Today's paper | eEdition | Subscribe
The Truth-O-Meter
Latest print edition
St. Petersburg Times
Special report
  • Testing Grounds
    The latest industry being outsourced to India is clinical drug trials. And any number of tragic things can happen on the way to your medicine cabinet.
  • More special reports
Video report
  • Friday Night Rewind
    It doesn't matter which team you cheer for. We've got video previews of every high school football program in Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco and Hernando County.
  • More video reports
Multimedia report
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Recipient email
You may enter up to 20 multiple email addresses, separated by commas.
Your message
Validation Code
Hear
validation
code
  Enter validation code

A multilevel scheme, in down-to-earth Quincy

By Richard Danielson, Times Staff Writer
In print: Sunday, October 19, 2008


“It’s a great little town, but it’s just poverty-stricken,” ChristTown Community pastor Bob Wells said of the North Florida town of Quincy. Residents called AdSurfDaily a “godsend” to the town.
“It’s a great little town, but it’s just poverty-stricken,” ChristTown Community pastor Bob Wells said of the North Florida town of Quincy. Residents called AdSurfDaily a “godsend” to the town.
[Mark Wallheiser | Special to the Times]
Social Bookmarking
Digg Facebook Stumbleupon
Reddit Del.icio.us Newsvine
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Video...
Loading...

QUINCY — The faithful come to ChristTown Community Church every Wednesday morning to lift up the needs of this town.

Good schools, good teachers, good jobs.

Especially good jobs.

Nearly half the work force drives half an hour to jobs in Tallahassee, and the biggest private employer is a mushroom farm. A third of the storefronts around Quincy's town square are government offices or stand vacant.

"It's a great little town, but it's just poverty-stricken," ChristTown Community pastor Bob Wells said. "To be 25 miles from the capital, it's quite a culture shock to see."

This summer, it seemed Quincy's prayers were answered. People began to talk about a local company, AdSurfDaily, and its founder, Andy Bowdoin (pronounced Bowden, like the football coach). It was growing fast and hiring locals.

"It's the best thing that has happened to me since Grandma's apple pie," said Foriest McNiel, 47, who went from making $7.50 an hour as a substitute teacher to $12 an hour as a customer service rep. "It was a godsend to a lot of us."

Then, in August, federal agents raided AdSurfDaily and froze company accounts holding $93.5-million. Officials accused the company of running a huge Ponzi scheme, one of the biggest frauds they can recall in Florida.

A federal grand jury has subpoenaed AdSurfDaily records in a possible criminal wire fraud investigation. Company attorneys say in court pleadings prosecutors told them Bowdoin, 73, will be indicted.

Contacted by the Times, Bowdoin generally declined to discuss the case, the company or himself. He did say he was working with authorities so AdSurfDaily could resume business.

"They just haven't understood how our program worked," he said.

Investors burned by Bowdoin in Alabama say they understand him perfectly — now.

Ask Betty Yancey what she would tell someone thinking about trusting money to Bowdoin, and she offers one word of advice.

"Run."

• • •

Quincy was once a wealthy place, thanks to caffeine and nicotine.

Nearly a century ago, a shrewd local banker advised his clients to buy Coca-Cola stock, and many did. Outside of town, farmers raised tobacco for cigar factories in Ybor City.

But over the years the Coca-Cola wealth dissipated as it passed from generation to generation. The tobacco farms died off. In 1982, Wal-Mart opened its first store in Florida in Quincy. The downtown dried up.

Quincy needed a new stimulant. Along came AdSurfDaily.

At first, Pastor Wells saw more cars on Jefferson Street and more people on the sidewalk.

"We noticed that before we ever knew anything about Ad Surf," he said. "It just seemed like there was more people and more life."

At the Gadsden County Chamber of Commerce, executive director David Gardner heard of visitors from all over the world checking into motels out by Interstate 10.

Both investigated and found themselves at a white wood-frame house with three rocking chairs on the front porch.

It once was Faye's Florist. Now it was AdSurfDaily. In charge was Bowdoin, Faye's folksy and soft-spoken husband. And tens of millions of dollars were coming in the door.

"It's so amazing how all this happened right here," Gardner says. "There was a tremendous buzz in the community: 'What the heck was going on?' "

The talk didn't stop at the city limits. On the Web and at huge rallies, AdSurfDaily attracted about 100,000 customers who authorities say put more than $100-million into the company.

Here's how AdSurfDaily worked: Members could pay to put their Web pages into a rotation of sites viewed by other members. The cost: $1 per view.

Members also could earn cash rebates by viewing up to 24 other members' Web sites for 15 seconds each every day. And they could earn commissions for bringing in new members.

The company says it explicitly told members it was not an investment, nor did it promise any rate of return.

But the company's marketing had a different tone. In a video, according to court records, Bowdoin described AdSurfDaily as an "income-earning opportunity." The company called its ad-surfing program the "Cash Generator." And it had a Spanish Web site called La Fuente de Dinero (The Fountain of Money).

Federal investigators say AdSurfDaily led people to believe they could earn 125 percent of their membership fees as rebates, plus commissions for referrals.

Early members were paid with money from later ones, authorities said, and the scheme was doomed to collapse once the supply of new investors was exhausted.

Bowdoin incorporated AdSurfDaily in 2006. This year a series of huge rallies in Miami, Las Vegas, Chicago and Tampa fueled the company's explosive growth.

The Tampa rally took place in June at the Marriott Waterside.

It began with a Thursday night social. Wearing a polo shirt and jeans, Bowdoin mingled as members noshed on fresh fruit, cake, pastry, cheese and coffee.

That in itself was remarkable, said AdSurfDaily member Charmaine Tincher, a veteran of many seminars during her 18 years in home-based businesses.

"Most of the time when you're in any kind of business like that, the only time you see the corporate people is when they're up on stage," said Tincher, 55, of Port Charlotte.

What followed, she said, were half-day programs on Friday and Saturday where Bowdoin and others shared tips on marketing, planning, setting goals and being disciplined.

Tincher said the sales pitch was not high-pressure.

But a lot of selling took place.

The Tampa rally cost $237,482 to stage, according to court records, and rang up $29.1-million in sales.

That was not unusual.

The Miami rally drew 2,530 registrations and $39.2-million in sales. The Chicago rally brought in 4,100 people and more than $27.4-million.

"My goal is to make 100,000 millionaires in the next three years," Bowdoin told a cheering crowd in an online video from the Las Vegas rally.

• • •

His company booming, Bowdoin went shopping.

In July, AdSurfDaily paid $830,000 for the tallest building in downtown Quincy, the four-story Masonic temple.

"Andy comes across as being a really nice guy," Gardner said. "He really did want to make a commitment to this community with regard to the music theater and the art center."

Using AdSurfDaily funds, authorities say, Bowdoin also purchased a $695,000 waterfront home on Lake Talquin south of Quincy, plus a condominium in Myrtle Beach, S.C.

And investigators say Bowdoin used more company funds to buy $51,000 worth of jewelry in a single day.

That's more than what Bowdoin still owes investors on a previous business venture that went sour.

In Alabama, where he was successfully prosecuted in the mid 1990s, Bowdoin owes investors more than $46,000 in court-ordered restitution, according to court records.

Bowdoin told the Times he ran into trouble in Alabama because his company, Mobile International, sought to raise $1-million through a stock issue, and someone was improperly paid a commission to sell the stock.

"That nullified the registrations that our attorney had done with the state of Alabama," he said.

Prosecutors and investors paint a different picture.

The phone system was not delivered as promised, officials said, nor did the company tell new investors it was being sued by earlier investors. Plus it used money from its later backers to pay off the earlier claims. ("That was never the case," Bowdoin told the Times.)

Glen and Betty Yancey said they and their four sons invested a total of $454,000 in Mobile International and lost it all.

"We ended up selling a family farm" to invest, said Mrs. Yancey, 78, a retired gym teacher. "This was just too good to be true."

But Mobile International used investors' money to lease "lavish" offices in Atlanta, give Bowdoin and four other company executives large salaries, bonuses and generous expense accounts, as well as get a Mercedes and a Lincoln Continental as company cars, according to a lawsuit the Yanceys filed.

Bowdoin was charged with 89 counts of securities violations in four counties. After his arrest, he told authorities he had been borrowing from friends to get by.

To settle the cases, Bowdoin pleaded guilty to three counts, entered a pretrial diversion program in one county, was placed on five years' probation in a second and agreed to pay a total of $95,000 in restitution. (Other co-defendants also agreed to pay restitution.) He also was banned from selling securities in Alabama.

Bowdoin's latest restitution check arrived at the Wilcox County courthouse on Aug. 27.

It was for $100.

• • •

In an online video, Bowdoin has portrayed himself as a successful entrepreneur with a 45-year career in sales.

He does not mention his trouble in Alabama. At the Miami rally, a speaker said the only blemish on Bowdoin's record was a speeding ticket, according to court records.

That's not the only fact the company withheld, officials say.

Promoters have boasted President Bush gave Bowdoin a "Medal of Distinction" in recognition of his business success. In fact, investigators said, the National Republican Congressional Committee gave him the award after he made a substantial contribution to the GOP.

In the video, Bowdoin describes building up companies in dry-cleaning, pay phones, cellular telephones and global-satellite positioning technology.

JoAnn Kennedy said she heard about some of those ventures, plus a stint Bowdoin served as mayor in his hometown of Perry, during their marriage from 1985 to 1996.

While she held down a job as chief clerk for the Norfolk Southern Railroad, he pursued "all kinds of multilevel-type things."

"He was going from one thing to another," said Kennedy, 69, now retired. "One of them was vitamins. ... All of them were failures as far as I was concerned."

When the marriage ended — she left him after his arrest in Alabama — he owed her money, according to Georgia court records. She said he used savings she brought into the marriage for one of his businesses, not the home they planned to buy, and lost it.

Kennedy got a judgment for the money in the divorce but he has not paid. With interest, she said, he owes her $162,189.

Federal prosecutors say Bowdoin appears to have earned no significant income from "legal employment" in the 20 years before starting AdSurfDaily.

One of his neighbors in Quincy said Bowdoin borrowed $3,000 from him for a GPS company selling trackers for vehicles, office equipment, even children.

Retired Marine Corps Master Sgt. Bill Allen, 85, said Bowdoin talked about the company's potential to generate tens of millions of dollars. But after a few months, Allen decided he wanted his $3,000 back.

He got it, but it took a while. When he first asked, Bowdoin told him the company wasn't doing as well as expected. So Allen turned up the pressure. He said he borrowed the $3,000, and his creditor was demanding the money.

"You think maybe I could call him and tell him what the problem is?" Bowdoin asked.

Asked about Allen's account, Bowdoin declined to comment.

• • •

After the raid by the Secret Service, many AdSurfDaily members howled in outrage.

Some described getting healthy rebates, and many said the company brought new customers to their Web sites. The only stealing, they said, was done by the government.

More than 3,000 sent in e-mails of support. The testimonials came from all over: Florida, Hawaii, Ontario, Connecticut, Wisconsin, North Carolina.

In Quincy, Mayor Andy Gay feels sorry for the 80 employees who lost their jobs. But if the company was doing something illegal, he said, "I'm glad they got caught."

"I can tell you what," says Gay, who met with Bowdoin after hearing the company might leave town. "Before I stick my neck out there again, I'll investigate real good who's doing business in Quincy."

Pastor Bob Wells hopes to see AdSurfDaily resume business, and not just because it brought jobs to town.

Two weeks before the raid, Wells and his wife cashed in her retirement fund and put the proceeds in AdSurfDaily.

Bowdoin seemed like a down-to-earth straight-shooter.

"I'm a pretty good discerner of people just from being where I've been," said Wells, who runs a drug and alcohol rehabilitation program.

Since the raid, Wells has spoken to Faye Bowdoin, who has roots in Quincy and is better-known around town than her husband. She told him she wakes up at night thinking about all the people who have been hurt.

Now AdSurfDaily is waiting to hear whether a federal judge will let it resume business under the supervision of a court-approved monitor. In its request, the company offered this concession: Andy Bowdoin would not be an employee, officer or director of the company.

In the meantime, Wells said the Wednesday prayer circle has added to its list of community concerns.

It has begun praying for Faye and Andy Bowdoin.

Times researcher John Martin and online business editor Becky Bowers contributed to this report.


How AdSurfDaily worked

According to the company

• Members buy advertisements on the Internet for $1 for each guaranteed hit. Each ad puts a member's Web site into a rotation of ads viewed by other members. The page advertised could be anything from a corporate Web site to a MySpace page.

• Members earned rebates by taking up to six minutes a day to view other members' pages online. If they viewed the required number of pages, they could receive daily payouts equal to 1 percent of the amount they put in until they received 125 percent of the initial purchase price. But those payouts were contingent on revenue. If no revenue came in on a given day, no rebate would be paid.

• Members also could earn commissions by referring new members to the company.

According to the government

• This business was about investing, not advertising.

• Virtually the only source of revenue was from members' fees.

• Once the supply of members was exhausted, the business would collapse. Thus, it was a Ponzi scheme, and the last members in would lose their money.


[Last modified: Oct 23, 2008 07:44 PM]



Comments on this article
by Mary Oct 23, 2008 7:44 PM
I was wrong. After reading the story again, the author is completely correct and accurate in his portrayal of ASD. Andy Bowdoin was definitely continuing his previous con artist antics. Anyone with a grain of intelligence can determine that fact.
by Mary Oct 23, 2008 5:28 PM
A follow up to my other comment..my friend read this and took it word for word and then told me that Andy is a BAD MAN; that it doesn't look good for ASD. This writer is slandering Mr. Bowdoin and ASD. A front page retraction is called for here!
by Mary Oct 23, 2008 5:27 PM
I read this article and the posted comments; I have to say that the article is not completely accurate which gives the readers, especially the ones who do not know the facts, the wrong impression. This is bad reporting! It should be corrected.
by Mary Oct 21, 2008 7:35 PM
I agree with Jack and John. Patrick Pretty has thoroughly studied ASD and his objective analysis is right on the mark. ASD members are the LEAST objective. I'm 100% convinced that Andy Bowdoin was continuing his previous con artist antics with ASD.
by Jack Oct 21, 2008 7:35 PM
ASD members who cry business bankruptcy because ONE ad venue closed (ASD) is like a father who says his family is starving to death because the corner store closed. Attention Mr Father: THERE'S OTHER FOOD STORES IN THE AREA!
by Mark Oct 21, 2008 4:25 PM
ASD did for people in 2 months more than any government or other institution has done in a life time!!! ASD also showed the new way to advertise. This is the new way!!! Deal with it newspapers, magazines, television...times have changed!
by Ty Oct 21, 2008 4:20 PM
I read Patrick Pretty and thoroughly studied his ASD viewpoint. His analysis is interesting, but used exaggerated figures to punctuate his points. I posted opposite examples from my group. Patrick replied, evidently compelled to defend himself.
by Susan Oct 21, 2008 4:19 PM
I can only reply with my experience with ASD. All I was promised happened until the AG stole the money, computers and shut the office down. "All in the name of protecting me using the "Patriot Act". AG needs to leave us the hell alone.
by Tom Oct 21, 2008 4:19 PM
What is the AG doing about Investment Firms stealing billions of dollars from Investors? I can think of a few companies that wrote the book about Ponzi & ruining people & their lives! We need ASD back online to give members a chance to advertise.
by Mark Oct 21, 2008 4:18 PM
ASD has changed the way advertising is done. It sure scares worthless newspaper ads, expensive TV commercials nearly nobody watches etc...Besides ASD has done for people in 2 months more then governments and other institutions have done in alife time
by Ka'iu Oct 21, 2008 4:17 PM
I say leave it up to the individual. If they don't do the due diligence, they'll lose everything. Either way, why does anyone have to step in? I'm tired of the gov't pretending they're looking out for "our" best interest. If I lose the $, my bad!
by Martha Oct 21, 2008 4:17 PM
Barb (first comment) should explain to the rest of why tens of thousands of people are "hurting" because one ad selling venue has closed. As for money back, you GAVE that money to Andy and it was HIS after 3 days, per the terms you agree to. Right?
by Attique Oct 21, 2008 4:12 PM
I have met Andy Bowdoin twice and if you ask me if he is a scam?absolutely not.Is he perfect ?absolutley not.Is he a failure ?absolutely not ,to me he is a winner because be never quit despite his past failures and kept going at the age of 74.
by John Oct 21, 2008 2:42 PM
Shame on John Martin & the the St Pete Times. Rather than go after the REAL crooks who put this entire country at risk - you attack a business that has helped over 100,000 people. Looking for a 'ponzi'? Then look at Social Security!
by jian Oct 21, 2008 2:32 PM
already got so many copy cat out there, who took ASD or Goldenpanda's member doing same business in a differnt title, is interesting, isn't it? ASD member, ASD model, ASD name, different CEO.
by Attique Oct 21, 2008 2:14 PM
ASD provided great benefits of social web advertising.In few months with ASD my web site saw increased traffic,sales & more affiliate sign ups.Everyone is an advertiser and also becomes a customer.You learned about other's businesses and products.--
by Martha Oct 21, 2008 2:10 PM
Jean is ASDelusional. The judge has NOT released $2 million to ASD. Head out of the sand, girl. Try to keep up.....
by Deb Oct 21, 2008 10:30 AM
I spent my ad dollars with ASD which gave more exposure on my site and increased sales. A newspaper ad never did that. The government doesn't need to protect me from myself. I want ASD back. Hey, AG, I bought a lotto ticket today and got nothing!!!!
by Jenny Oct 21, 2008 10:30 AM
Our law class in Florida has been following this ASD case with much interest. We debated the merits weeks ago and unanimously decided that ASD is an illegal company and should not be allowed to reopen.
by Rocco Oct 21, 2008 10:30 AM
It comes down to this and only this. Is ASD a legal Business or not? No more to say...
by John Oct 20, 2008 8:56 PM
I agree with Jack. Patrick Pretty has thoroughly studied this ASD situation from an objective viewpoint. His analysis is brilliant and it leaves me totally convinced that ASD was operating illegally and should not be allowed to operate again.
by epale Oct 20, 2008 8:55 PM
I can't help but read this and think about our government bailing out AIG and others AIG is still holding lavish parties at the most expensive hotels in the world,corporate CEOs are taking millions in payoffs,etcwhat is the difference? they are free!
by Jack Oct 20, 2008 8:01 PM
Patrick Pretty's blog explains why ASD is a Ponzi. The AG should be praised for his efforts against ASD.
by Tom Oct 20, 2008 7:55 PM
The Gov should know what a Ponzi is. They've been running our social security like a Ponzi scheme for years now.
by Mike Oct 20, 2008 7:53 PM
Hi Barb & Steve.. I agree. We need ASD back online to give google a run for their advertising dollar. Yo Richard (the writer), why not do a story on Google and see where their millions$$ went to? Swimming pools, in-house million $$ amenities, jets et
by Arthur Oct 20, 2008 6:26 PM
We need Andy and ASD back in business now as good people are being destroyed. Why doesn't the AG go after the Investment Company execuitives that have stolen billions of dollars from the Investors and our country.
by TW Oct 20, 2008 6:19 PM
It's good that the AG is doing his job and bringing Ponzi schemes to justice! But bad that he doesn't understand ASD.
by John Oct 20, 2008 6:08 PM
Thank God that the AG is doing his job and bringing Ponzi schemes to justice!
by Ty Oct 20, 2008 5:21 PM
Re: my comment moments ago - rebates coming largely from MEMBERS' FEES (now proven false) was a vital componeent of the Fed's "Ponzi theory" premise!
by Dan Oct 20, 2008 10:28 AM
This paper Has No idea what they are talking about.
by Brad Oct 20, 2008 10:16 AM
Here come the ASD supporters, like Robert, threatening lawsuits against anybody who says anything bad against ASD. When Judge Collyer eventually rules against ASD, these threats will hopefully disappear.
by Robert Oct 20, 2008 9:55 AM
This paper better be ready to print a retraction!! Im sure papers like this and the national enquirer are used to law suits....get ready Tampa
by ken Oct 20, 2008 9:54 AM
i guess those prayers of yours didn't work too well....
by Pete Oct 20, 2008 9:54 AM
Richard, very nice article, as balanced as possible. The math proves that it's not sustainable and later "advertisers" would not be able to recoup their "purchases" through the rebates. The rebates were the reason that most people joined.
by Marty Oct 20, 2008 9:54 AM
Many members have said that over the past few months "if the government could hear ANDY explain the business model" they'd understand it. I doubt Andy will take the witness stand, with "character" witness like this ready to testify, don't you???
Subscribe to the Times
Click here for daily delivery
of the St. Petersburg Times.

Email Newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

 
ADVERTISEMENT