Make us your home page

Citizens backs off controversial home evaluation plan

Citizens Property Insurance customers now have a lot more options for calculating what it would cost to rebuild their homes in the event of a hurricane.

After public outcry and media scrutiny, Citizens backed off late Friday from sole use of a controversial software program to calculate home replacement costs, a process that some critics called a back-door way to raise homeowners' rates.

Instead, the state-run company, by far the biggest property insurer in Florida, said it will now accept a range of alternatives, including outside appraisals, for estimating the cost of rebuilding homes damaged in a hurricane.

"We believe that providing these options gives our policyholders and agents more confidence in the valuation process while providing policyholders with adequate protection for their homes," Scott Wallace, Citizens' president, CEO and executive director, said in a statement.

In a story on Sunday, the Tampa Bay Times documented cases where homeowners were battling Citizens over estimates that valued their properties not only far above market value, but also far higher than what independent appraisers said it would cost to rebuild. Higher valuations can translate into higher rates.

One such homeowner, Ruth Lauro of New Port Richey, lives in a two-bedroom house worth little more than the $33,500 she and her husband paid for it in 1979. Yet, Citizens' software model estimated it would cost $124,000 to replace the home.

Homeowners, appraisers and others accused Citizens of using higher replacement costs to circumvent rate caps. As insurer of last resort, Citizens' policy count has swelled to nearly 1.5 million as it assumes high-risk policies that large private insurers refuse to cover. At the same time, it has been under political pressure to raise its rates as aggressively as possible to shield Floridians from a massive bailout after a major hurricane.

Sen. Mike Fasano, R-New Port Richey, one of Citizens' chief critics, said the insurer's reversal shows consumers can come out ahead in the long run.

"It's great to hear that if you do pursue and do battle against what you think is wrong, the people do come out winning once in a while," Fasano said when told of Citizens' decision.

Problems date back to late 2010, when Citizens began using a software program called 360Value to calculate replacement costs. Late last year, Citizens tightened its program further, telling agents to rely solely on 360Value and not accept alternative appraisals given by homeowners.

But as complaints continued to rise, the agency decided to review the program, authorizing contractors this month to reinspect a sampling of homes in Tampa Bay and south Florida which had used the 360 evaluation.

Under its revised plan, the methods that Citizens will now accept to calculate replacement costs include:

• Estimates generated by its current vendor, 360Value, along with two other companies with similar software: MSB and e2Value;

• An insurance reconstruction cost valuation prepared by a licensed appraiser that is specifically formulated to establish the insurance reconstruction cost rather than market value;

• Estimates prepared by licensed general contractors, architects or engineers that include a contract price for reconstruction cost and an itemized list of the home's features.

•A property inspection report dated within the past 12 months that was ordered by another insurer and includes a reconstruction cost estimate.

It was not immediately clear how homeowners who believe an earlier estimate was wrong can retroactively use an alternate appraisal or if policyholders will be reimbursed for premiums based on the earlier, higher replacement estimates.

Jeff Harrington can be reached at or (727) 893-8242.

Citizens backs off controversial home evaluation plan 01/20/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, January 25, 2012 12:20pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Who's best global airline? Qatar Airways takes No. 1 spot but Delta tops U.S. carriers


    The good news? Delta Airlines tops all U.S. airlines in a new Skytrax global airline passenger satisfaction survey of the world's best airlines. The bad news? At No. 32, Delta still ranks behind dozens of Middle East, Asian and some European airlines. For Tampa International Airport and the major airlines that operate …

    Southwest Airlines, the biggest carrier at Tampa International Airport, improved its customer satisfaction rating among global airlines in a recent survey.
[Times file photo]
  2. Vinoy resort will ask St. Petersburg voters to approve new parking garage (with tennis courts on top)

    Local Government

    ST. PETERSBURG — The Vinoy Renaissance St. Petersburg Resort & Golf Club is undergoing a $50 million redevelopment and part of that plan calls for building a new one-story parking garage over eight existing tennis courts.

    The Vinoy Renaissance Resort and Golf Club is undergoing a $50 million redevelopment. The Vinoy wants to build a one-story parking garage as part of that project, in place of eight existing tennis courts. The tennis courts would be moved on top of the garage, which would hold 270 parking spots. But the Vinoy needs St. Petersburg voters to approve the project in a November referendum. This is an artists' rendering of the new garage from the street. [Courtesy of Vinoy Renaissance Resort and Golf Club]
  3. House committee passes Florida-sponsored flood insurance bill


    The House Financial Services Committee pushed through a Florida-sponsored bill intended to cut flood insurance costs. If passed, the bipartisan bill would help create a marketplace for private flood insurance.

    A House committee passed a Florida-sponsored bill meant to lower flood insurance rates.
[Times file photo]
  4. 3 new restaurants open: Deccan Spice Indian food, Farmacy Vegan Kitchen, the Cake Shop

    Food & Dining


    Deccan Spice has opened at 2325 Ulmerton Road, in what used to be the elegant and vast Grand Siam space in Feather Sound. It's getting high marks so far for its traditional Indian lunch buffet, and offers a range of southern Indian dishes (vadas and dosas and idlis, oh my) seldom seen …

    Farmacy Vegan Kitchen + Bakery serves wraps, acai bowls, smoothies and juices and plant-based baked goods like strawberry cupcakes. Photo courtesy of Charles Rumph.
  5. The driver who died in a Tesla crash in Florida using Autopilot ignored 7 safety warnings


    When Joshua Brown's Tesla slammed into the side of a tractor-trailer last year at more than 70 miles per hour, the fatal accident became the world's first known car crash involving a partly autonomous vehicle.

    Tesla requires its drivers to keep their hands on the wheel even when Autopilot is engaged. A crash in Florida showed that the driver was warned to keep his hands on the steering wheel.  (AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez) TXTG101