Make us your home page

'Cash for clunkers' law has catches

After President Barack Obama signed the Car Allowance Rebate System into effect — it's commonly called the "cash for clunkers" law — he set the wheels in motion for one of two things to happen, depending on whom you talk to: The law is either a needed shot in the arm for the retail auto industry, or a boondoggle that will cost taxpayers millions.

There is one thing no one can dispute: There is bound to be confusion. Example: To qualify for a $3,500 or $4,500 taxpayer-financed "voucher" to apply to the cost of a new vehicle, your old car must be EPA-rated at an overall 18 miles per gallon or less. Supposing your "clunker" is a 1987 Chevrolet Caprice: That vehicle was available with four different engines and two different transmissions. A Caprice with a 4.3-liter V-6 and a three-speed automatic transmission is rated at 18 mpg, so it qualifies. If the car has the same engine and a four-speed automatic transmission, it is rated at 19 mpg, and doesn't. If it has a 305-cubic-inch V-8 engine, it qualifies. If the V-8 engine is 307 cubic inches, it doesn't.

According to the automotive information Web site, a 1987 Chevrolet Caprice with the V-6 engine in average condition is worth about $149 in trade-in value. If that car has the three-speed automatic transmission, it is eligible for as much as $4,500 toward a new car. With the four-speed transmission, it's worth $149.

Some early versions of the law made provisions for two details that many legislators thought were important: The vouchers would also work toward trading your vehicle in on a gas-sipping used car, and the vouchers would apply only to vehicles traded in on a made-in-America car. Neither of those provisions made the final draft.

By applying the law only to new vehicles, critics argue that financially strapped buyers will be tempted to buy a new vehicle even though they can only afford a used one. And used-car dealers argue that the market for 1- or 2-year-old used vehicles could plummet, since there will be a $3,500 or $4,500 cash incentive to buy a new vehicle, and no incentive to buy a used one.

And by making the law apply to imported vehicles as well as domestics, other critics argue that a central point of the measure — to keep American factories working — has been compromised.

Predicting the ultimate impact of the new law is difficult; some analysts expect a minor bump in sales, while others are more optimistic.

"Our recent estimates indicate nearly 1 million additional vehicles would be sold in the U.S. in 2009," said Lonnie Miller, director of industry analysis for R.L. Polk and Co., an industry data provider. If true, that would represent a 10 percent boost in overall sales.

Others are less optimistic. "Similar legislation has seen success in Europe because European new vehicle buyers keep their vehicle considerably longer than those in the U.S.," said Jeremy Anwyl, chief executive of "But in the end, this is a nonevent. Even 250,000 new vehicles' sales will not provide the impact needed for an industry looking for at least 5 million in additional sales."

"It's a very poorly conceived piece of legislation that will neither significantly reduce our country's carbon footprint nor do anything to substantially spur new car sales," said editor Karl Brauer. "The only thing more ineffective than this bill is the government's response to sagging car sales, which are really taking their toll on the overall economy."

The law is good from July 1 to Nov. 1, through the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which will carry out the measure. If the $950 million appropriated for the program runs out before Nov. 1, the program would end prematurely unless extended by law.

For a relatively small percentage of the buying public that owns an appropriate clunker and needs a new car — and has the means to pay for it — the "cash for clunkers" law could be the answer to a prayer.

For the rest of us — yawn.

'Cash for clunkers' law has catches 07/30/09 [Last modified: Thursday, July 30, 2009 5:01pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Orlando Sentinel.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Road to Nowhere' is back: Next phase of Suncoast Parkway coming


    Despite intense public opposition and dubious traffic projections, the Florida Department of Transportation has announced that construction of the toll road known as "Suncoast 2" is expected to start in early 2018.

    The Suncoast Parkway ends at U.S. 98 just south of Citrus County. For years residents have opposed extending the toll road, a project dubbed the "Suncoast 2" into Citrus County. But state officials recently announced that the Suncoast 2 should start construction in early 2018. [Stephen J. Coddington  |  TIMES]
  2. A sports rout on Wall Street


    NEW YORK — Sporting goods retailers can't shake their losing streak.

  3. Grocery chain Aldi hosting hiring event in Brandon Aug. 24


    BRANDON — German grocery chain Aldi is holding a hiring event for its Brandon store Aug. 24. It is looking to fill store associate, shift manager and manager trainee positions.

  4. Lightning owner Jeff Vinik backs film company pursuing global blockbusters


    TAMPA — Jeff Vinik's latest investment might be coming to a theater near you.

    Jeff Vinik, Tampa Bay Lightning owner, invested in a new movie company looking to appeal to a global audience. | [Times file photo]
  5. Trigaux: Look to new Inc. 5000 rankings for Tampa Bay's future heavyweights


    There's a whole lotta fast-growing private companies here in Tampa Bay. Odds are good you have not heard of most of them.


    Kyle Taylor, CEO and founder of The Penny Hoarder, fills a glass for his employees this past Wednesday as the young St. Petersburg personal advice business celebrates its landing at No. 25 on the 2017 Inc. 5000 list of the fastest growing private companies in the country. Taylor, still in his 20s, wins kudos from executive editor Alexis Grant for keeping the firm's culture innovative. The business ranked No. 32 last year. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]