to throw to. … M...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Tampa Bay businesses feel Red Tide’s sting: ‘Our sales are going to be our lowest ever’

Tampa Bay businesses feel Red Tide’s sting: ‘Our sales are going to be our lowest ever’

TREASURE ISLAND — For the first time during her 15 years bartending at Caddy’s on the Beach, Amanda Hudson had to help close shop early this past weekend because the smell of dead fish coming from the gulf was too putrid to bear."We had to shut down ...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Updated: 9 hours ago