Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Trial pitting nursing home residents against Medicaid begins

TALLAHASSEE — Marguerite Pace, 48, has a business degree, a law degree and passes her time in a Sarasota nursing home bed. Renal failure and collapsed vertebrae have kept her from moving around on her own since 2006.

But she harbors a vision about what life could be. She would like an apartment of her own, a motorized wheelchair, an aide to help her bathe and dress and, most of all, a job.

"I want to work," Pace says. "I don't need legs for that."

Her story and those of dozens of other nursing home residents are playing out this month in a federal lawsuit over how Florida treats some of its frailest citizens.

Southern Legal Counsel and AARP have sued the state under the Americans with Disabilities Act, alleging that Florida's Medicaid program too often relies on nursing homes instead of bringing services to people's homes. The disabilities act requires states to integrate people into their communities.

Similar lawsuits have sprung mentally ill people from institutions. This case extends the debate to nursing homes.

Battle lines were drawn Monday in opening statements.

Lawyers for the state noted that Florida serves about 50,000 frail Medicaid clients at home or in assisted living homes, compared to 40,000 to 45,000 in nursing homes. Since 2009, state agencies have transferred 1,700 nursing home residents back into the community.

"We have had a flat nursing home population for a decade while home and community based programs are expanding," said Justin Senior, general counsel for the Agency for Health Care Administration. "It's a pretty dramatic success."

Plaintiffs' lawyers say the state has not done enough. They want U.S. District Court Judge Robert Hinkle to order Florida to expand its at-home programs.

"We think thousands of people could come out" of nursing homes, plaintiffs' attorney Stephen Gold said. "If they can reside in the community with appropriate services, the failure to do that is discrimination."

Pace, who appeared in a video deposition, was the first witness as plaintiffs began to put on their case. She can use a cell phone and a computer and has researched programs that teach disabled people how to drive.

But Medicaid workers had rejected her request for at-home care. They were not worried about money. Both sides agree that supporting people at home or in assisted living is usually less expensive than a nursing home.

But Pace wouldn't be safe outside the nursing home, Medicaid said. She lacks support in the community, the Medicaid report said. She needs "24-hour observation and care" and can't leave "because of safety issues."

Jacksonville resident Clayton Griffin was also denied at-home care while living in a nursing home. He also needed 24-hour care and observation, Medicaid evaluators said.

Griffin, 58, simply moved out two years ago, trying to pay his own way from a Social Security check. But it was nowhere near enough. In September, Judge Hinkle ordered the state to start providing him at-home services, so now he gets frozen meals he can microwave and aides about four hours a day to get him out of bed, clean his house and do laundry.

Testifying by telephone, Griffin said he attends church, does his own shopping in a motorized wheelchair, goes to the movies and socializes with neighbors in his apartment.

"I have a sense of independence," he said. "I have the fellowship with people my own age. Well people. They aren't sick."

Gold asked him if he was still seeing a "lady friend."

"Yes," said Griffin.

"No further questions."

The nonjury trial is expected to last two weeks. Later this week or early next, the state gets to put on its defense, to explain in detail why people like Pace and Griffin might, in fact, be unsafe in the community.

Hinkle could take months to rule.

Trial pitting nursing home residents against Medicaid begins 02/07/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, February 8, 2011 7:10am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa man crashes into parked cars, gate at the Islamic Society of Tampa Mosque


    A Tampa man intentionally drove his pick-up truck into two parked vehicles before smashing through the locked gate of the Islamic Society of Tampa Mosque, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office.

    Shaun H. Urwiler, 42, was arrested July 16 for intentionally driving his pick-up truck into two parked vehicles before smashing through the locked gate of the Islamic Society of Tampa Mosque, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  2. USF hoops to play at Indiana in November


    The USF men's basketball team is set to get an early test from a Big Ten powerhouse in non-conference play next season.

  3. Last steel beam marks construction milestone for Tom and Mary James' museum


    ST. PETERSBURG — Tom and Mary James on Wednesday signed their names to the last steel beam framing the 105-ton stone mesa that will be built at the entrance of the museum that bears their name: the James Museum of Western and Wildlife Art.

    The topping-out ceremony of the James Museum of Western & Wildlife Art was held Wednesday morning in downtown St. Petersburg. Mary James (from left), husband Tom and Mayor Rick Kriseman signed the final beam before it was put into place. When finished, the $55 million museum at 100 Central Ave. will hold up to 500 pieces of the couple's 3,000-piece art collection. [Courtesy of James Museum of Western & Wildlife Art]
  4. Florida's school grades improve as educators get the hang of a new system


    Following a trend, Florida's school grades showed strong gains in the third year after the state changed its grading formula and the standardized tests that students take every year.

    After finding out earlier Wednesday that her school went from a low C to an A,  Bear Creek Elementary principal Willette Houston celebrates with her students in the YMCA After School program at the school in St. Petersburg. Houston is giving a high five to rising fifth grader Jonaven Viera. Rising 4th grader Jonathan Cafaro is in foreground with his back to camera. [CHERIE DIEZ   |   Times]
  5. Tampa Bay woman, 11-year-old boy had sex up to 20 times the year their baby was born, detectives say.


    TAMPA — A woman sexually battered an 11-year-old Brandon boy, got pregnant and raised the baby for three years before a tip led to her arrest, Hillsborough County sheriff's officials said.

    Marissa Mowry, now 25,  had sex as many as 20 times in 2014 with a boy who was 11 when he impregnated her, Hillsborough County detectives allege. [Photo courtesy of Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office]